80°
Submitted by super_luigi16 631d ago | opinion piece

Sakurai v. Nintendo: The Old Franchise Problem

Did Masahiro Sakurai, director of the entire Super Smash Bros. franchise, just diss Mario, Zelda, and Pokémon?

In his weekly Famitsu column, Sakurai described his role at TGS, complaining that he had very little time to actually judge the games by playing them; rather, he and the other judges could only watch. The Game Designers’ Award is considered one of the most prestigious rewards given out at TGS, and Sakurai said that he wanted to give the reward to an original, indie-esque game rather than a heavily-milked AAA-title. Translated by various sources, Sakurai wrote the following... (3DS, Nintendo, Super Smash Bros., Wii U)

lilbroRx  +   631d ago
There is no problem with old franchises. People are trying to make them into a problem, though, because they resent the success Nintendo has with them.

I never see anyone minimalizing the success GTA,Gran Turismo, God of War, or Halo for being old franchises. Its always just Nintendo.

This article takes what Sakurai said and spins it far out of context.
Tiqila  +   631d ago
I have not read the article, but if there is a problem with old nintendo franchises (maybe because of a lack of innovation or sth.) that would also apply to God of War and Halo.
daftpunkfan  +   631d ago
God of War and Halo are both just as guilty of this. No one here is denying that, and it's often pointed out in reviews and discussions.

I just don't think that excuses Nintendo from sticking to the same franchises they introduced in the late 1900s.
D_RoyJenkins  +   631d ago
None of those franchises you mentioned have been milked as much as Mario, Zelda, Pokemon.
3-4-5  +   631d ago
* They need NEW IP with that Nintendo Art Style.

* Nintendo, give us some cool new ip that is a mixture between Mario 64 + RPG + Wind Waker = awesome.

Maybe a future setting, maybe a unique creative setting, but give us something else please.

I love Nintendo's characters, but most of them are from the late 80's/ early 90's.
Tiqila  +   631d ago
YES PLEASE! that would be awesome.
lilbroRx  +   631d ago
Nintendo releases new I.P. every year. People just ignore them.

Just this year alone, they released the Wonderful 101, Dillon's Rolling Western, and Crashmo. There were few others in there as well.
daftpunkfan  +   631d ago
I don't resent the "success" Nintendo has with old franchises. I entirely believe that after several decades with them, it's time to get into some new territory.

I also think that the games you mentioned are guilty of this.
scissor_runner  +   631d ago
Problem is a square doesnt fit into a triangle no matter how hard you push.
There hasn't been a 3d 4 player mario game, a mario kart that had as much short cutting or such lush graphics, or a smash bros that adds some thing new... yet there has been a big problem with japanese anime influencing their games.
D_RoyJenkins  +   631d ago
Wrong post
#3 (Edited 631d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
OhReginald  +   631d ago
Just give me a new metroid game nintendo and I will forgive you. Cause right now you are really a sinking ship to me at this point.
lilbroRx  +   631d ago
There sales just exploded over the last two weeks and they are sinking?
Dunban67  +   631d ago
Their sales predictably went up - no one thought they would do otherwise- they will continue to go p thru the holidays at least- having said that- Wii U sales are still very low and the Wii U is still not selling on a pace to reach close to 9 million for Nintendo s fiscal year- so the Wii U is still a sinking ship- the question is- will the upcoming sales be great enough to reverse this trend
just wait until early 2014-e3. (1.new shigeru miyamoto game, 2. X from monolith soft
3.super smash bros wii u 4. the legend of zelda wii u 5.mario kart 8) and this is just the stuff we know about.
daftpunkfan  +   631d ago
Three of those are exactly what the article is talking about (milked Nintendo franchises) and the other is in danger of the same (the Xeno series).
The only reason nintendo can't focus on creating new ip's is because of horrible 3rd party support. nintendo doesn't have the luxury of creating new first party games that might not sell there system. unlike sony& microsoft, nintendo can't fall back on the blind faith of 3rd party developers & a steady stream of games until they release the there first party titles.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

Yoshi's Woolly World Is Like Every Other Nintendo Game, And That's Not A Bad Thing

39m ago - Yoshi's Woolly World might look and play like every other Nintendo game...but that not necessaril... | Wii U
40°

Fugitive Games holding Reddit AMA today @ 4.00pm PST for Into the Stars

46m ago - From GameWatcher: "We're a stone's throw from the Early Access release of Into the Stars from Fug... | PC
Ad

An Interview with Jeremy Dunham

Now - Jeremy Dunham of Psyonix talks about design choices, importance of player feedback, DLC, and the most important thing to master in Rocket League. | Promoted post
30°

Defect: Spaceship Destruction Kit Preview | Entertainment Buddha

46m ago - EB: It’s a steep learning curve to get your spacecraft to work for you, but the satisfaction the... | PC
40°

Here's Why You Need to Play Battleblock Theater

47m ago - Geraint at GameSpew.com writes: "From The Behemoth, creators of Alien Hominid and Castle Crashers... | PC
30°

Sid Meier's Civilization Beyond Earth: Rising Tide Interview (GameWatcher)

47m ago - GameWatcher: "We sit down with Firaxis games to chat about the lengthily titled Sid Meier's Civil... | PC