Try our new beta!Click here
Submitted by mephman 873d ago | opinion piece

GTA V's Torture Scene Is Entirely Justifiable

Gaming Union: "It’s that time of the year again, when a Grand Theft Auto title releases and everyone with a soap box and some sort of grudge against the industry declares whether games are (or are not) art and what elements of the medium should (or should not) be allowed. Raising questions into the integrity of the entertainment sector is commonplace, but gaming offers a unique perspective that a book or film cannot. Making a player partake in an intense, if questionable, moment is a unique way to deliver narrative; and when the subject in question is rape, torture, or murder it’s understandable why a few ethical questions would be raised." (Grand Theft Auto V, PS3, Xbox 360)

fozzness  +   873d ago
Completely agree. And great comparison with Heavy Rain... hated doing those freaking trials... also hated having to control the villain upon replaying it.... but alas, that's part of the game *shrug*
Scrivlar  +   873d ago
I felt very uncomfortable with the torture scene but much like the cut scene with Floyd and his Girlfriend , They reminded me that Trevor is a very dangerous maniac and sadistic murderer. I think it's important to remember that otherwise it doesn't do the character justice.
Pintheshadows  +   873d ago
I think the whole point is that you feel uncomfortable. It shows just how violent and depraved Trevor is. He enjoys this kind of thing and whilst he could refuse or find another out he doesn't.
Sanrin  +   873d ago
Exactly. You're not meant to be comfortable with his level of depravity, although if you are perhaps...that's something to be concerned with?
Scrivlar  +   873d ago
People saying Heavy Rain was worse are wrong in my opinion. You were doing it to yourself but with Trevor you were torturing an innocent terrified man when you knew he would've told you anyway, it was torture for the sake of torture. If the guy was a terrorist and the mission was to torture him for ways to stop a bomb I wouldn't have given a shit.
titletownrelo  +   873d ago
well said man
#3.1 (Edited 873d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Beatbuddy: ON Tour Review (Invision Community)

5h ago - Experience a fast paced action game set in the Beatbuddy universe! Help Beatbuddy to play aweso... | PC

Vertigo Void Review (Invision Community)

5h ago - Introducing Vertigo Void, a game by developers James de Silva and Matthew Sanders that takes the... | PC

Gran Turismo SPORT Beta Testing Begins early 2016

Now - Start tracking GTS with's release date alert service and be notified when the GTS beta launches. | Promoted post

#52Games52Weeks 5 – Nubla (AKA The Worst Game on PS4)

5h ago - Psgamer: Nubla turns this debate on its head asks the exact opposite question – Can art be made i... | PS4

The Witness Review - You Might Want to See This | Entertainium

5h ago - "If Braid was the little kid in class who loved to draw beautiful pictures but was cleverly obnox... | PC

A Fanboy's Look Back at the Entire Street Fighter Series

5h ago - One fan's nostalgic trip down memory lane at the legacy of the Street Fighter series and how he r... | Culture