GameFront: "A Youtuber has made a pretty big claim: that Treyarch “stole” (as in stole your bike, your phone; thievery) some art concepts and the overall design for a map titled “Origins,” part of Black Ops 2′s upcoming Apocalypse DLC."
those are eerily similar.
I don't think there is enough of a similarity to pursue legal action though. It would be easy to argue that everything is derivative, and that the original Francsico Fruiz robot looks like The Iron Giant, or that the game robot was more similar to Gort (The Day the Earth Stood Still). I'm not saying that there aren't similarities, but look at this: http://fc09.deviantart.net/... That's a random DeviantArt picture. People, especially the Japanese, have been doing this same sort of thing for a long, long time. The images ARE very similar, and the image could have very well been ripped off, but it'll be hard as hell to prove. If it was stolen, though, this guy deserves justice.
The problem is that everything is conjecture at best. You google WW1 fighter plane? You see planes like in that video / picture. You have a war? Then you're bound to have trenches (these are hardly unique to even the CoD series) You google WW1 tanks? You see tanks like in the picture / video. As you mentioned the robots resemble other robots from the past and it's not like we're talking about unique designs here (like a Gundam for instance). It's extremely difficult / impossible to win or even make a case when we're talking about planes / tanks designed to look like the same thing. I am also willing to bet there are a number of other artists / pictures throughout the years that could make an equally valid claim and simply share a similar starting point.
All I said is that they're eerily similar. I'm making no claims one way or another.
I'm with the concept artist 110%. It's not just that there's a giant robot. Every other detail is identical, from the trench with the overhang, the tank, the weather, the old-school planes, etc. Just keep in mind that this could all be BS viral marketing also. If they're not 'in on it', the concept artist deserves a kickback beyond a reasonable amount, since they were neither asked or in any other way made aware. If they are in on it, then they're all just laughing all the way to the bank with a fake controversy that you should make sure to 'share, like, comment, tweet, retweet' etc. about.
@admiral The point is all of the elements together, not that you can google pictures of rain or tanks or planes or trenches or giant robots, etc. It's that all of the elements are not only present, but look practically identical in design and layout.
Counter argument I found that they've had this planned since 2008 or prior with World at War zombies map Der Riese ["The Giant" in German]. http://www.youtube.com/watc...
@ Sidology Saying "eerily" similar is the same as "fightingly similar" and in turn strongly implies you believe they're connected. @ EeJLP- You missed my point completely. The DLC is set in WW1, so using WW1 style planes / tanks is not only expected, but logical. Considering that is also the case in the artwork, I wouldn't say the similarities are anything to be shocked about. As far as the layout goes... if you watch enough videos / angles / examine it enough ways it you're bound to find similar looking events. If you're really saying two things set in the same period are obviously related to one another because soldiers are in a trench, one show shows them near a walkway, a tank is on the hill... then I strongly suggest you become a lawyer today.
@EeJLP-: "Counter argument I found that they've had this planned since 2008 or prior with World at War zombies map Der Riese ["The Giant" in German]. " You know what though? The developers who made WarZ also told media that they didn't steal DayZ's ideas and that they had WarZ in mind and have been making it since before DayZ too. Guess what? They clearly fucking lied. Even if they did think of an idea to involve something 'Gigantic' doesn't negate ALL evidence to support the fact that the Theme/Concept/Design/atmospher e Resulted in something that is blatantly similar to the artists' work. You don't just go from "Giant German" and end up with extremely similar results. To say they Never have seen that artwork or that none of them at Treyarch are guilty would be completely ignorant and naive because most evidence points to an uncanny copying in the artists favor.
The carrier multiplayer map on Black Ops 2 looks just like the map on Haze the PS3 game.
Except the one from haze is dynamic....
Maybe so but Haze had very reviews. I guess that's why they never continued with the brand. It was suppose to be competition for Halo. But I think they gave up on it too early.
wow thats scary.Very similar artwork its hard too deny the connection...
If it is indeed stolen... Francisco Fruiz should get a cut from the DLC being sold from Treyarch and Activision! But if it was me, I'd take it to court!
When you cant copy paste... you copy paste
Some one its going to get lots $$$.
And that someone is Bobby Kotick.
very similare they make one small change for the eyes hhhh
They're similar, but thats about it. Quite similar to how the Kerberos soldiers and Helghast could be interchanged without a hassle. However, the Kerberos comparison is a lot more similar than anything being claimed here... In my honest opinion... I think this is just someone (or someones) getting worked up that they see a similarity between two things. Not like a robot in WW1 is something completely unheard of, nor is it really unique enough to claim ownership of.
So this guy drew up a huge oversized robot fighting an army of people, planes and tanks set during the WWI area during terrible conditions and a lightning storm and you think it's merely a coincidence that the level turned out to be EXACTLY as he drew it? If I asked you to dream up a WW2 scenario involving Aliens and I did the same, I guarantee you we would come up with two completely different things. The fact that these are basically identical is what stands out as concerning... there should have been one or two things that ended up being different.
"If I asked you to dream up a WW2 scenario involving Aliens and I did the same, I guarantee you we would come up with two completely different things." Yes, but your logic is horribly flawed. While your example would most likely result in different end results, we're not looking at two people being asked to do the same thing. We're looking at Treyarch doing a picture and someone claiming that they're the same. What is different about this situation? This is just one version out of who knows how many that happened to line up. This sort of thing happens and there are differences. Different eyes, legs look more squared than rounded, head is a different shape, squared joints (original picture has rounded joints) and so forth. Lets also not forget that the blog post from Fruiz was taken down, so it might have just been a ploy to get people talking about the DLC.
Similar art happens all the time in video games, you wanna see some weird similarities, look at THIS http://th05.deviantart.net/...
I still think the Kerberos vs Helghast one is the most similar / interesting. Random pic via google http://i60.photobucket.com/...
I guess that's true, then again the guy on the left Sasuke has a very general look that's seen throughout almost everything in Japanese media from what ive seen.
god i love the inception background music on that youtube video. & also its an automatic loss for the artist if he goes and sue activition, thats alwats the case unfortunately. but if it is true treyach should atleast put "inspired by(artist name) "
This is pretty far of a stretch. It's just a giant robot in a war setting. They could have been inspired by Resistance for all we know, or the Iron Giant, there are heaps of things that could have inspired it. This truly is the definition of coincidence. What does the artist even want credit for? CoD has always been about war, so he just wants credit for coming up with a giant robot? That's pretty original..
You see if that was the other way Activision would sue the f*** out of him
Well I have the season pass and I'm going to play it. Sorry Fruiz.
lol, you bought a COD season pass.
Yeah to the most sold game in history....duh.
lol, you base game quality on sales.
A robot featured in a punked up WW1 setting is not original to begin. The fact that he points out THE typical WW1 tank as evidence of copying is just....meh this isn't even an issue.
Whaaaaaaaat ! Treyarch accused of being un original ?!! I will hear no more of such things, good day to you N4G ! Good day indeed !
Vonderhaar be thinking he's slick and shit, now pay the man for what you stole, A**wipes