140°
Submitted by HAMM3RofBUDDHA 399d ago | opinion piece

Ranking Modern Handheld Gaming Units By Their Sound Capabilities

Rather than ranking the technical merits of some of today’s handheld units to establish a pecking order, Entertainment Buddha would like to rank them based on their sound capabilities. Sound is a key feature in game design, and can add all sorts of depth to a gameplay experience. Without sound, gaming definitely wouldn’t be the multi-sense affecting medium that we all have come to love so dearly.

This applies even more so to the handheld gaming space because devices of this nature don’t sport high-end surround sound systems like consoles. If a mobile gaming device doesn’t boast strong built-in audio capabilities it can definitely tarnish the experience of playing games on the go. Sure headphones can be used to amplify sound on handhelds, but not every gamer wants to pack a pair of high-end cans with them every time they play a mobile game. (3DS, iPad, iPad HD, iPhone, iPhone 5, Mobile, PS Vita, Tag Invalid)

GreenRanger  +   399d ago
I always play handhelds with headphones on, so I never really take any notice of speakers.
Canary  +   398d ago
Probably a good idea. Headphones give better sound quality than any tiny micro-speakers ever will.

...

Personally, I think the original 3DS had the best speakers. The whole "surround" quality really took me by surprise. The XL/LL has surround speakers, too, but the volume is lacking so it's not quite as impressive.

I've gotta say, though, the Vita has terrible speakers. Not so much quality-wise as location-wise. Why Sony decided to put the speakers down low, where they'd be covered up by the average gamers thumbs while using the analog sticks, I'll never know. Maybe they thought they had to change things up from the PSP for the sake of being different? I don't know, but it's a terrible placement that never should have made it past the Vita's initial design face.

Literally the only thing I want in a potential Vita design is better speaker placement. And maybe a matte finish.
TheGamingArt  +   399d ago
I hate saying this, but the Vita's sound output is utter crap when pinned up to the iPhone or iPad...... I can't see it ranking above anything on that list. That's one of the biggest problems I have with my Vita, YOU MUST wear headphones to hear it (especially in a vehicle).
dcj0524  +   399d ago
Yeah. The speakers suck. Can barley hear it.
porkChop  +   399d ago
...? I can hear my Vita perfectly, even when I'm in the car, in my room with my fan on full speed, or at a birthday party where everyone is fairly loud. I only ever use my headphones when I'm lying in bed at night. And the audio quality on my Vita's speakers is great whether I'm listen to music, playing a game, or watching a movie.
TheGamingArt  +   398d ago
Sir, I believe you are deprived of quality speakers and your ears have developed fine tuned follicles that are direct to small sounds. If you pin it side by side with other portable devices, the sound simply does not carry well past other noises.
tubers  +   398d ago
It sounds tin-y near max levels and it doesn't even get that loud.

Not that it directly relates but even PJD series on my PSP 3000 sounds better in speakers than PJD f VITA on speakers.
STK026  +   399d ago
I think, if they ever do a remodel of the Vita, the speakers should be placed elsewhere. I can't speak for everyone, but when I use mine, my thumbs are placed over the speaker grills, which greatly reduces their effectiveness. Placing them under the screen or over the D-pad/4 face buttons would be a major improvement I think.
porkChop  +   399d ago
I think the perfect place for the speakers would be at the bottom edges/corners of the screen. They'd be out of the way and still placed far enough from each other to provide good audio positioning.

Even if they just moved the speakers up directly under the D-Pad/Face Buttons, I think they'd be perfectly fine and out of the way.
Otoshigamisama  +   399d ago
Uhmm why is iphone,ipad,mobile phones considered Handheld gaming systems? I think their pretty much different to gaming only systems
SkullBlade169  +   399d ago
... well, they're handheld and you can play games on them.
IMightBeRetarded  +   399d ago
But I need clickers and knobby things to play my games.
tubers  +   398d ago
@IMightBeRetarded

The younger gen are practically weened with touch screen devices, depends on the game too.
PrimeGrime  +   399d ago
I would say the PS Vita. People say the speakers sound like shit but they also don't realize each game has different sound production for its sound effects and music. The frequencies could be ranging which makes a huge difference in sound. Could be recorded in 44.1khz, 48khz, 96khz, 192khz. Also could have been recorded in a different bitrate 16bit, 24bit so on.

While I do agree some games sound like crap, games like Soul Sacrifice and Dragons Crown sound absently great on the PS Vita.

I do like how effective the left and right are on the PS Vita. Sounds stupid but you can really get a sense of what direction something is coming. They are placed well but I do agree with @STK026, that has happened to me a couple times but since then I have learned not to rest my thumbs like that.

For the most part though I just usually plug it into my monitors or use headphones.
HAMM3RofBUDDHA  +   399d ago
Well said and a point brought up in the article. Sound design on the developer side is key.
admiralvic  +   399d ago
Why in the world would anyone care about sound capabilities?

This is one of the very few things that can be "fixed" with add ons and is honestly a double edge sword. Like I doubt anyone wants to blast the volume so everyone in the car can hear you slicing and dicing enemies and a lot of people end up playing these muted / with headphones on the go.
neogeo  +   399d ago
The HTC-ONE cell phone says hello. The thing has 2 huge
stereo speakers with Dr Dre beats audio. My car radio was broken and that phone fills the car with almost enough sound to make you believe it's a normal stereo. Also the old Sony Phone S10 was insanely loud.
#7 (Edited 399d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
TongkatAli  +   399d ago
From what I heard the Iphone and Ipad have the better speakers then the Vita and 3DS. Confused cause I have heard a lot of shit talking about the two handhelds speakers.
vakarian75  +   399d ago
The speakers on the 3ds are good but in some games like Super Street Fighter 4 the audio in the cutscenes is really bad.
porkChop  +   399d ago
Having used both the 3DS and the Vita, I'd say this article is way off. The 3DS speakers aren't bad, they work well enough and sound decent, but their audio quality is well below that of the Vita. The drivers themselves are much better than the ones in the 3DS with much higher fidelity.

This article isn't really about the sound "capabilities" of the handhelds, it's more about how well developers utilize the speakers. So really, this articles should be about specific games' audio, not the systems.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories

Lords of Xulima - PC Preview | Chalgyr's Game Room

1m ago - Chalgyr's Game Room writes: Lords of Xulima reads like a list of the things I love most about... | PC
40°

Final Fantasy XV: Here are some details on Noctis and His Friends

2m ago - GC - "We have some new details on Noctis and gang." | PS4
20°

First screenshots for WWE 2K15 on Xbox 360 and PS3

2m ago - Amazon have posted screenshots of the PS3 and Xbox 360 versions of WWE 2K15. The screenshots s... | Xbox 360

Sentris - PC Preview | Chalgyr's Game Room

5m ago - Chalgyr's Game Room writes: Guitar Hero, DJ Hero, and Rock Band completely changed the definit... | PC
Ad

Warriors Orochi 3 Ultimate (XB1) Review

Now - Ken mows down massive armies in the latest Musou game. | Promoted post
10°

Curve Digital bringing Nova-111 to PS4, Xbox One, Wii U and Vita in 2015

5m ago - Nova-111 will be coming to PS4, Xbox One, Wii U and Vita, it has been revealed. | PC