330°
Submitted by jcnba28 429d ago | video

Did Sony just Prove The Wii U’s Texture Bandwidth Is Not Slow?

Playeressence - Doctre81 discusses how Sony’s Mark Cerny might have indirectly proved that the Wii U is nowhere near as weak as some developers (EA) are saying. (Mark Cerny, Wii U)

Attached Video
zeal0us  +   429d ago
Well it may not be weak as developers like EA saying it is but I doubt most big name developers will take the time to fully understand how the system works/try to use the system to its full potential.
thorstein  +   429d ago
Wow. Is your avatar two faces or a candlestick holder?
RyuCloudStrife  +   429d ago
That's amazing!!
Dagobert  +   429d ago
I think it's two gay guys about to kiss.
BitbyDeath  +   429d ago
The two faces or the candlestick holder?
#1.1.3 (Edited 429d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(2) | Report
pixelsword  +   429d ago
It's either or... it depends how you want to see it.

I prefer the candlestick holder because it looks like Moe from the Three Stooges cloned himself and is about to tenderly kiss himself.

OT:

That was a good catch by whomever put that video together; I wouldn't have caught that because Nintendo really didn't clarify because of the end results, maybe; but this guy pieced it together well.

On the downside though, if they are alike in the same way, that means:

1. that development will still be a bit tricky to unlock the potential (in the video that's just a round-about way how they use to say about developing on the the PS3)

2. They have decent development tools now to make development a breeze (what developers said about developing on the PS4)

So either way it looks like the PS4 and WiiU have power, but Sony may have finally created good development tools to patch up the harder spots but maybe not the upper-upper echelon of development like Cerny is stating.
#1.1.4 (Edited 429d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report
TriforceLightning  +   428d ago
It's looks the logo from Double Fine's new game Massive Chalice but it's not.
TripC50  +   429d ago
I agree with you zealOus. Now lets watch others avoide your comment by talking about your picture that looks like two faces... or maybe a glass. Because who gives a shit.
Cuzzo63  +   428d ago
Lol. slow last few months for WiiU news huh
yewles1  +   429d ago
Yeah, because 12.8GB/s DDR3 on the Wii U is TOTALLY not slow compared to 68GB/s DDR3 on XBOX ONE and 176GB/s GDDR5 in PS4...
RememberThe357  +   429d ago
Someone explain to me what the disagrees are about?
SegaSaturn669  +   429d ago | Funny
I disagree with anyone whose name starts with Y because I was sexually assaulted by my uncle yulius yates when i was six.
gaffyh  +   429d ago
People only click the "Disagree" button to annoy the people who actually care about that feature. Don't worry about it.
HyperBear  +   429d ago
Those disagrees are the result of a group/percentage of the N4G community who do not fully understand the technical specifications of each of the three gaming platforms, and thereby, they disagree because their "beloved" system of choice is being sarcastically downplayed when compared to the other two.

Does that about sum it up? lol
sourav93  +   429d ago
@Sega LMAO!
gameonbro   429d ago | Spam
ChickeyCantor  +   429d ago
The video is pointing at the eDRAM which could compensate in certain areas.
But is it sufficient enough for a lot of games? Absolutely. No one is expecting the richness of PS4/xboneone on a technical level.

Ultimately they don't matter to us gamers. A good game is a good game in the end.
#2.2 (Edited 429d ago ) | Agree(28) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
yabhero  +   428d ago
True, let's hope the power doesn't get in the way of the WiiU getting good games though...
TheOneEyedHound   429d ago | Immature | show | Replies(1)
Qrphe  +   429d ago
Don't forget about the EDRAM and SDRAM both the Wii U and Xbox One have. They may not be ideal but they do help a ton with performance.
kwandar  +   429d ago
Well lets talk about that ....

Quantity of memory doesn't impact speed, well it does in the sense that accessing MORE memory is theoretically slower. Doesn't mean that more memory isn't good, but accessing more memory is slower, although it does let you do fast screen draws.

More to the point, I don't think anyone argued that Xbox One or PS4 don't have more/faster memory. The argument has been, all along, that Wii U isn't capable of running next gen (however the hell that's defined) and that just doesn't seem to be the case according to Sony.
starfox79  +   429d ago
your wrong mate wiiu has 32/64MB edram on mcm thats 130GB to 260GB of bandwidth ram,thats without the cpu..
herbs  +   429d ago
And Yewles learned nothin from the video lol.
Locknuts  +   429d ago
Disagreed because you didn't watch or understand the video.
Dgander  +   429d ago
I thought the video was explaining texture bandwith? Anyway it does not surprise me to see that kind of comment from a well known Sony fanboy mongoloid with aspbergers on youtube. The people that thumb him up probably has the same sickness he has.
jcnba28  +   429d ago
I don't think you understand what Mark said in the video....
TriforceLightning  +   428d ago
Someone obviously did not watch the video.
quantae06  +   428d ago
Instead of leaving that comment on here, you should debate Drtre about it then. I'm sure he has a logical explanation.
Blastoise  +   429d ago
I don't know what any of this means.
starfox79  +   429d ago
It means if ur system RAM is good but ur Cache memory is poor then you loose mega power,wiiu has 3MB of edram cache on the cpu cores,with tons of edram on the MCM basically for ur gpu and cpu to share at will,then there's that 30% of secret specs we know nothing about on wiiu could be another 32MB edram or 64MB ??
RTheRebel  +   429d ago
Another reason to respect Mark =)
He himself shut the haters I will buy Knack DAY 1
TheGamingArt  +   429d ago
Jesus. I seriously hate seeing non developers spread information they DON'T UNDERSTAND. This isn't a walk in the part bit of information and the concept can be applied to both consoles. You will hit a LOT of other bottlenecks in the process that the onboard memory can't compensate for. Passing more memory through the bus != next gen graphics. That's not how this logic works. Stop pretending to understand OpenGL and Direct X architecture and learn how to develop before spewing out this shit from your asses.
annus  +   429d ago
It's just a numbers game to most. They don't understand that it doesn't matter if you can hold 1TB of VRAM if you don't have the processing power to actually render it.
TheGamingArt  +   429d ago
And yet, people are disagreeing with me..... ignorance is disgusting. Disagreeing with me is like being an average joe telling construction engineer architect that the main suspension can be removed from the building and everything will be fine. Considering I'm a developer for a living, I believe I'd have quite a bit more insight with memory management and allocations, bandwidth in busses, etc than those of you who just read articles and watch people rant on Youtube without any insight on the actual matter. I should have even MORE insight on this matter since I deal with ARM based mobile chips. Ignorance is bliss.
#5.1.1 (Edited 429d ago ) | Agree(9) | Disagree(8) | Report
Isis06  +   429d ago
Ignorance truly is bliss...
gameonbro   429d ago | Spam
TheGamingArt  +   429d ago
@gameonbro

I got that he's calling developers lazy and stating that the Wii U can keep up with next gen titles. In the first wave of games, this may hold water... but it won't later on. This argument lies true for anything though, optimization = better performance better games. It also equals a lot more work, money, time. It's not worth it. Especially for a system with such a low install base. Why would you budget hundreds of hours for optimizing your game on a console, when the game will hardly sell compared to other consoles in which you'll receive the same if not most likely better performance from without optimizations? It's a waste of resources. Especially with the latest statements from EA not even remotely breaking even on a single WiiU game they've released.
kwandar  +   429d ago
"Passing more memory through the bus != next gen graphics."

Problem is that no one (to my knowledge) has defined "nex gen graphics".

Can Wii U play with Xbox One and PS4, given the current software? Yes as far as I can tell,if the programmer isn't lazy and/or the studio wants to spend the $ for programmer time to tweak.

The hardware does the job for anything I've seen so far, just not as simply or elegantly. Maybe in 5 years we can have this discussion again and you'll be spot on.

If you were attempting to say that passing more memory through the bus != graphics capabilities of PS4 or Xbox1, I think only fools and fanboys could disagree.
JohnS1313  +   429d ago
The real problems the Wii U has are the mediocre 2GB of RAM and USB 2.0. Too little RAM and slow USB. The hard drive is tiny. They expect gamers to use an external hard drive. Fine, then include the faster USB 3.0 so the games aren't slow.
wampdog29  +   429d ago
@JohnS1313

And yet another person that knows very little (if anything) about the technical side of game consoles. This would be fine if you didn't try and make it SEEM like you know how things work. USB 2.0's max data bandwidth is 480 megabits/second which is 60 Megabytes/second. The Wii U reads game discs at 22.5 Megabytes/second (which is actually really fast and something that isn't ever spoken about). This means that USB 2.0 is still plenty fast enough to read games.
kwandar  +   428d ago
I dislike USB2, not because of speed, but because you have to buy drives with an added power adapter. Minor, but it is a nuisance. Speed however is of no issue as wampdog29 correctly pointed out.
TripC50  +   429d ago
If you consider the information compiled into that video "shit from your asses." I would like to know what your shit looks like because that "shit" seemed pretty interesting to me.

Joking aside, you suck.
#5.3 (Edited 429d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
TheGamingArt  +   429d ago
All because you gather data on people saying what can be optimized, doesn't mean that one thing can equate to another. This guy gathered arguments from EA that provide techniques for increasing processing with a lower bus speed. This does not provide any relevance to massive graphical enhancements or anything of the sort. This kind of algorithm allow developers to improve on things such as texture load ups. What does that have to do with keeping up with current gen? Theoretically, this doesn't increase polygon counts, this doesn't increase the amount of animations and physics that can be processed simultaneously at a high frame rate. This is an invalid argument based on information the arguer doesn't understand. All of those processes are based on physical GPUs and CPUs and their respective on board memory and speeds. Hence "shit from your asses". And all because you are interested in it, doesn't make the argument remotely valid.
TripC50  +   428d ago
Look guy I'm just a gamer, not a tech genius like you. "This is an invalid argument based on information the arguer doesn't understand." The only thing I'm pointing out is that you suck because of your overly negative attitude towards this article. If you dissagree with it can you do it in a better, more intellectual, way instead of getting shitty in a comment section? Because not all gamers are as tech savy as a developer.
TheGamingArt  +   427d ago
@TipC50

If you don't understand it, you shouldn't talk about it or agree with it. Take some time out and do some research. Spreading this stuff is how we get fanboys and Air heads who just talk the talk. It brings out the worst in people when people believe crap and it isn't valid at all.
#5.3.3 (Edited 427d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
TripC50  +   427d ago
I never agreed with it. I said it was interesting. Read my first comment again.
#5.3.4 (Edited 427d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
Pancit_Canton  +   429d ago
Yup. It's not slow, It's terrible. The PS3 (22 Gb/s) has higher bandwidth than the Wii U (12 Gb/s) which came out almost 7 YEAR AGO. Stop defending Nintendo. This is the reason why they get away with this crap.
#6 (Edited 429d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(26) | Report | Reply
herbs  +   429d ago
And Pancit Canton learned nothin from the video.
BATRA  +   429d ago
THIS IS JUST FUNNY THAT WII U IS NEXT GEN AND NO BODY WANTS TO MAKE GAMES FOR THE WII U?
SaffronCurse  +   429d ago
You would be terrible the business department.
Actually, I hope EA hire you!!
#7.1 (Edited 429d ago ) | Agree(11) | Disagree(6) | Report | Reply
JohnS1313  +   429d ago
That video doesn't prove a thing about the Wii U. It just proves how well designed the PS4 is.
Realplaya  +   429d ago
It proves a lot pay attention. He basically says take advantage of the system and if you can't you'll have issues.
DarkHeroZX  +   429d ago
But that's assuming a system has anything to take advantage of in the first place. Yeah Wii u has more advantages over 360/ps3 but not enough to run games that need 3 gig of ram to run.
RFornillos4  +   429d ago
so basically what Mark Cerny is saying -- if developed properly, and make use of the necessary features, the architecture used by Wii U is capable of things that the specs don't literally show outright.

haters gonna hate; but as a gamer, that's good enough for me. i'm in it for the games anyway, and not into any pissing contest. also, if ever, i can always get a second console.
Africa-Garvey  +   429d ago
THE WII U IS AS POWERFUL AS EVEN THE SO-CALLED NEXT GEN CONSOLE
OTHER NEGATIVE MINDED PEOPLE AND DEVS HAVE STARTED CHANGING THOUGHTS INCLUDING EA

@KWANDAR ; ASSESSING A LARGE MEMORY BY CPU OR GPU IS SLOW HENCE THE NEED FOR CACHES

Wii U 32MB FAST EDRAM, 1MB SRAM, OUT OF ORDER CPU, & AN UNKNOWN CHIP, ALL ON ONE MCM ...
DarkHeroZX  +   429d ago
Dude the Wii U is just a bump up from next gen. PS4 and X1 both dry rape the Wii U in every conceivable way.
PigPen  +   428d ago
The Wii U is more powerful then most people think, and will take years to unlock its full potential. You're talking crazy.
Omegaman   429d ago | Spam
nnodley  +   429d ago
If I'm not mistaken Cerny was talking about an eDRAM chip they were thinking of using that was capable of 1000GB/s not that every eDRAM chip is capable of those speeds. I could be mistaken though and that's what it sounds like to me. xbox 360 had eDRAM and it had no where near 1000GB/s.

Wii U is and will be quite a bit better than ps360 though. Looking forward to the stunning Pikman 3.
thomasmiller  +   428d ago
Again, boy it is nice, even when sony points this out!! I bet the trolls and the media are very disappointed in sony for telling the truth!!
PigPen  +   428d ago
They will rather down play it, but I think deep down they know.
CouldHaveYelledUiiW  +   428d ago
As a fan, I think-

>GEN after GEN, people use the Retro/Family/Styled graphics of games like Mario and Mario Kart as evidence of Nintendo System power-
And even though the GC and the N64 were as powerful as the competition, Haters got away with untrue statements because of perception.
By perception alone, some were saying that the WiiU was not even as powerful as 360/PS3- even though we all know that is/was BULL. <

This is precisely why Nintendo needs to fund a more Western-styled project.
Like a 2nd Party FPS or a Modern Open World, and have it playable or viewable at launch.

Nintendo has to show the gaming world (Developers and Players) what the system can do- and they have to show it with graphics that the "cORE" understands.

That way when people say we can't do this on WiiU or on the Next Nintendo Console, everyone can point to that game as proof of what the system can do.

Nintendo is great and I will always buy their systems

But if they keep saying they want the "cORE" they need to give developers like EA and the various Engine Makers under EA (Frostbite, Unreal, Crytek.) no room to HATE.
ibroman  +   428d ago
I believe he was reading off the shin'en game interview article in the interview.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

Shenmue's Lore Shared in Sixty Seconds

9m ago - For those who are not familiar with Shenmue, the LORE YouTube Channel has created a perfect prime... | Culture
20°

Fairy Fencer F is A Solid JRPG Held Back By Way Too Many Issues (Review) | Twinfinite

20m ago - Compile Heart RPGs aren’t for everyone, but despite a few failings Fairy Fencer F puts together a... | PS3
20°

Avicii, Kasabian and more make FIFA 15's soundtrack

20m ago - EA Sports has revealed the 41 songs that make up FIFA 15’s soundtrack, which includes exclusives... | PC
10°

Samurai Warriors 4 - Complete roster of characters revealed

20m ago - KOEI TECMO Europe today revealed the complete new character roster for Samurai Warriors 4 - Compl... | PS3
Ad

Destiny The Game

Now - Explore Mars, Rediscover Venus, Reclaim the moon, Protect Earth. Become Legend. The wait is over! Destiny is now available to play, Pick up your... | Promoted post
30°

CastleStorm: Definitive Edition sieges PS4 and Xbox One starting Sept 23

20m ago - Zen Studios release news and information (including DLC packs) on CastleStorm: Definitive Edition... | PS4