100°
Submitted by Lavalamp 754d ago | opinion piece

"Gritty" and "Mature" Aren't Synonyms

USgamer: "In my own free time, my personal gaming has been gradually drifting in an easterly direction as mainstream big-budget Western interactive media continues to do less and less for me. I've been delving primarily into the worlds of visual novels and the more obscure ends of the Japanese role-playing game market, and what I've discovered among those candy-colored, doe-eyed titles is something refreshing: maturity without overt, overwrought darkness or grittiness." (Culture)

Timesplitter14  +   754d ago
I'm getting some strong weaboo vibes from this article
Hicken  +   754d ago
And I'm getting strong ignorance from your comment.

Thing is: Western games can do the same. There was a point in time where Western cartoons pulled it off effortlessly. The Spiderman and Batman and X-Men cartoons of my youth were mature without being gritty.

I was just talking with my sister today about how those shows managed to tackle mature themes without resorting to the vulgarity or explicitness of today's shows. Yeah, they were for kids, but they tackled things like discrimination and cheating in relationships and personal loss, moral dilemmas, etc. And there wasn't a need for grittiness to pull it off.

He brought up visual novels and JRPGs because they continue that, while Western games usually just go for shock factor.
Snookies12  +   754d ago
Do you know what that term means? It is someone who is not Japanese that is completely infatuated with their culture. So, an article can't really give you that vibe, as it's not a person lol. It's a stupid phrase anyway though, when did liking other cultures become a bad thing?
#1.2 (Edited 754d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
rezzah  +   754d ago
Maturity to me isn't about how dark things can be, it is about the capacity to think and see things other may forcefully/unknowingly hide from.

What is dark is truth, because lies become common and "safe" among our daily lives.
knifefight  +   754d ago
I've felt this way for a long time. Just because something has boobs and F words doesn't mean it is mature.
RememberThe357  +   754d ago
But it does mean it's awesome.
rezzah  +   754d ago
To each their own, personally based on how it's done it can be completely immature.
RememberThe357  +   754d ago
Of course it's immature. But immature doesn't mean bad. Being mature is about knowing when to take things seriously and when to not take anything seriously at all.

Explotions, tits, beer, guns, cars (basically GTA) all can be extremely entertaining. The problem comes when all you can focus on are these and you ignore everything else.
rezzah  +   754d ago
Nor does immature always mean good (or that it is awesome).

When meaning is given to something perceived as immature, it can be looked upon as either "bad" or "good".

Your reply to knifefight implies that anything with boobs and F words is awesome, based on your use of words. With that comment there is no room for exceptions, to which I disagree with.

I can accept immaturity, but it depends on how it it done. There is always variations, therefore it falls to personal taste.
KwietStorm  +   754d ago
I get what you're saying, but mature can mean different things. It doesn't have to mean thought provoking and a centerpiece for deep discussion. If something has boobs and the f bomb all over it, it's rated mature because it's just not for kids.
RememberThe357  +   754d ago
Great thought from the author. I haven't thought about this too much but it gets me thinking. I think I'd be more into these Japanese titles if it wasn't for that damn anime art style. it cool for some kind of tv shows (I grew up watching Toonami religiously) but in a lot of these games it just puts me off them. I'd love to see the true maturity that the author talks about in more gritty games. Few western games have emotional depth of any kind and few Japanese games are appealing. The Last of Us, MGS, and The Walking Dead seem to be the only games that are both gritty and mature.

If there is a "renaissance" this generation please let it be on the narrative side. Look at Killzone; one of the coolest fictions in games, and some of the worst story telling in games. I want to see western devs take "adolescent boy's power fantasy" and lace thought provoking, emotionally challenging, negative. No more depth only found in the books you pick up in Skyrim, but the depth presented to the player as just as critical a part of the game as the gameplay and graphics. Frankly it adds much more than either of those two.
#4 (Edited 754d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
Kratoscar2008  +   754d ago
You should try the SMT series and not im not talking about Persona im talking of the MAIN SMT series.
RememberThe357  +   754d ago
I've never even entertained the idea, but I'll go check the series out. Any specific titles or just scatter shot?
Kratoscar2008  +   754d ago
For PS2 you have:

Digital Devil Saga 1&2 (Game about hinduism and reincarnation)

SMT 3 Nocturne (A game about Philosophies and Reasons)

Devil Summoner 1&2 Raidou series (An ARPG about a detective that uses demons for his investigations)

On DS:

SMT Strange Journey (A scifi themed dungeon crawler)

PSVita (Every Persona game, P2 has some serious story )

3DS

SMT 4 (Comming in 6 days)
Devil Summoner Soul Hackers (Not related to Raidou)

Those are excellent games.
#4.2 (Edited 754d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
metaltales49  +   754d ago
are the SMT devil survivor games on the DS or the 3DS any good
Dj7FairyTail  +   754d ago
@metaltales49
YES
RememberThe357  +   753d ago
Wow, thanks for the list. Those short descriptions caught me. I'm definitely going to go down this list and learn more about these games; this has been bookmarked.

Again, thanks man. Bubs for the help.
Kratoscar2008  +   753d ago
Its a great series howewer SMT 3, 4 and SJ have a different approach in Storytelling as they are more world driven and the characters themselves are just means to carry ideologies but they are a good way to convey them.

DDS is more story driven but dungeons are still more focused.

Raidou games have a taisho era setting (When Japan was beggining to be americanized) and are ARPGs.

Well im sure you know Persona by now.

Anyways have a good time.

Oh and you have Chaterine for PS3, its a puzzle however but very well handed mature themes like paternal resposability, infidelity and so on.
#4.3 (Edited 753d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

Naughty Dog talks climbing with Drake, weapons and Uncharted 4's new composer

8m ago - While things may be a bit slim for PS4 gamers in 2015, 2016 is shaping up to be a massive year wi... | PS4
40°

Gamescom 2015 Shows off Scalebound

14m ago - After two other quick announcements, Scalebound hit the stage from Platinum Games. Stepping up to... | Xbox One
Ad

Warhammer Fans! Win a Pro-Painted Ghorgon!

Now - Turbo Tape Games is pleased to announce a contest for an exclusive Ghorgon miniature hand-painted by Dave Taylor! | Promoted post
40°

Rare Replay Xbox One Review: The Ultimate Retro Compilation | USgamer

15m ago - USgamer: "Boasting no fewer than 30 games from Rare's extraordinary back catalog, Rare Replay... | Xbox One
40°

Submerged Review | Complete Game Reviews

16m ago - The reviewer writes: "Submerged is a rather unique game that has an interesting take on the adven... | PC
40°

Rare Replay review | Eurogamer

36m ago - With this hardware generation seemingly locked into a cycle of re-releases and remasters, it take... | Xbox One