Submitted by MoXxXi 786d ago | opinion piece

The Last of Us is Below Naughty Dog's Standard of Quality and Polish

KaboomShark writer Ryan "Rdawg" T writes - "By now, I would say it's a pretty safe bet to say that most people have gotten their hands on Naughty Dog's latest masterpiece, The Last of Us. I sure know the guys at KaboomShark have! We have become quite accustomed to having late night multiplayer sessions, but that is a story for another time. To get back on topic, The Last of Us is a beautiful game that tells the amazing story of a scarred man and a traumatized girl. However, regardless of how beautiful The Last of Us is (by both standards of environment, story and gameplay), there are still many issues that left me perplexed. When I play a Naughty Dog game, especially one like The Last of Us which focusses on environment and atmosphere, I expect something that is polished to a degree that most development teams can only dream of. I wish I could say that about their most recent success showcased this level of polish, but I just can't. While The Last of Us is a great game, it's just not up to Naughty Dog's standards when it comes to quality and polish." (PS3, The Last Of Us)

Majin-vegeta  +   786d ago
Name one game that is bug free and perfect??Exactly you can't.You can't get rid of every little thing.
MoXxXi  +   786d ago
Sure, there are no games that are completely bug free, but you would think Naughty Dog would at least try and get rid of a lot of the easy ones, such as disappearing walls and environments. There are just a lot of bugs and glitches for a Naughty Dog game. It didn't ruin the game, but it definitely put a strain on some pretty important parts for me.
Abash  +   786d ago
If they were so easy to remove dont you think Naughty Dog would remove them in a simple update? The Last of Us is the best looking console game yet, it pushes the PS3 to it's limits, it isnt as simple as you think
HarryMasonHerpderp  +   786d ago
To be fair you could tell they were pushing the PS3 to its limits and also the campaign is twice as long as an Uncharted game. I imagine that's why it's not as bug free as their earlier games.
I'm guessing they will release a patch in the future to tidy things up a bit.
admiralvic  +   786d ago
@ Abash

While it might be more complex than we might think, that doesn't mean it is super complex either.

For instance take the sex line phone numbers. They could have avoided that WHOLE SITUATION by simply calling the numbers before including them in the game. Would have took, what? 2 minutes to verify they weren't real numbers, yet they didn't.
Soldierone  +   786d ago
A lot of that stuff will take ages to perfect. A lot of disappearing things etc are just how games render, and sometimes it comes down to the console itself skipping a beat. I bet a lot of these will disappear if you play the game again, then happen again at a different point. I've had several games do that.

its like saying "dont you think car manufacturer A would find a way to stop brakes from wearing out, dead batteries, and spark plug replacements?"
darthv72  +   786d ago
if this game is "below" standards...
damn!! i cant wait to see what their games look like that are "at" or "above" standards.
KwietStorm  +   786d ago
There is no such thing as an easy bug to get rid of. And you would have to know it's there, and be able to recreate it before you can fix it anyway. Tired of all these armchair software engineers this generation.
gamertk421  +   786d ago
How dare you bash the Sony Pony crown jewel! Look it's a great game, but it's not the second coming. There's nothing wrong with a bit of criticism when deserved. You'd think they were talking about someone's kid or something.
soniqstylz  +   786d ago
I'm on my third playthrough, and have yet to see any of these strange bugs. The only one I've seen is that some textures didn't load properly during the prologue on my NG+, but that was fixed by the recent patch.
Salooh  +   786d ago
I never saw disappearing walls and environments. You people just like to complain . i only saw like 2 or 3 bugs in two playthroughs ..
pixelsword  +   786d ago
What's this article really about?

To Paraphrase:

"I just published a flaimbait article and now you MUST click on it to see if I'm right or wrong! Muhaha!"

Which is about 80% of game articles anyways...
Am_Ryder  +   781d ago
Disappearing walls and environments are 100% down to the individual console's Blu-Ray player, and it's faults. Usually due to aging. A massive majority of players didn't experience anything at all.

I didn't experience a single bug throughout the entire game. No exaggeration. I've probably been playing it for about 40-50 hours. Not a single bug or glitch.
AsheXII  +   786d ago
Zelda, Mario and Metroid games, for most parts,
-GametimeUK-  +   786d ago
All have bugs. Very popular with the speed runners.
zebramocha  +   786d ago
@ash you know you can glitch a game.
duducus  +   786d ago
They don't have visual bugs...
Tiqila  +   786d ago
they have visual bugs, in any 3d mario game go to a wall and crouch -> head is in the wall.
#1.2.4 (Edited 786d ago ) | Agree(15) | Disagree(0) | Report
j-blaze  +   786d ago
MGS4, FFXIII/2, Resonance of Fate, RE5 etc "most japan made games"... i didn't experience any bug in these game while in TLoU there are a lot, and some areas in the game weren't polished and looked dated yet ppl say it's the best looking game on console lol
Pintheshadows  +   786d ago
Including RE5 in your list is an absolute joke. It had this tiny little issue called 'companion AI' that liked to glitch out frequently.
HeavenlySnipes  +   786d ago
I agree that MGS4 had zero bugs that I encountered other than the ones near the dumpsters
Skips  +   786d ago

I actually encountered this one, quite a few times... http://www.youtube.com/watc...

lol, so NO... Practically every games has glitches.

In Resonance of Rate and FF, there's really not much going on other than cinematics. -__-
#1.3.3 (Edited 786d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(2) | Report
kayoss  +   786d ago
MGS4 was bug free because 75% of the damn game were CGI cut scenes. I'm not saying any bad about MGS4, the game was awesome but sitting through cut scenes after cut scenes was a little tedious.
DigitalRaptor  +   786d ago
"Looked dated".

You are a joke. Dated where?

The Last of Us is a stunning game. It's stunning in its design. The beauty of nature and a well-realised crumbled civilization. Completely perfect and natural animation, despite certain bugs.

The way light purses through the trees, the beautifully bleak emptiness, the lush greens. Even the dark and bloodshed is beautiful as it's grounded and realistic.

There's nothing you can say to negate all of this stunning beauty, besides some rough textures here and there.
#1.3.5 (Edited 786d ago ) | Agree(10) | Disagree(2) | Report
2pacalypsenow  +   786d ago
MGS 4 single player
Skips  +   786d ago
Metal Gear Solid 4 = 5-7 hours of GAMEPLAY

The Last Of Us = 13-14 hours of GAMEPLAY
Campy da Camper  +   786d ago
@skips...5-7 hours? I spent waaay more than that. Did you just run through the game on easy?
2pacalypsenow  +   786d ago
@skips TLOF took me 14 Hours on Normal MGS 4 took me 15
Skips  +   786d ago
I'm talking gameplay WITHOUT CUT SCENES guys...

In terms of PURE GAMEPLAY on Solid Normal, it took me like 5-7 hours. But when you bumb up the difficulty to say, Big Boss Hard, or Big Boss Extreme. Of course it would take a few hours longer.

Without cinematics though, it's definitely a whole lot shorter than The Last Of Us.

MGS4 has like, almost 10 hours worth of cut scenes while The Last Of Us has 3 hours worth.



"TLOF took me 14 Hours on Normal MGS 4 took me 15"

MGS4: 15 - 10 = 5
TLOU: 14 - 3 = 11
#1.4.4 (Edited 786d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(2) | Report
Reverent  +   786d ago
Having took 16 hours to beat MGS4 and 14 to beat TLOU, still, MGS4 didn't even come close to exhausting the PS3's power as much as TLOU.

@Skip, actually TLOU has less than an hours worth of cutscenes. The majority of what people assume are cutscenes, are actually in game occurences. I've even checked the Bonus Gallery in TLOU after beating the game. Surprisingly, there were very few cutscenes and most of them were about a minute long.
#1.4.5 (Edited 786d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report
black0o  +   786d ago
Final Fantasy XIII on ps3 .. and that game didnt even needed a single update since it came out
Zezo  +   786d ago
Tlou is not a bad game in general but it has some pretty lame aspects. Is it a perfect game? Not at all. Does it deserve praise? Absolutely no Fu*&^ing way. It looks like absolute garbage, covered in jaggies, and horrible low res textures.

And the ending, oh boy what a waste.
isa_scout  +   786d ago
This is what a Troll looks like people. Move Along, Move Along...
#1.6.1 (Edited 786d ago ) | Agree(9) | Disagree(0) | Report
omi25p  +   786d ago
Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Muffins1223  +   786d ago
No but it shouldent be a glitchy mess like fallout or skyrim on ps3
Mr_Nuts  +   786d ago
Well I've played the game and finished it and never came across one bug....must of been lucky

Besides does it matter....hell in 2011 we gave Bethesda Studio of the Year and Game of the Year to Skyrim. The most bug filled game of the entire year
MoXxXi  +   786d ago
Of course, with Skyrim the glitches were silly and almost improved gameplay. With a game like TLoU where the environment is set so well, it's so easy to lose the tension when Ellie's sprite floats in the air with enlongated limbs...Maybe I just like to get mad at small things because I am so infuriated that TLoU was better than Bioshock Infinite :}
Baka-akaB  +   786d ago
Come on now you're scrapping the barrel . Skyrim's bugs werent entertaining nor game improving . On one platform the game became even unplayable at times .

Both hardly have the same level and amount of bugs , each game's ambitions and scope aside . Plenty people manage to play Last of us mostly bug free . The most we've heard about issues with the game was usually about the saves .

I so far only got stuck once on some barrel whose contact made noise and alerted clickers
#2.1.1 (Edited 786d ago ) | Agree(23) | Disagree(1) | Report
Lovable  +   786d ago
Hey that would have been hilarious bugs!
Hydralysk  +   786d ago
I played Skyrim on PS3, and a glitch, which hasn't even been fully resolved made it so that for the first few months the game had a framerate so bad that it made the game practically into a slideshow.

Skyrim does NOT get a pass, especially since they tried to cover it up by not giving out PS3 review copies.
#2.1.3 (Edited 786d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report
isa_scout  +   786d ago
Did you play Skyrim on the PS3??? Because after 120 hours or so the game became unplayable for me due to the lag and stuttering. Nothing about that made me feel like it was small,silly, or improving the gameplay. I haven't even experienced a small glitch in TLOU and I've beaten it three times already.
CaptainYesterday  +   786d ago
I didn't experience any bugs during my playthrough my game froze once but that was because I was playing for way too long it's hard to stop playing once you start!
Unicron  +   786d ago
I hit a ridiculous amount of occlusion bugs, saw a ton of seams in the geo, but the sheer size of the game's world made me pretty forgiving of it. I only hit one missing environment bug and no animation issues. I'm guessing they updated their occlusion system from previous titles and weren't able to work all the kinks out before ship.
Williamson  +   786d ago
I too never came across a glitch/bug. Seems like people will do what ever to bring this game down, keep trying since this is one hell of a game.
killerips   786d ago | Spam
SIRHC13   786d ago | Bad language | show | Replies(1)
fattyuk  +   786d ago
PersonMan  +   786d ago
I noticed some textures taking forever to load, but that's the only problem I ran into. Some textures in Uncharted 3 took long to load as well... I guess it's the engine. I even tried playing The Last of Us from an SSD drive and the textures took an equally long time to load, so I know it has nothing to do with reading from the blu-ray drive and more to do with the engine not having the resources available to load the texture at that point in the game. The rest of the game played okay though.

My other other complaint is, I wish I could jump on my own and I wish the camera was a little further back so I could see the entire character. I'm not a big fan of waist-up camera views.... it makes it look funny when walking.
Mr-SellJack  +   786d ago
Jumping?!as in freely?that would totally kill the tension and survival feel of the game also camera is zoomed so it wouldn't feel like uncharted and your typical. tps.jumping for nothing and like a retard like uncharted is disabled.jumpimg is for efficient use in the game
PersonMan  +   786d ago
I like the freedom to jump in games. It's just the way I am. However, it's not like the game was ruined because I couldn't jump. It was still an excellent game.
Mr-SellJack  +   786d ago
Turd article is shite
Maddens Raiders  +   786d ago
This is really dumb.
xtremexx  +   786d ago
fairly sure they are anomalies. bugs happen.
MestreRothN4G  +   786d ago
Stupid hit fishing = WTF and NO.
And, obviously, no hit.
TuxedoMoon  +   786d ago
I want to beat the game and dont want any spoilers, but ill assume that the bugs ruined the game for him? If the glitches were as bad as this writer says, then the game might not have been getting near perfect scores. I don't think Skyrim, with it's game of the year award, got near perfect scores and some reviewers did take the game breaking glitches into consideration.

Some glitches and bugs are tolerable. Unless it breaks the game, then it shouldn't be much of an issue.
#14 (Edited 786d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
Roper316  +   786d ago
( minor spoiler )I agree to an extent because very early on when I was fleeing with Sara & Tommy and we were in Tommy's car, Tommy ended up outside in front of the car facing back at me talking to me while he was still supposed to be driving & the car was still moving down the road.

I kind of think that this game was supposed to release in October/November but was bumped up to June because of the PS4 releasing around that time. So some things didn't get as polished as they could but this is still just an incredible game / experience that everyone should get the pleasure of playing.
Pintheshadows  +   786d ago
I came across them only when showing it to my friends. The first playthrough had a few issues when I threw molotovs but not much more. However this time during the opening sequence the game flipped out as they hit the traffic jam and Joel, still sitting floated through the roof of the car and the helicopter overhead also floated upwards.
jjb1981  +   786d ago
A Masterpiece!
KittyEmperor  +   786d ago
Only bug i've ever encountered in this game is the autosave one and that has been fixed.
silkrevolver  +   786d ago
I came across one bug, and it involved a stray dog getting stuck on a roof.

I'm gonna go ahead and disagree with the authors on this one.
medman  +   786d ago
People really love to complain. One of the best, if not the best, developer on the planet has consistently graced the gaming public with phenomenal games and we sit here and moan about what amounts to rather insignificant little bugs? Really? I loved the game. That story is fantastic, the world they created is brutal, harsh, and wonderful. I can tolerate an occasional glitch considering everything the game is. Nothing in this life is perfect. Why would you expect any game to be?
Bowzabub  +   786d ago
I attribute the majority of flaws in The Last of Us to the hardware.
strickers  +   786d ago
Uncharted was buggy. UC2 had some massive bugs. I encountered one where I dropped through the environment . Why? Because they push so hard and are actually quite small teams . UC2 shat on all other console games for ages , technically .
A few bugs for that level of visuals and presentation are acceptable .
Especially with so many other games full of glitches , tearing and framerate issues , while achieving far less
testsubject  +   786d ago
Even though I only got to play this game once on my friends PS3,( I don't have a PS3),I have experienced glitches in The Last of Us and it still is one of the best games I have ever played,same goes for Bioshock Infinite :)
jakmckratos  +   786d ago
below standard of quality and polish??? It oozes quality you BITCH.
Son_Lee  +   785d ago
The beauty of always trying to be perfect is you constantly improve your quality of work. Naughty Dog knows this.
evilhasitsway  +   785d ago
ok I played and beat the game I didn't see any major problems with the game so whatever you say man. don't talk crap unless you have played it and beat it. and that goes for any game.
elda  +   785d ago
Bought it a month ago & still haven't played it yet.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

3 Ways The Taken King Takes Destiny A Step Closer To Being A Traditional MMORPG

25m ago - The changes coming to Destiny with The Taken King expansion help move the game in the direction o... | Xbox 360

Thorgrim Grudgebearer introduces the Dwarfs of Total War: Warhammer

1h ago - A full cinematic trailer introduces the Dwarfs of Total War: Warhammer. Narration by Thorgrim Gru... | PC

Top 5 Movies To See This Month

Now - The month of September has Johnny Depp portraying an enraged criminal, a group of climbers trying to make it home safely, and the return of the sur... | Promoted post

Rock Band 4: Full Band Gameplay Video

2h ago - Skewed and Reviewed have posted video of their session on Rock Band 4 from PAX Prime. Two members... | PS4

The Resurgence of FMV Games

2h ago - Nerdopotamus.com - Our writer, Irfan Hanjra, delves into the resurgence of FMV (Full Motion Video... | Industry

Mad Max: Jeet’s stronghold upgrade guide

2h ago - At first, a stronghold is little more than a ruin with miserable people in it. Visiting one doesn... | Xbox