Submitted by BrashGames 873d ago | opinion piece

Videogame Reviews – when did 70% become average?

Ever notice all the 4 star reviews plastered over movie posters? In the world of movies, music and pretty much any other form of entertainment open to critique, a 4 star review is something to be very proud of – something worth showing off. Oh, unless that form of entertainment happens to be video games. (Culture, Killzone 2, Thor)

dedicatedtogamers  +   873d ago
Microsoft was the one to really trumpet review scores half a decade ago. They made it a huge part of their PR. Every time a 360 exclusive got above a 90 (or if it got a better score than a PS3 equivalent) Microsoft would issue a press release and say "Xbox 360, the home of the highest-scoring racing game of 2007. Xbox 360, the home of the highest-scoring third person cover shooter of the generation" etc. etc.

And then if a multiplatform game got a better Meta score on 360, even if it was by just one point, Microsoft would issue a press release and say "Call of Duty Such-and-such. Highest-scored version only available on Xbox 360".

They were the one who came up with all the meaningless metrics like "we have the most 90+ average games on Metacritic. We rule Metacritic!" They would incorporate that into their conferences on-stage at E3 and Gamescom and places like that. And people wonder why everyone started getting so defensive/offensive about review scores?

And then once Wii and PS3 started to dominate the Metacritic charts, Microsoft fell strangely silent.
#1 (Edited 873d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
from the beach  +   873d ago
They actually mentioned this in the Xbox One reveal, 'Forza - best rated racing series of the generation', or something to that effect.

The article raises a good point, if you flick across to the music rankings on Metacritic the best albums usually hit mid to high 80s, on account of a broader range of scores. With games, when one site ranks lower than the rest all kinds of dumb accusations are made..
RonRico  +   873d ago
Agree. People really overreact if a generally highly reviewed game gets a not so great score from some obscure website. There's always that ONE.
Its so funny when you see a game review noways and the score is a 5/10 or average, you instantly think the game is pretty bad or is lacking enough to make it unplayable.
UNGR  +   872d ago
Seriously blaming Microsoft for this? Rather than all of the reviewers? You should call the the glue company and see if they have a solvent to get your lips off of Sony's ass. I suppose poverty was Microsoft's fault too? Get bent fanboy.
MysticStrummer  +   873d ago
I guess many people equate 70 to being just barely passable because of school grading systems...?

Grades of 60-69 used to be classified as a D, but I think many schools have dropped the D and just go with A,B,C, and F, so anything below 70 is a failing grade.

Idk... it's been quite a while since I was in school, so I may be off but that's my two cent theory.

; )
Unicron  +   873d ago
Which is silly because reviews are opinions, nothing more.
MysticStrummer  +   873d ago
Agreed, but some people take this stuff very personally.

There are also those reviews that are clearly inaccurate for whatever reason, yet they get included in the almighty MetaCritic average.

I don't know how many reviews I read this generation that made me wonder how long the person spent with the game, and there are undoubtedly review scores given for shock value to generate hits.

Honest opinions are great and entirely valid, but not all opinions are honest.
kevnb  +   873d ago
When too much $$$ became involved.
2pacalypsenow  +   873d ago
Because in school our grades are in the same way a 70 is a C. Anything above 85 is acceptable
Summons75  +   872d ago
Yeah, actually my school and most colleges from hat I understand a failing grade starts at 69% and D is 70-72 then the rest is good. I hate the grade system, especially when your use too a 60 being failing grade then you retake math because of a 69.
OrangePowerz  +   873d ago
2 1/2 out.of 5 stars is considered a bad movie and by the same standards as 70 isn't average 2 1/2 stars wouldn't be a bad movie, but just an average movie.
mydyingparadiselost  +   873d ago
I've been wondering this as well over the past week and I have no good answers except metacritic and money. It seems pretty pointless to have a system that goes from 0-100 but 60 and below only get used once or twice a year and even then it feels more like a game is being made fun of instead of actually being reviewed when this does happen. It seems the way games are reviewed is broken, a system like percents or 1-10 have been over used and fit more with grading tests than giving an accurate account of what a game does well and where its failings are at. I think the way Rev3 does reviews are probably the best way to do them, a 1-5 scale ensures the scale is small enough that its entirety is used and the reviewers side comments on what's is liked and disliked give a more personal idea of what kind of person would even want to play the game in the first place.
310dodo  +   873d ago
Game prices will dictate how much weight reviews carry.

Difference between a 7 or a 8.75 game is big when $65 comes into play.
CrossingEden  +   872d ago
70% become average when gamers became whiny self entitled manchildren
Pittoo  +   872d ago
Most games released this year have been shit.
manageri   872d ago | Spam

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

ARK: Survival Evolved Goes on Sale on DFTBA and gets Thanksgiving Event

16m ago - Andrew writes: "Are you looking for a great deal for the game ARK: Survival Evolved? Who isn't... | PC

Jake & Tess' Finding Monsters Adventure Now Available For Gear VR

2h ago - VRFocus reports on Brazilian developer Black River Studios launching Jake & Tess’ Finding Monster... | Android

HotLiked - What the Internet is talking about right now

Now - Kill some time at HotLiked.com. You will regret it... | Promoted post

Q&A With Thomas Van Den Berg, Co-Developer Of Kingdom

2h ago - Baden of WGB: "I got the opportunity to toss a few questions toward Thomas van den Berg, better k... | PC

Thanksgiving and Black Friday 2015 iPhone and iPad Games Sales and Freebies

2h ago - Appunwrapper writes: "Thanksgiving is this week, and along with it comes Black Friday sales. I se... | iPhone

Minecraft: Story Mode – Episode Three: The Last Place You Look Review | GodisaGeek

3h ago - Nicola Ardron: "This is the strongest entry to date in Minecraft: Story Mode. It still isn't hitt... | PC
Related content from friends