Submitted by Lavalamp 584d ago | article

The Last of Us vs. The Walking Dead: The Comparison We Had To Make

Kotaku: "There are no shortage of zombie games out there—but outstanding ones have come out in the last year. At first glance, aside from the zombies, these games might seem like they don't have much in common. The Walking Dead is an adventure game about moral choices. The Last of Us is a cinematic survival horror game. Apples to oranges, right?

Not exactly. Comparing the two reveals some huge differences, sure, but also some illuminates some fascinating things about the games and storytelling in general.

Might as well shoot this in the head while we're here, no? Let's dig in." (iPad, iPhone, PC, PS Vita, PS3, The Last Of Us, The Walking Dead: Episode 1 "A New Day", Xbox 360)

Prcko  +   584d ago
Watch Out on Spoilers guys and girls
HammadTheBeast  +   584d ago
Both are fantastic games, but I would choose The Last of Us just because of how amazingly beautiful the relationship between Joel and Ellie is shown.

It's by far one of the most beautiful action/surivial horror games ever made.
supraking951  +   584d ago
glad Last of Us didn't go the typical Walking Dead route, so predictable. I was fearing TLoU would copy that overrated game. next.
cyguration  +   584d ago
The Walking Dead is not predictable or overrated.

***Spoiler Alerts***

How many main characters lose their arm to an infection?

***Spoiler Alerts***
Bimkoblerutso  +   584d ago
It was fairly predictable in that you could pretty much guess who was going to live and die the second the cast was introduced.

Though, it really didn't matter in the end. The emotional punch was still...substantial, to say the least...

Edit: And I agree with BigBoss. I think both games did more for storytelling and characterization in the industry than we'll really realize for quite a few years down the road.
#2.1.1 (Edited 584d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(4) | Report
Harpers_Ferry  +   584d ago
I'm not sure I understand this post. Is this a joke?

Are you implying that removing a limb due to infection isn't predictable? Because it totally is, and is pretty standard fare in zombie fiction.

Are you implying that having a choice in whether or not to cut off the arm makes the overall story any less predictable? Because it doesn't.

The Walking Dead was a great game, but much like the comic, it's predictable as all hell. That doesn't mean it can't have a great story or writing.
mgszelda1  +   584d ago
Loved the story in TLOU. Did not see half the things coming
brodychet  +   584d ago
best game NA
brodychet  +   582d ago
NA = North America.

Not saying "Nah"

rpd123  +   584d ago
Bro, the Last of Us is an incredibly predictable game itself. The only thing I did not see coming is SPOILER Davis turning on Ellie after they fight off hordes of zombies. I called him being a cannibal though. Everything else was pretty predictable. And drew a considerable amount from the Walking Dead comics and past zombie movies and whatnot. What makes the game so great is the way they told the story though.
#2.3 (Edited 584d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
Bathyj  +   584d ago
You thought he was a cannibal, but didnt think hed turn on her?
rpd123  +   584d ago
I suspected him being a cannibal, then he seemed really nice so I dismissed it, but then when he started getting all douchey I went back to thinking he was a cannibal.
trenso1  +   583d ago

So you predicted that sam would get infected and his brother would commit suicide.

that joel would bodly lie to ellie at the end and would kill marlene.

rpd123  +   583d ago
Yeah I called Sam getting infected. That was incredibly predictable. The suicide I didn't call. I figured he'd kill his brother but not that he'd kill himself. But the game as a whole was pretty predictable. Major plot points- Ellie being immune, Joel's daughter dying, Joel saving her instead of finding a cure. It's been done before, it'll be done again. Like I said, what makes it great is the way they told it and the development of the characters that a lot of games/movies don't pull off well.
brodychet  +   582d ago

Lmao, I'm pretty sure most people suspected Ellie to be the cure.

But there's no way you knew Joel would get punctured through the stomach, and David to be a blatant pedophile.

Also, I doubt you expected Joel to turn into a selfish "bad guy" and become so attached to ellie that he gives up finding the cure to just be with her.

Nah there's no way.
xBigxBossx  +   584d ago
The walking dead was not overrated. It is the best 20 bucks I've ever spent on a digital game. TLOU stomps all over it IMO. But these two games aren't comparable. Both brilliant in their own ways.
mgszelda1  +   584d ago
Walking Dead was mediocre. Praised for its "amazing story" and "unique gameplay"
Don't get me wrong I got walking dead for $20 so it wasnt a terrible buy. But it was too predictable, probably more so with the fact that the developers said we wanted to make players cry led to one of two possibilities for an ending which came true. Oh and the gameplay is just a straight rip of Heavy Rain which quantic dream has been doing since Indigo Prophecy.
Last of Us came out with great animations, intense gameplay, and a very unpredictable but amazing storyline. I kept pondering over what my top 5 ps3 games would be and TLOU is 2nd for me. MGS4 is first for me
Joln  +   578d ago
TLOU was mediocre. Every single major character, plus that Ellen Page RIPOFF Ellie was extremely obnoxious and annoying.

I also find it hard to believe how in a game designed to be so "realistic" and "original" as TLOU could possible be all that when Joel can just gun down an entire squad of fully armed Fireflies and Ellie stabbing a man twice her height and size to death with a knife.

Everything about TLOU is cliche and Hollywood whereas in the Walking Dead you at least have a major influence of the storyline and gameplay.

You're just a fanboi.
elhebbo16  +   584d ago
comparing a 60 game to a 20 one? if you put gameplay to a side for a minute, I think the story in both were probably the best in all of gaming. not because of the zombie/infected theme but because of the hard choices that someone would make in those types of situation. some might seem unmoral and wrong but thats what made these games so great.
Trago1337  +   584d ago
The Walking Dead had a better over all story in my opinion. The Last of Us was a better gameplay experience though.
mgszelda1  +   584d ago
how was walking deads story better? Ending seen from a mile away. TLOU ending so far out of view I might as well be the first European stepping onto the Americas
goldwyncq  +   584d ago

While most of us guessed that Lee's going to die in the end judging from the last episode, it was still more emotional and heartbreaking than TLOU's ending. Really though, we really can't compare the endings since they're vastly different from each other, just a matter of opinion on what you think was better. I thought the story from each game was equally good, but in terms of gameplay and everything else, TLOU wins.
Bladesfist  +   584d ago
How was the ending of the last of us far out? does the game have multiple endings or something?
mgszelda1  +   583d ago
TLOU story was much less predictable. Where the walking dead was extremely predictable, on top of that it was ridiculously cliche
HellFeast  +   583d ago
I love them both, end of comment.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

#IDARB Available Early for Xbox One

27m ago - It’s not February quite yet, but Xbox Live members can now grab their free copy of @IDARBGame | Xbox One

Seven Improvements TT Games Needs To Make To Lego Avengers

29m ago - GI There is no shortage of Lego games – they seem to propagate with the speed of a rabbit farm... | PC

Borderlands 2 lead writer Anthony Burch is leaving Gearbox

29m ago - Almost five years ago, Anthony Burch went from being a Destructoid staff member to a Destructoid... | Industry

Iron Knights Review | AppGamer

29m ago - It is very true that the hack-and-slash genre of games has become more and more popular. Read the... | iPhone

Check out the new Bloodborne Trailer

Now - Sony just released a new trailer of the upcoming PS4 exclusive by From Software and SCE Japan Studio. | Promoted post

Stunt School: Skyrim

31m ago - All the tricks you can pull off in Tamriel with horses, dragons and really, really big mountains. | PC