OXM: "The new weapons aren’t much to write home about. Sure, the Rhino shotgun has a blistering rate of fire, and both it and the CLAW machinegun come with their attachments already unlocked, but neither is likely to replace your current favorites. These are small quibbles in the face of this expansion’s biggest problem, though: the woeful lack of people with whom to play. Days and even a couple of weeks after Lost Island’s release, finding even a single match often felt like an endurance trial, which is a shame — this add-on’s neither truly spectacular nor a fantastic value, but it is worth playing. Too bad even paying customers may never get the chance."