Submitted by Captain_Mushroom 688d ago | opinion piece

5 Changes, and Gamers will LOVE Xbox One

Hello, and welcome to Feedback Unexpected – a feature in which I, Vlad Pintea, express my personal feelings from a gamer’s perspective on the current state of our beloved industry in a tiny bit more personal fashion. My next topic will be all about Microsoft, and its incredibly controversial next generation console, Xbox One - Vlad Pintea, chief of news and reviews/PC editor for Analog Addiction (Industry, Microsoft, Xbox One)

mark134uk  +   688d ago
are ms paying all these blogs to write these silly stories
Erudito87  +   688d ago
did you read it?
mark134uk  +   688d ago
no lol just fed of sieing these why you should buy a xbox threads
Erudito87  +   688d ago
they're saying what ms needs to change about the xb1 for people to actually want one
JokesOnYou  +   688d ago
Very poorly thought out news piece, I mean his comments on kinect shows he lacks knowledge with even the basic functionality of how the X1 works, kinect isn't going anywhere its built from the ground up with kinect, lol I'm glad it is and there is no just take it out, people who think this just dont want a X1 and should buy a ps4.
Captain_Mushroom  +   688d ago
Nah man, just throwing my two cents out there. I'm already set on buying the PS4, but the thing is... if there's no competition, Sony might get lazy and start screwing with gamers. Competition is great, so I really want MS to get some love from the audience in order for us gamers to get even more great products from Sony, MS, and Nintendo.
BallsEye  +   688d ago
I bet no matter what MS will do (even give 50 free games on launch, turn off DMR and give box of chocolates with each xbox) you and your kind will find a new thing to hate on in xbox one.
Erudito87  +   688d ago
it would be nice if ms made those changes but they are just soooo in touch with their consumers first windows 8 and now the xbox 1
MikeMyers  +   688d ago
1. Online check-in.

Doubtful they will change that. It is needed to make sure people don't take advantage of that 10 family circle.

2. Rights to your games

This can all be tweaked over time by listening to feedback. It's all software based.

3. Kinect.

No, they want a Kinect in every system and I don't blame them. This way itt's not treated as a peripheral and everyone will be on a level playing field. This makes it much easier for game developers to support. It's like asking Nintendo to drop the Wii U Gamepad and make it an option, not going to happen.

4. Live model

They should be pushing more towards the Playstation Plus model, give out freebies and other incentives instead of just having everything behind a paywall.

5. Independent developers

This is a big area that needs to be addressed. They need to work with smaller developers more and make it easier to publish your own games. They are the creative minds out there.
Captain_Mushroom  +   688d ago
Who's down-voting? That's exactly what MS needs to do.
MikeMyers  +   688d ago
They down-vote because they can. That's how this place is run. You could say the Xbox One is black and get disagrees. Thankfully Microsoft is making the reputation model for Xbox Live better.


This could be a major improvement. You also won't get that swarm mentality you do here. Where people will down-vote everything because they don't like a certain member or a certain system.
DragonKnight  +   688d ago
Xbox One is black.
rainslacker  +   688d ago
I disagree that the X1 is black MikeMyers. In fact it is liquid black. There is a clear difference between black and liquid black, and you should be ashamed of yourself for being an Xbox fan and not knowing that difference. Since I am a Sony fan, I don't care what that difference is, but still I disagree with your assertion of the Xbox One's official color.


BTW: Just poking a little fun at the theme of these comments. I agree, the disagrees get out of hand sometimes. I'd prefer people say why they disagree.:)
Panthers  +   688d ago
I dont want the Xbox brand to die, but MS seems to want that. Everything about this is a slap in the face to Xbox fans.
CRAIG667  +   688d ago
1 very positive thing however is, I imagine me and ten friends/family will buy one and one game each,add each other as family members on our live profiles and instantly have 10 games in our collections... tahts like a £450 saving,Sony can't or won't top that...
Gravitic  +   688d ago
Agreed, its excellent. Xbox all the way. 10 PEOPLE can play that same shared single-player or local multiplayer game ALL at once, its fantastic, will save my household a fortune.
Skynetone  +   688d ago

you can make 10 accounts on the Xbox one {one master account} any of the ten accounts can play that game on that console {that's of course they don't lock the game to one account} if you log into that account from a different xbox one you can play it for one hour {you can only save progress if you log into the master account} two people can not be logged in from different Xbox ones at the same time and play multiplayer, two or more people can log into the same console,

to break it down, its a one hour demo from a different xbox one and you cant save progress unless your on the master account

ps+ lets you play every game release for one hour, its the exact same thing, except ms lets you only demo a game that a family member/friend has bought, not every game like ps+
#3.1.2 (Edited 688d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(2) | Report
CRAIG667  +   688d ago
@Skynetone you are wrong-look into it.
Skynetone  +   688d ago
I may be wrong bro but checking out his interview that's the conclusion ive come too

SilentGuard  +   688d ago
If you can share a game with ten "family members" how are the publishers saving money by going after used games? Seems to me the money made by attacking used games is far outwieghed by everyone sharing games with ten other people. I like the feature, but if they are doing that then why even bother with restricting used games. Seems kind of pointless
#3.1.5 (Edited 688d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report
CRAIG667  +   688d ago
@SilentGuard I can't get my head around it either, I wonder if DLC will be included, I mean Borderlands 2 for instance is great but if you want to further the experience the DLC is great(and massive), is that gonna be shared on the family library or is that somewhere they plan to recoup some revenue... who knows?
rainslacker  +   688d ago
I personally have a feeling that the 10 family/friends sharing feature isn't going to be quite what MS is hyping it up to be, namely due to what everyone has stated about publishers actually wanting that and how it is possibly worse than 2nd hand sales. The game sharing policy was abused on the PS3, which is why it's gone from 5 to 2 systems. I imagine this would be gain even more abuse since it's now being a heavily promoted/mentioned feature.

I could see it as you can share it for an hour or two, so people can try the game, but without restriction? I just can't imagine any publisher would want that.

I'm hoping it is what some people are assuming it is, that would be a tremendous feature, but I'm still skeptical that it will be that cool.

I also don't feel this feature warrants a mandatory 24 hour check-in for those that don't want one...which is what MS is using to justify it from current interviews.
#3.1.7 (Edited 688d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
CRAIG667  +   688d ago
Even if they were to implement any changes it would most likely be months after launch,one change at a time and they would probably not make a big deal out if the changes either...
Honest_gamer  +   688d ago
didn't know you get 2 free games with live a month that's good, free games are always great, just hope its not all really old games.

ps+ is GREAT wanted far cry 2 a year or so ago was £24 or so but it was free for ps+ at £8 (discounted price for a day) so i got it in the end i was able to get the game i wanted for £8 since then ive downloaded about 30 games a mix of vita (i dont have a vita get but ive been downloading them so when i do i have a back log ;-) ) ps3 and ps1 games, and when ps4 comes out i'll get ps4 games in there to, that's just great even more so that the price hasn't gone up
DragonKnight  +   688d ago
"didn't know you get 2 free games with live a month that's good, free games are always great, just hope its not all really old games."

Only until November, and really old games.
Honest_gamer  +   688d ago
aw what, was happy there i thought it was xbox's version of ps+ for xbox one, ah well :'(
CRAIG667  +   688d ago
Hopefully they see sense to carry that on with durango, although I can't see it happening to be honest...
DragonKnight  +   688d ago
Yeah, a lot of people thought it was going to be the same but it's not.

Example: Xbox 360 is actually the console that the games will show up on first, until November when the X1 launches. The first two games available are Assassin's Creed 2 and Halo 3. Two old games you can buy cheap if you haven't already beaten them.

PS+ will continue offering free games even with the PS4 and on the PS4 you get Drive Club for free day one if you're a PS+ member. That's the difference despite what the disagrees seem to think.
MikeMyers  +   688d ago
PSN+ is also known for offering 'really old games' for the PS3. On Vita those games are more enticing. For the PS4 Sony wants to make sure they can offer PS4 gamers something so they will be giving out Drivers Club but not the full game.

Microsoft should be doing more like the Plus model and giving out free stuff because right now they are not committed to doing that in the long term.
SilentGuard  +   688d ago
the 2 free games a month are only for the 360 and only until the release of the One
Grave  +   688d ago
I agree if they changed those policies I would actually start consider upgrading my 360, but the likelihood of it happening is probably super small. This article says it all with the Plus vs. Live comparison. Microsoft always just seems to be about the bottom-line, not the gamers who are fans of the system.
hazelamy  +   688d ago
get rid of the drm.

don't have restrictions on trading, if publishers want to do anything like that it's up to them,and it's up to me not to buy those titles, but when they "allow" it, don't put restrictions on trading, like them having to be on your friends list or only being able to trade a game once.
or only being able to trade it at "selected outlets", most likely the "evil" gamestop.

make kinect optional.

the fee for online play wouldn't stop me buying, it never stopped me buying a 360, i just played single player.

letting indies self publish would be better i believe, but lack of it wouldn't stop me buying.

so for me, there are three things they need to change before i consider buying an x1.

how would you even know if a game had already been traded once anyway?
yacinedelucia  +   688d ago
This article can be summed up in one sentence
"Transform the xbxone to a ps4" if you want to sell it
Captain_Mushroom  +   688d ago
LoL, pretty much, yeah.
yacinedelucia  +   688d ago
So i will simply get a ps4 if its really the ideal system.
Mikelarry  +   688d ago
we can suggest from now till the cows come home, but ms are still adamant their way is correct. i read an article recently and i think it was major nelson saying they will NOT be making any changes to the xbox one. i think know they what to do but are too proud to admit their mistakes which is about to cost them dearly
LeRise  +   688d ago
5 changes, and Xbone turns into a PS4.
True_Samurai  +   688d ago
But I already love X1
MoreRPG  +   688d ago
I don't see MS removing that 24 check-in if they do they gonna have to change the whole system

They should've kept the ability to install and share games via internet only to the digital games.
#13 (Edited 688d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
rainslacker  +   688d ago
I could see requiring the 24 hour check in if you CHOOSE to install your games on the hard drive for immediate play back. Otherwise I think just popping in the game disc could function as the verification for those that choose to play offline. It gives the choice back to the consumer. Connect for a better experience/more features, or don't connect because you can't/don't want to.

Honestly, this would go a long way in allowing them to achieve what they are hoping for for a connected console as most people that are able to connect would. For those that can't/won't they still make money off the games.

I'm fine with the install to the hard drive, they just only have one method of making it work that I have a problem with. I imagine this 24-hour check in is a remnant of their original used game policy, which I still believe the back-peddled on to push it onto the publisher once they saw the community outcry on it.
josephayal  +   688d ago
5 dreams
yacinedelucia  +   688d ago
maybe There Is one solution inorder to get Microsoft to sell it,s Xbox one.
Give it for free or something like 19$...and that,s a fair price i,m serious.
This thing won,t play offline .it will charge extra fees
For reselling your games. If it works they will cover
The cost of the machine in the first year.
But selling something i actully will not really own
For 499$ Is crazy.i hate Apple and the iPhone for
The same reason but they are not crazy enough
To make a mandatory online check every 24h or
Your iPhone/iPad will stop working.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

The Triumphs and Tragedies of E3's Past

2m ago - With just 40 days until E3 2015, we take a look at what makes this the must-watch video game even... | Culture

Tony Hawk games: Ranked from worst to best

2m ago - MMGN writes: It’s been a long time coming but we’re finally getting a new Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater.... | Xbox 360

Visit CGMagazine: The Culture of Games

Now - CGM is for the mature audience of comics and games that wants more out of their media than just a review score. | Promoted post

Extra Punctuation: Narrative Continuity of Fighting Games is Convoluted, Especially Mortal Kombat X

2m ago - Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw: The narrative continuity of an average one-on-one fighter is more con... | Industry

BioShock Dev Hiring for Next Game; Fun and Interesting AI Opponents Wanted

2m ago - Irrational Games aren't completely dead in the water; they're currently hiring some new talent fo... | PC

Phantasmal Early Access Impressions - CramG

6m ago - Some hands on impressions of the Steam Early Access version of Phantasmal which is a survival hor... | PC