Try our new beta! Click here
Submitted by TFXR 899d ago | opinion piece

E3 2013 Reveals Gaming Journalism Is Bulls#!t And Other Secrets You Didn't Know

FleshEatingZipper writes: "So you run a gaming web site. You have a decent following and good traffic and while you’re not an internet celebrity, you are willing to travel halfway across the country (or further) on your own time and dollar to cover the latest and greatest games for your readers. But even after building a network of contacts, you’ll simply be shut out by the biggest companies, even lied to. Coverage of the expo’s biggest events are ruled by an exclusive few, an inner circle – the IGNs, the GameTrailers and the Giant Bombs – and everyone else is shut out entirely. Unless you’re in the business of covering indie titles by small developers, gaming journalism boils down to being in an established circle of friends – the touted 300-400 full-time gaming journalists that this industry can support – having a lot of financial backing to kick your way in or being a major news outlet like ABC or Fox News. If you’re not any of those, you’re iced out of coverage at the highest tiers. Let me explain how getting your gaming site into E3 works." (E3)

midwestkel  +   899d ago
It sucks being low on the totem pole.
TFXR  +   899d ago
Yeah, it does. Yet so many people make the trek and get treated so badly.
Abriael  +   899d ago
Sorry, but there's only one solution to this. Instead of complaining about being treated unfairly, put your head down and work, work, work until you either burn out or get the recognition you think you deserve.

If you burn out before you get there, then maybe you simply aren't as good as you think. If you work on your site less than ten hours a day, you probably aren't doing enough.

(and I'm using "you" as a generic you, I don't know you, so don't take it personally).

Yes, game journalism is not a huggly, easy, friendly place for the faint of heart or the easily discouraged, and yes, some people have more access than others. Guess what? Most of those people earned it the same way everyone does. By getting doors slammed in their face over and over and over.

I've done it for 16 years, both on print and web, up and down, and I still get doors slammed in my face at times. It's entirely normal.

We're dealing with companies that are at E3, Gamescom, Tokyo Game Show and other conventions to gather visibility and ultimately make a buck. Their time is limited. Their developers can't see everyone in four days. So they'll give access to those that will give them the most visibility in return first, and then the others if there's room left.

Sounds cold and harsh and unfair? It is. It's called the reality of business.
Roll with the punches or don't roll at all.
#1.1.1 (Edited 899d ago ) | Agree(6) | Disagree(5) | Report
jsslifelike  +   899d ago

What a cop out. If you're a company and you accept appointments, you should be held to keeping them. Actually, more articles should be written/published like this so then end-consumer can learn to avoid the products of companies that can't even help being shady at the middle of the process. Now, if we could just get gamers to have any kind of balls to skip over these products out of principle, maybe this would change.
Abriael  +   899d ago
@jsslifelike: if you think the "end consumer" cares about the woes of a few writers, you're naive. Even more so to the point of avoiding getting the game they want.

That's an entirely laughable statement.

"hey gamers! boycott the game because they didn't let me into the booth!"


As much as I can sympathize with the predicament, part of being a professional also involves accepting that problems happen and taking it in stride, instead of taking it personally and shaking one's angry fist at the "privileged!", while thinking that saying " I'm media!" should open all doors.
#1.1.3 (Edited 899d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report
DragonKnight  +   899d ago
@Abriael: Have you ever once worked in gaming journalism? It has little to do with hard work today and more about partnerships and contacts which is why it sucks. Seriously, don't talk about what you don't know.
Garethvk  +   899d ago
While it is true the big guys get special treatment, we had EA, Microsoft, Activision, Bethesda, Konami, Disney, Sega, Sony, and a few others extend us invites to their events and well as proivides us booth tours. If you build a good reputation the invites will come.

But they are dead on. Not just at E3 others shows as well. I remember one company who promised and interview and full review. So we did site, radio, magazine and other coverage. Only after they got coverage did they say oh we cannot do that the person at the booth at no right to offer that. So I cut them off from all reviews and promotion. A year later they asked to meet with me at PAX. I sent an intern.
#2 (Edited 899d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
TFXR  +   899d ago
It wasn't so much the invites, it was the malicious fibbing, thinking we had a chance of seeing stuff. Then not being able to get on the show floor early to make the appointments you do have? C'mon...
#2.1 (Edited 899d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Garethvk  +   899d ago
You are dead on. We tend to make sure to do meetings with those who have treated us right in the past and new companies. I prefer drop ins for most but the top flight stuff. PAX is a good one to get to as it caters to press and fans. There are so many fans they often are more receptive plus being in Sep, this is often their last chance to get coverage from you before the holiday releases.
TFXR  +   899d ago
@Gareth Unfortunately, since this was a banner year with so many big unveilings, it was especially frustrating to not see many of those top games.
midwestkel  +   899d ago
It's really tough building a rep sometimes with the bigger companies because they want you to email a general PR email and you get a new person responding every time.
Garethvk  +   899d ago
Big issue now is that so many use PR firms and they have their list of must sends and then their favorites. They are famous for oh we do not have enough to go around. So thats why if they pull that three times in a row, they are out until it changes. No matter if your small or not, if you stop covering them they will come around. But the way the pr reps change so much makes it tough. When I started, even before the site you dealt with one or two people at the company directly. For some I have two or three agencies and about 6 contacts so its a pain to get things done.
TFXR  +   899d ago
Yeah, it's frustrating when even different games have different PR agencies at the same studio. It's just weird how they buffer all that now.
HarryMasonHerpderp  +   899d ago
I don't know why you had those problems. You would think they would be eager for EVERYONE to see their games and get as much exposure as possible, it makes no sense. Some of the suits running things behind the scenes just have no clue what they're doing and have no place in the videogame industry.
Garethvk  +   899d ago
I had started a Orginization/Union of sites for film reviews years ago. Big and small present a united front, share resources and such. Those who took part did well but sadly many took the resources, would not share and oddly enough, are all gone now. I would be up for doing this though for games.
TFXR  +   899d ago
Would be interesting to even set up an "indie media" booth, but I know those are crazy expensive.
Garethvk  +   899d ago
The key would be getting some sponsors who would pay to be shown. Like how some games or hardware share a space. See our new game X while taking a tour of the Y hardware booth.

You could always do what some indies do and hold meetings in a hotel near the venue.
Cueil  +   899d ago
and intern lolz
clank543  +   899d ago
Do we need that many more gaming journalists? I mean, I get everything I need to out of either Giantbomb or IGN. I never really go wanting for much else, honestly.
Virtual_Reality  +   899d ago
Just saying, but Giantbomb and or IGN does not cover entirely all the details in the industry of gaming.
MikeyDucati1  +   899d ago
lol man when it comes to IGN and Giantbomb, I rather have the little guy. You know why? Cause I know IGN is getting treated nicely and paid nicely to be nothing more than a big advertising site for the games they cover. An IGN editor get all pissed at me for comments I made about his co worker (or co-editor, however you want to call it) review on Dust 514. I felt he judged Dust 514 unfairly due to him being used to easy, pick up and play shooters like COD. This guy begins nitpicking my posts as if I was some 13 year old child. No, I've been around since Atari and it was quite apparent he had prerequisites for Dust that were formulated through previous FPS titles who follow each others' trends. He didn't judge it upon its own merit. So yes, I can appreciate a little variety instead of having the "big dogs" sell me a dream just so they can still get insider industry access and perks.
#4.2 (Edited 899d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
HarryMasonHerpderp  +   899d ago
Yeah you can't trust the big sites anymore.
There's just too much money involved for them to be 100% honest.
nismo15  +   899d ago
Xbones reveal was Bulls#!t know that much having to edit in clapping for its conference , desperation is a stinky cologne
Bathyj  +   899d ago
that wasn't necessary at all. totally off topic.

but I do like the super troopers reference.
Lokai  +   899d ago
I don't agree. I've gone from the perspective of a super small time gaming journalist to working on a medium sized gaming magazine, and while I wasn't able to get much done as small time journalist/blogger, we still had a few big companies entreat us and allow us to the same courtesy as the "elite" you seem to mention. Furthermore, now that I work at medium sized gaming website we have had few issues getting appointments with any of the game developers, and we are very far from something like Eurogamer, Giant Bomb or IGN. It had more to do with finding the appropriate emails, starting to try to find appointments months in advance of E3 and working hard to get all of that setup.
MikeyDucati1  +   899d ago
Interesting. I always wanted to get into video game journalism. But it seems as though you must "sell" some of your beliefs to do well in it. My opinion is definitely left field on plenty of occasions.
Cueil  +   899d ago
or you figure out a whay to get big... T&A helps... hot chicks doing the leg work probably would help as well... it's much harder to say no to some hot chick then it is to say no to a sweaty dude
MikeyDucati1  +   899d ago
lol so you're suggesting a pimping journalist? hilarious
Cueil  +   899d ago
I'm not the one complaining... sometimes you gotta do what you gotta do
cyguration  +   899d ago
It's crappy because it's based on exposure, not hard work.

IGN pays for the most exposure, so quite naturally IGN gets the most exclusives. The same thing applies to Polygon; they pay for exposure, so they get the exclusives.

Sorry to say, son, but we live in a plutocracy and the only way to fix it is to complain enough and get others to complain enough with you to incite some sort of change.
jazzking2001  +   899d ago
everything the article said is true
it has happened to me and its not a great feeling

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Nintendo Life - Dementium Remastered Review

13m ago - Dementium Remastered is a solid re-release. It makes some great changes that help make the game s... | 3DS

Tower Defense Game Alien Creeps TD New Update Adds New Languages

13m ago - TTP: Alien Creeps TD, the tower defense game developed by Outplay Entertainment, has recently rec... | iPhone

US Movie Releases to Look Out For in November

Now - Remember, remember, the films of November! It’s the time of year when the nights draw in, the year winds down and studios line up their most presti... | Promoted post

Miko Mole Review (PS4) - Punk and Lizard

14m ago - SJ Hollis writes for P&L: "Great for the kids or for killing a whole lot of time as there are mor... | PS4

Final Fantasy XIV & Heavensward for PS4 or PC ($19.99)

14m ago - GameStop offers Final Fantasy XIV: Heavensward for PlayStation 4 or Windows, bundled with a downl... | PC

99 Rockets Now Available On The App Store

15m ago - TTP: Alongside games featuring more traditional gameplay experience, several games offering uniqu... | iPhone