NWR's Les Thomas writes:
"When it comes down to it, this game's presentation is creepy. The static, text-based interactions with your horse instructor and the shop owner feature truly bizarre character depictions. The characters are rendered in an eerily realistic style, photographic almost. I wouldn't let my daughter around these weirdoes.
The simplistic design and superficial gameplay are sure to turn off everyone, including the young girl target group, and especially horse owners. The limited touch screen controls and shoddy conventional controls only make things worse. My Horse & Me is, in a word, plop."