Submitted by Donnieboi 518d ago | opinion piece

Opinion: Xbox One reveal proves Sony was right to conceal PS4

Microsoft's muddled presentation suggests it has been outmanoeuvred for the first time in the console war, writes Tim Clark. Pop quiz, hotshots: Who knows why Sony didn't show the actual box when it revealed PS4?

Put your hands down if you think the prototype wasn't ready. Of course it was ready. The console will be released this year, which means the case design will have been done a long time ago. It's not the sort of thing you can knock out on a Friday afternoon between crafty games of Candy Crush. (Culture, Industry, Microsoft, PS4, Sony, Xbox One)

MasterCornholio  +   518d ago | Well said
I found it horrible that they showed off the XBONER and they didnt demonstrate any games on it. I mean sure the conference was mostly about digital television and sports but they could have had a live gameplay demo of something.

Well makes the Major Nelson look stupid for tweeting this.

"Announce a console without actually showing a console? That's one approach"

How about announcing a console without showing any games?
#1 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(94) | Disagree(7) | Report | Reply
BlackTar187  +   518d ago
Announce a Video game console and show no gameplay footage
Shadow Flare  +   518d ago | Funny
Rent a crowd to clap because the real crowd don't want to

That's one way to do it
#1.1.1 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(88) | Disagree(2) | Report
Blackdeath_663  +   518d ago
well you get criticised for showing games but not the console, and you get criticised for showing the console but no games you can't please everyone i guess. what killed the xbox for me anyways is what surfaced after the conference, like no used games, needs kinect to function, needs to be connected to internet every 24hrs, cannot change or upgrade HDD etc...
#1.1.2 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(20) | Disagree(2) | Report
blitz0623  +   518d ago | Funny
Xbox, turn on PS4
darthv72  +   518d ago
its like...
they switched places this time around.

It had long been rumored that during the dev of the 360, they upped their specs at the last minute to compete with sony.

in the end both the ps3 and 360 were comparatively matched in terms of specs. PS3 had the better cpu and 256mb system ram / 256mb video ram, 360 had the better gpu and 512mb unified ram. with ms showing first

so now, both ps4 and xb1 have 8 core custom AMD cpu and 8gb of ram. sony upped their ram from 2 to 4 then ultimately to 8gb gddr5 where as ms seemed to have been set with going with 8gb ddr3 from the start. with sony showing first this time around.

this is a pretty good read actually: http://www.eurogamer.net/ar...
MikeMyers  +   518d ago
"Quote from the article:

"Take a look at the third question again. Do you know what Sony's policy for pre-owned games is going to be? I don't. The best CVG's bloodhound of an editor could extract from Michael Denny, Sony's VP of Worldwide Studios after the PS4 reveal, was some bluster about doing "the right thing" by consumers and developers. Cool! Beyond that, Sony has largely got away scot-free ever since."

Exactly. Sony is now using Microsoft to try and answer these hard questions. Both of them won't say yet. So don't start saving for that PS4 just yet, they too might have something up their sleeve, and why not? They already adopted online passed and have DRM restrictive games on PSN.
SirBradders  +   518d ago
Sony are smart now all eyes are back on them cos we know what the xbox looks like and we have seen just a small portion of games from the ps4 and i actually do wanna see the design even though its no importance.
One4U  +   517d ago
i cant wait for e3 , naughty dogs uncharted team is like almost 2 yrs into development ! cant wait for the other devs too !
turgore  +   518d ago
Wait till E3.
onyoursistersback  +   518d ago
Ever gamer is waiting for E3, why are people bringing it up...?! O wait, you still think Mircosoft is gana "wow" us?! Haha
Shadow Flare   518d ago | Trolling | show
majiebeast  +   518d ago
Please be excited.
Killabites  +   518d ago
Don't live in hope my friend.
Y_5150  +   518d ago
I say that for the Wii U. It's going to get better for the system. But PS4 is going there with some momentum and I bet if it doesn't end up like 2005 E3 reveal of the PS3. Then it would be fantastic!
AnimeAvenger  +   518d ago
I don't know why your getting disagrees. If MS went all out, what the fuck would they show at E3? I will be waiting with you man.

LOL, just remember there wasn't really any wow factor at the PS4 announcement.
plaZeHD  +   518d ago
Oh wow ouch
sway_z  +   518d ago
MasterCornholio you are a TROLL...


'Nope because XBOX fans are extremely happy with the direction that Microsoft is going with the Xbox brand.

Seriously if they didnt like it then they wouldnt have supported Kinect which sold boat loads of units'

sourav93  +   518d ago
I just looked at his past 10 comments, they're all negative comments towards xbox, just the one one here. So I don't see how he's a fake. I don't condone doing what he's doing, but he's definitely not in 2 minds about it.
sway_z  +   518d ago
Ok, I take your word for it Sourav93...
#1.5.2 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report
Maddens Raiders  +   518d ago
It's really quite simple -

Sony is doing amazing things.

Related image(s)
#1.6 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(13) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
Y_5150  +   518d ago
Picture never gets old.
maniacmayhem  +   518d ago
I don't even think Sony had a live gameplay demo. So why expect MS too?
Raccoon  +   518d ago
Shut the hell up! We expected games and core specs not TV, NFL and 5 billion transitors....
#1.7.1 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(21) | Disagree(0) | Report
S_C  +   518d ago
Killzone: Shadow Fall ,need i say any more
maxgamehard  +   518d ago
Knack was a live game demo as well.
maniacmayhem  +   518d ago
Don't remember Knack so that must tell me something and Killzone from what I remember looked like a demo as well since I didn't actually see anyone playing.
Adva  +   518d ago
What a nut job. Killzone was LIVE, Knack was live (On the vita aswell), pretty sure Drive was demoed though not sure about that title. Watch_dogs aswell.
HeroLv9  +   518d ago
Jimmy Fallon played killzone Shadow Fall on his show...go watch it on Youtube.
raytraceme  +   518d ago
Killzone shadowfall was played by jimmy fallon LIVE and it was gameplay because the other guy with jimmy sucked at it.

also knack showed off gameplay on both the ps4 and the vita with remote play.

And we expected ms to because they are showing the reveal 3 months after the ps4 reveal. Which could prove the leaks about x1's developement being delayed.

And don't give me bs that is was played on a pc because we actually know the full whereabouts of the ps4's architecture while we got lame vague specs from MS.

Guerilla also has a full slideshow presentation on how kz:sf was made on the ps4 MS has nothing.
#1.7.7 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(12) | Disagree(0) | Report
maxgamehard  +   518d ago

I am sorry but i just have to.

Qrphe  +   518d ago
>dis amount of denial

Turn off the damage control
The_Troll_Whisperer  +   518d ago
One phrase: Killzone: Shadow Fall

I have spoken

(P.S. you usually defend Sony...)
they should have never shown the box. Not even when e3 comes. It's ugly.
bestofthebest  +   518d ago
it looks like my cable box
One4U  +   517d ago
well it is the X"box"
Biohazard8860  +   518d ago
Major nelson's is microsoft's puppet.
FamilyGuy  +   518d ago
"with that big hardware reveal still tucked under its skirt"

I lmmfao at this line
horndog  +   518d ago
So they didnt show forza or remedy's new game?? True that ghost and ea's are third party games but still games never the less. I hough it wasmade clear tht e3 would be about games. Look forward to it
Prcko  +   517d ago
i agree
Majin-vegeta  +   518d ago
Xbox:Sony where's your console?

Sony:Yea but what's the point in showing a console if you ain't got no games to demonstrate??
#2 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(57) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
ronaldk   518d ago | Spam
yesmynameissumo  +   518d ago
Sony's focus was on...wait for it...GAMES. Coming out with that as the only topic (outside of tech specs, etc.) showed PlayStation as a brand is about video games. Microsoft showed the world the Xbox brand is about whatever can make Microsoft money. Glad it played out the way it did personally.
esemce  +   517d ago
Yeah now us real non fanboy gamers don't have to worry about choosing between two consoles at launch it's simple.

Hate Activision
Hate EA Sports
Hate Kinect
Hate TV
Hate Paying for simple MP
Hate Timed exclusives and dlc
Hate the lack of exclusives MS has given us since Kinect.

That's a lot of hate and I've still got some more.
Themba76  +   517d ago
don't forget Hate COD
cleft5  +   518d ago
Dude the xbox reveal proved you shouldn't make a console look like a betamax player. Seriously, what was Microsoft design team thinking. If Apple teaches us anything it's that you don't sacrifice form, you figure out a way to make form and function work.
#5 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(13) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
xk77  +   518d ago
whether you like it or not, Xbox will still sell because the other audience will like the DVR features more
cyhm3112  +   518d ago
I am not so sure about this, are people going to spend $400 to $500 dollars just to buy a TV box with inferior gaming aspects, a tv box with better functionality than xbone probably can be bought for under $100.
Narutone66  +   517d ago
That's one expensive remote control. You have to keep paying monthly fees to use.
maniacmayhem  +   518d ago
I mean, what were you people expecting it to look like? It's a console not modern art, it'll sit under your tv probably in most entertainment centers in some compartment. I thought it looked fine, nothing fancy or extravagant. Simple and elegant in its minimalist approach.

All good.
sparta76  +   518d ago
Elegant!? Lol
DigitalRaptor  +   518d ago
Elegant... yeah cause VHS players are what you would describe as elegant.
maniacmayhem  +   518d ago
Looks nothing like a VHS player. I get it, it's the internet and try to be funny is hip but this is my opinion. Sleek, black, with cool LED(?) lights, one logo at the end, nothing (so far) blinking, flashing or counting down as an old school VCR would do so no VCR player is not how I would describe as elegant.
Shadow Flare   518d ago | Trolling | show
Z501  +   518d ago
Been discussing this with friends since the Feb 20th reveal. Sony caught MS off guard. The ironic part is Sony is STILL putting out exclusiveS currently. With a new console dropping this year. What's Microsoft's excuse?
Why o why  +   518d ago
2 differing cultures towards gaming and their customers. One uses the hit em fast and hard then switched to the skim the hurdle approach where as the other adopted the slow and steady approach that has continued throughout the gen. 3 new core ips this year alone....vs none.

Funny thing is I've heard people make excuses for why one of the console manufacturers has slowed done. Using the impending gen as the reason. You woulda thought they would of at least had 1 gameplay footage ready with the hiatus ms's studios have had. They cant all be making motion control games
#8.1 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(8) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
riddick33  +   518d ago
Sony must be shaking like a leaf in fear.

I wish i watched PS4 press conference with more appreciation at least they showd some respect to the gaming industry, after Microsoft's TV DVR peace.
#9 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(9) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
OlgerO  +   518d ago
The sony press conference was absolutely amazing when you compare, I think im going to rewatch it today.
One4U  +   517d ago
i did that yesterday , no joke after watching the xbox reveal , sonys conference looked even better
JAM_brz  +   518d ago
The things are going in the wrong way.

Once upon a time in my life, I used to have a game device that plays games. Then some time later I had a game device that can connect to the internet. Then now I have a TV device that I can sometimes play some games, even that I don't be so sure.
Z501  +   518d ago
Noticed the last 4 years it's "wait til E3" from xbox supporters. It's NEVER wait til TGS or wait til GamesCon. How come you don't hear ps supporters saying wait til E3? hmmm
agentxk  +   518d ago
That happened to be the rallying cry for Vita supporters last year.
Z501  +   518d ago
'They' also said TGS. It wasn't just a once per year thing. How long has the Vita been on the market? You might have a point if Vita owners WILL be saying the same thing 4 years in a row. See my point.
TheGreatBambinoX  +   518d ago
I wonder what the people in charge of the Xbox One are thinking right now? I wish I could be there.
FrigidDARKNESS  +   518d ago
yhe only thing it proves is how inferior sony is when it comes to technology and designing OS.
boyh com[anies have the same goals to win the living room its thaat MS is doing it better,
#13 (Edited 518d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(16) | Report | Reply
scotchmouth  +   517d ago
You can't even type.
Shacojin  +   517d ago
Was it too much to ask for actual gameplay footage.. for at least 1 game... just one?
Jihaad_cpt  +   517d ago
Microsoft's presentation in a nutshell: TV,TV,TV,TV... Kinect. I jest
ziggurcat  +   517d ago
i don't think showing the hardware has anything to do with the complaints people are having with the new xbox since the problems are all on the software side of things.

the same complaints would have happened even if MS didn't show the box.
Saleem101  +   517d ago
Block used games try to fight that argument my my tables has turn for the better greed is going kill Microsoft...
dollison27  +   517d ago
And the controller runs on AA batteries...WTF? Replacement controllers I would guess will be about $60 -70 and we don't get a rechargeable battery...stupid
MakiSaad2  +   517d ago
Microsoft kill yourself

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

28 Greatest Video Game Villains Of All Time

8m ago - Andrew Ryan, Imran Zakhaev, Wheatley – the modern era of gaming has seen its fair share of memora... | Culture

6 Things Alien: Isolation Nails, and 5 It Misses

11m ago - Here’s a list of things Alien: Isolation excels at… and what it could have done better. | PC

Does Bayonetta 2’s hypersexuality cross the line, or is it camp?

12m ago - AV Club: Joe Keiser weighed in on Bayonetta 2 this week. He enjoyed its silky smooth combat and b... | Wii U

Mario Kart 8 Analysis - Yoshi Circuit DLC Trailer (Secrets & Hidden Details)

13m ago - GameXplain: "We analyze the Mario Kart 8 Yoshi Circuit DLC trailer to uncover all the secrets it... | Wii U

Getting started in Archeage

Now - Quick overview from Curse on everything you need to get going in Archeage. | Promoted post

The Evil Within review | Times of India

13m ago - If you aren't at all afraid of taking up a challenge and love getting scared out of your pants,... | PC