GamesRadar: "Call of Juarez: Gunslinger offers an entertaining romp through a stylized Western world. The famous name dropping doesn't add much spice to Silas' revenge story and their gameplay implementation is even less memorable. But where Gunslinger falters with the legends of the West, it succeeds in creating a score-based shooter with an interesting, constantly morphing environment and charming narration. If you're looking for a Wild West story that can stand on the shoulders of the legends it houses, Gunslinger may be a let down. But those who want a solid Western shooter with exhilarating mechanics, you'll want to give this game a try."