70°
Submitted by Relientk77 472d ago | opinion piece

Are the E3 critics ever right?

GamesRadar - E3 is an event filled with promises. Gamers congregate in Southern California every year to sit in awe of the new innovations companies show off. Even more sit at home and watch coverage of the event; hosts killing time with more not-our-hands-on looks at new and shiny games. At the end of the event, a select few game journalists from leading media outlets come together to vote for what they believe the best game of the show to be, by way of the Game Critics Awards. (Culture, E3)

GalacticEmpire  +   472d ago
The only one on that list that is almost unanimously GOTY and best of show at E3 is uncharted 2 and rightly so. It's still my personal top contender for game of the generation and I'd be willing to bet a lot of other peoples too.
Soldierone  +   472d ago
Sometimes yes, sometimes no. I say that for various reasons.

If you attend, you will know that a lot of the games shown off during conferences etc, are not playable at E3 itself. Then there are ones that are playable, but are held behind closed doors and don't really get a lot of these nominations. For example when Sony unveiled the vita, at the conference it was basically free game to it, but at E3 it was more of a "here touch it while I watch over you" deal.

I think during those years when several AAA games are actually present and being a part of the show, the awards matter. Other times companies like EA just do a great job of being the center of attention by providing their games, while others are still somewhat hiding them. I remember Medal of Honor won all kinds of shooter awards while Ghost Recon and COD were in a closed doors environment.
admiralvic  +   472d ago
The real question is, does it really matter?

E3 shows off early / tech demos and merely gives you a small taste of what was possible from the game. The problem is that we don't know what or how much a game will change between point A and B, which could be minimal like Borderlands 2 or vast like Aliens: CM (which without a doubt gave the impression of being better than it was). This is all no different than seeing a really good TV commercial. I can't tell you how many times I've been mislead by a movie commercial, only to find out I saw the best scene or the ad gave the impression of it being a completely different movie than it was. Furthermore, what you see at E3 isn't always a clear indication of what is going to happen or even every title out there.

Some random examples off the top of my head from last year...

- Papo and Yo was playable, yet there were plenty of more deserving PSN titles (in my opinion).
- Anarchy Reigns was not playable at the Sega booth, but Virtua Fighter 5 The FInal Showdown was (which was free with Plus, so who cares what I thought of it).
- Rayman Legends had a rather lengthy and well done demo, yet we will probably see it again at this years E3.
- Lost Planet 3 had an interesting boss battle, yet that constantly gets delayed.
-I don't believe The Walking Dead was there on any level, yet this won GOTY from a number of sites.

So yeah...
Kingthrash360  +   472d ago
critics are never right.
SegaGamer  +   471d ago
@kingthrash360

You're right, critics suck ass. I can't stand them and i don't know why anyone does, make up your own minds if something is rubbish or not. I can guarantee that over half the games i own critics hate.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

PAX Prime: Hands-On Preview of Tales from the Borderlands | GamersNexus

8m ago - GamersNexus: "Here’s a recap of what I came across in my PAX Prime demo / preview with Tales from... | PC
40°

The Importance of Marketing Bayonetta 2

8m ago - gamrReview's Stephen C Barrett: "The first game developed by Platinum Games for Wii U, The Wonder... | Wii U
30°

Nintendo’s New 3DS – Here’s Why You Should Be Excited

8m ago - More than just the size and style redesign of the 3DS XL, the New models are a half step toward b... | 3DS
20°

Mega-Sized 'Master Control' Gameplay Trailer Released for Civilization: Beyond Earth

8m ago - Hardcore Gamer: The new “Master Control” video was shown for the first time moments ago at the Fi... | PC
Ad

Need Cash? (US Only)

Now - How would it feel to have your money struggles solved by this time tomorrow? We give fast loans from $100-$10,000+, and repayment terms up to 60 mo... | Promoted post
20°

PAX 14 - Tinseltown Rampage in Dead Island 2 Demo (Twinfinite)

8m ago - Spec Ops: The Line developer Yager has taken the reins for Dead Island 2, and even at this stage... | PC