90°
Submitted by wound 810d ago | article

Playing the Piracy Card – Game Dev Tycoon

Game Dev Tycoon developers tried to hold up a mirror to the gamers that pirated their game, but a deeper level of promotion was actually on their mind. (Dev, Game Dev Tycoon, PC)

Mikeyy  +   810d ago
I'm going to wager a guess that the same thing happens to Game Developers that happens to musicians.

Singer "A" Records Record "B". Record "B" Sells less then expected. Record lable takes their full expected share from the sales of Record "B". Then gives a small bit to singer "A" citing that Piracy has swalled all of the "Profits". Singer "A" then goes on a rant about how Piracy is ruining the business, while the Record Company throws more wood into the fire.

I'll wager the same happens between game developers and their publishers.
dktxx2  +   810d ago
"While this experiment may have shown a high “piracy” rate for one day, it does not give the Greenheart devs A RIGHT to act AS THOUGH they are OWED for their WORK."

WHAT!?
itz_zombies  +   810d ago
something about the author screams "avast ye scallywags"
Anon1974  +   810d ago
A few problems with this article.
"I saw no plans by the devs to post the game on Gamestop Impulse, Indie City, The Humble Store, Beamdog, GamersGate, or any other service that deals with indie titles. This game was not being advertised well, despite all the venues out there for distribution."

That's a pretty big assumption right there. For all you know, they could have approached every single one of those sites and simply been turned down. There are thousands upon thousands of new indie games out there. These sites don't just simply launch every single new game that comes out. I've personally pitched one of my company's finished indie game to 4 or those sites you mentioned for distribution and only ever heard back from one, Desura. The answer was no.

It's irrelevant that they leaked the "cracked" version of their game. If they hadn't, someone else would have and the end result would have been the same, with the exception that the pirates would be playing the full version and not the "cracked" version they put out.

You're just splitting hairs here. What does it matter that the idea has been done before? You think this is the first game that has borrowed from another? And they simply blogged about their experience on their web site. 99% of indie blogs out there are completely ignored. There was no way they could have known that this experiment would catch the media's attention. I blogged about the 95% piracy rate my studio's last game was experiencing on Android, and it didn't attract any attention. They just went about it cleverly, but there was no guarantee that experiment would pay off for them.

What does it matter how they advertised, how they distributed distributed the game, or similarities to some other game? At the end of the day, two developers made a game that thousands were enjoying and only a handful had paid for. That's the cold, hard fact of the matter, and a fact that every single indie developer out there has to struggle with on a daily basis. You seem to have completely and utterly missed the point of this whole exercise. You're like the guy who says the rape victim was asking for it because she dressed provocatively.

If you don't think developers deserve compensation for their hard work when people enjoy their product, you have no business writing about video games.
#3 (Edited 810d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
itz_zombies  +   810d ago
100% agreed
dyjefeliqed03   810d ago | Spam
matgrowcott  +   810d ago
It was pretty obviously a publicity thing. The article turned up on their own site days after release. Nobody in their right mind considered this a win against piracy. They uploaded the cracked version themselves to get their work mentioned on as many gaming sites as possible with only a little effort.

There's nothing wrong with that. It was a funny move. But I imagine there was a "proper" crack within hours.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

Beta Data: July 31, 2015

2m ago - MMOGames' weekly look at Beta, Alpha, and Kickstarter events and news in the MMO industry. The mo... | PC
30°

Fallout 4: QuakeCon Impressions | Gamereactor UK

3m ago - GR-UK writes: "If you're part of those who didn't get enough even with the extensive Fallout 4 pr... | PC
Ad

Devil May Cry 4 Special Edition (XB1) Review

Now - Ken revisits the fourth entry in the saga of Dante (and Nero). | Promoted post
20°

Olympia Rising PC Review - Morbid Play

3m ago - Whistler writes, "If there was one thing old school platformers of the 8 and 16 bit era proved it... | PC
30°

The must play ‘Rare Replay’ games

4m ago - Rare is one of gaming’s most beloved developers, with a plethora of highly praised games througho... | Xbox One
40°

The 15 Best Games Since 2000, Number 7: Resident Evil 4

6m ago - USgamer: "Resident Evil 4 is the best goddamn game in the series. Full stop. Sadly, I'm not al... | Culture