Submitted by fathoms 877d ago | opinion piece

Is It Really Fair To Blame Xbox For The Fall Of Final Fantasy?

A lot of old-school Final Fantasy fans want to point an accusatory finger at Microsoft and the Xbox. It sounds stupid but is there a kernel of truth...? (Culture, Final Fantasy XIII)

Snookies12  +   877d ago
I'm not blaming Xbox for the fall of Final Fantasy. That was Square Enix that brought themselves down. However, FFXIII the first game in the series was most definitely cut down because of the 360 version. They even said they had an entire second game's worth of content they ended up not using.

Now, would that extra content have made XIII a better game? Who knows... Either way, SE didn't give us a game worthy of the Final Fantasy name. It was a good RPG, just not a good Final Fantasy.
#1 (Edited 877d ago ) | Agree(15) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
dedicatedtogamers  +   877d ago
It definitely was Square-Enix's fault for being so shady. Sure, Microsoft benefited by having FF13 go multiplat, but it's not like they said to SE "hey, make the game s***. Cut it down and make it linear". It was SE's fault for developing the game as a PS3 exclusive and then switching it over so late in the development cycle.
MaxXAttaxX  +   877d ago
It's definitely Square Enix's fault.
No one forced them to change the formula so radically to try to appeal to a different gaming audience that likes shooters and action games and turn the game into something that could barely even be considered an RPG with a 30hr tutorial.

And no one forced them to put the game on Xbox either.
The 360 versions of XIII and XIII-2 only managed to sell 30% of total PS3 sales. Not even half. So I hope it was worth it, SE.
#1.1.1 (Edited 877d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(3) | Report
Pozzle  +   877d ago
Exactly. I think a lot of gamers blame Microsoft for FFXIII's failings because then they don't have to admit that such a long-standing and well-known developer like Square Enix might just be losing their touch. But if other developers can make amazing multiplatform games, then why can't Square Enix? There have been some great JRPGs this generation (some even on Wii, which is a much less powerful console than 360 and PS3), so there's really no reason that Square Enix should struggle with making a multiplatform game (especially this late into the generation).

Maybe I'm just being pessimistic, but I can't imagine the cut content would have vastly improved the actual quality of the game. IMO most of FFXIII's problems were in the strange design choices and how the story was written/played out.
OmegaSlayer  +   877d ago
Only Square is guilty.
Qrphe  +   877d ago
Square Enix made all the decisions from the beginning. If there was content cut from the PS3 version, SE was also to blame, not Xbox.
majiebeast  +   877d ago
Square enix is to blame. Wada made stupid decisions this entire generation with Star ocean 4,Last remnant and the final fantasy franchise. The Final Fantasy name is B rank at this point next gen less Toriyama waifus or just alot less Toriyama.

Ofcourse it didnt help that the 360 only used DVD.
Godmars290  +   877d ago
Not just this generation: the mistakes really started to happen when the worlds each game took place on were extended.

Yes, given FF10's ending there was certainly excuse to go into more depth - despite what most thought of Tidus - but the direction FF10-2 forgot all but the most trivial aspects of the original story. Became contradiction.
Qrphe  +   877d ago
The Last Remnant became one of the best games I've played on PC in the last years; too bad the 360 version was crippled to begin with.
wishingW3L  +   877d ago
I blame Toriyama because the game was beyond bad.
Pozzle  +   877d ago
He butchered the Parasite Eve series too. :(
Prodigy-X  +   877d ago
Its both Square Enix & Microsoft fault.
Godmars290  +   877d ago
Square's just become hopelessly out of touch with its creative side.

I have little to no hope for vs13 or whatever its called.
TheColbertinator  +   877d ago
I blame Square for making such awful decisions this gen with FF.

I blame Sony for making the PS3 incredibly difficult and expensive to make games for.RPG developers in Japan had no budget capable of making PS3 games before 2010.
animegamingnerd  +   877d ago
i never blamed the 360 cause the 360 can hold massive and great looking games like red dead and skyrim on 1 disc square just honestly didn't knew what they were doing with final fantasy 13
DOMination-  +   877d ago
Those games didn't have 1080p cgi cutscenes. Open world games that use the in game engine for cutscenes are generally not that big.

Just Cause 2 for example is only 6gb and Skyrim is 3.8gb. FF13 didnt been to be linear it just needed to not have cutscenes that were several gigs each but they couldn't very well ditch them at that point in development because they're so expensive to make. The 360 port at the point in the development cycle was a bad decision
animegamingnerd  +   877d ago
yeah final fantasy 13 really need didn't to 7gb just for 1 CGI cutscene or be the last looking JRPG it just need to be a good game i can several JRPG'S that look no where near as good as 13 but in termes of gameplay kicks the crap out of it

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Skylanders Superchargers Review | GodisaGeek

48m ago - Dan Naylor: "That you need all three types of vehicle to fully enjoy Superchargers isn’t really a... | PC

Samurai Warriors 4-II Review I Hey Poor Player

48m ago - Hey Poor Player's Adam Foster writes - "This time, Tecmo Koei have made a game that is not a sequ... | PC

Top US Releases in Cinemas This October

Now - October is upon us and, as award season starts to gear into life, a whole slew of top movie releases hit US cinemas; amongst which will see a retur... | Promoted post

Stairs - PC Review | Chalgyr's Game Room

48m ago - Chalgyr's Game Room writes: Stairs does an excellent job of setting the stage and creating an... | PC

The original Earthworm Jim team ‘would be up’ for a sequel

51m ago - Game designer Nick Bruty reckons the original team behind the classic Sega Genesis platformer sti... | Retro

Defense Grid 2: Enhanced VR Edition to Include Exclusive Content

52m ago - VRFocus reports on the confirmation that the forthcoming Oculus Rift version of Defense Grid 2 wi... | PC