A game that kills you for leaving your character in darkness for too long isn't to be played. A game that dares insinuate a character into a long-running show and hopes you didn't notice he wasn't around before can't be trusted to replicate the experience of the show.
A game that offers all the TV characters but gives you impersonators for the voices is a cheap, nasty rip-off. That is Lost Via Domus. Avoid it like you would Season 4 spoilers.