100°
Submitted by TheGameScouts 504d ago | review

Deadly Premonition: Director's Cut Review | The Game Scouts

Tin Salamunic: Deadly Premonition is ugly, broken, confusing, demented…and also one of the most extraordinary experiences of the decade. It disregards all conventional quality standards and plays by its own rules. It’s juvenile and careless, yet provoking and immersive. It fails as a traditional video game, but succeeds as a work of fiction. How much of its absurdity is intentional remains unclear, but this exceptionally orchestrated disaster has to be judged on its own merits. As one of those rare cases where the failures emphasize the strengths, Deadly Premonition achieves its individuality by being the Ed Wood of gaming – it’s so bad (well, more like odd) that it’s brilliant. Originally released as an Xbox 360 exclusive, Deadly Premonition has garnered a cult following and the reviews have been amusingly split amongst critics. While many despised the near broken gameplay and nauseating visuals, others praised its unique ruggedness as the holy grail of this generation. The Director’s Cut hopes to iron out some of the rough edges and reach the PS3 audience, but are the improvements enough to stretch beyond the game’s fan base or do they compromise the integrity of the original? (Deadly Premonition: The Director’s Cut, PS3, Xbox 360) 10/10

Wagz22  +   504d ago
I can't wait to platinum in this game!
Godmars290  +   504d ago
Can't help but feel that this score shows how pointless/counter productive numbered reviews are.

Anyone who knows anything about the game knows it has bad graphics and gameplay mechanics. That its the cult level story and presentation which makes it worth playing.
ifritAlkhemyst  +   504d ago
I don't understand how this game gets the raves it does. It is a bad game, every reviewer knocks it for shitty mechanics and what not.

Then they find the storyline charming or some nonsense, that suddenly makes the game 8-10/10 worthy? Game reviewers need to cut stuff like plot and characters out and focus on the actual gameplay, you know, what matters.
InTheLab  +   504d ago
I know dude. What makes a game, a game, is broken on every level. When you HAVE to be a fan of a crap show from 20 years ago to enjoy this game... Add that to the extremely poor presentation...

There's no way this thing is a ten.
BanBrother  +   503d ago
You must not have seen Twin Peaks. If you think it is crap, then you must be the Michael Bay generation. TV shows these days could only dream of being one-tenth as good as Twin Peaks.

So people are angry he over-valued the story? What about a game like CoD that has bad graphics and story, but gets away because of game-play? Minecraft?

Story is important to some people, me included. We are entitled to an opinion. If you think game-play is all that matters, don't bother with a games campaign, just play the crappy obligatory horde mode then.
InTheLab  +   503d ago
Yeah...forgot Twin Peaks went on for what, 5 or 6 seasons because it was riveting television. It was crap and got canceled.

As for your point about the story, I'm only agreeing with the op on how broken the game is. I do place gameplay at a higher value but I understand we all play for different reasons.
Pozzle  +   494d ago
Twin Peaks didn't get cancelled because it was crap. It got cancelled because the network forced the writers to solve the show's main mystery (Laura Palmer's murder) mid-way through season 2, then ABC shifted the show's timeslot multiple times, so the rating's dropped. It was shitty network decisions that eventually killed the show.

But if you think it was crap, you're probably too young to remember just how massively popular it was when it first aired. It was one of the highest rating shows of the early 90s. You couldn't go anywhere without hearing someone's bizarre theories on what was going on in the show. Heck, there was even a massive fan campaign to get it back on the air. It was a bloody good show.
#3.1.3 (Edited 494d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
R_aVe_N  +   504d ago
I am really confused...

Graphics 1.0
Gameplay 2.0
Value 10.0
Sound 10.0

how on earth does this come out to being a 10/10 game?
TheGameScouts  +   504d ago
I understand everyone's confusion about the score, but this game can't by judged by traditional scoring standards. It's like saying Picasso's paintings were ugly..therefore they are unworthy of praise and appreciation. That's simply not the case and you guys just have to check it out to truly appreciate its bizarre and unique nature. :)
#5 (Edited 504d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
thirtyandnerdy  +   504d ago
I'm trying really hard to like this game-- I've been playing a bit every day. I love the characters and can easily get past the visuals; my biggest problem with the game so far is that gameplay-wise it's a chore. It's just not fun to do much of anything in the world. Shooting, driving, load times when peeking in windows-- every single thing you do is sluggish. I can see the charm and brilliance in the title though, so here's to maybe falling in sync with it.
Kyosuke_Sanada  +   504d ago
It's a great game in my opinion. I won't say a perfect game because no game is perfect but the personality of the game coupled with the horror concepts makes it so damn infectious.

I consider it a must buy not 10 out of 10 material...
Heisenburger  +   504d ago
I have been loving the game. People here whining clearly haven't played it.

Once I got used to the driving it was smooth sailing.

I use the map as I do normal directions. Turn on the second left, then take a right kind of thing.

Luckily I don't share the burden of having to put a number* on my experience so far.

I have just been having a blast.
#8 (Edited 504d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

New Mighty No.9 Beta Gameplay Footage - Stage 2 & Boss Battle

28m ago - The Mighty No.9 Beta was just updated and this time we get to play on the underwater stage of Mig... | PC
20°

5 Games That Will Genuinely Make You Cry

28m ago - CCC Says: "I have been playing Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright and Danganronpa 2 lately, and... | Culture
20°

CCG Review: Lethal League

28m ago - GuG Writer, Ryan Thompson does a review of Lethal League for the PC. | PC
20°

Casual Monday: Game Dev Story

28m ago - Hardcore Gamer: Game Dev Story by Kairosoft Co. is a fun mobile game where you create and manage... | Mobile
Ad

Celebrate the new TV season with Filmwatch

Now - With the 2014-2015 TV season right around the corner, come join us on Filmwatch as we celebrate and give all you TV lovers something to enjoy! | Promoted post
30°

The Gears Game That Never Was

29m ago - Readers Gambit has a brief look at the gears game that never quite came to fruition. | Xbox 360
Related content from friends