140°
Submitted by crazypenguin08 624d ago | video

Is Bioshock Infinite Too Violent?

Violence in video games is without a doubt the biggest issue that our industry - and this genre in particular - faces at the moment. With horrifying tragedies of wanton gun violence cropping up in the headlines on a weekly basis, everyone needs a scapegoat. The finger of blame has to point somewhere, so why not at video games? (BioShock: Infinite, PC, PS3, Xbox 360)

Attached Video
crazypenguin08  +   624d ago
Of course not. I agree with the guy in the video, it's appropriate.
Derekvinyard13  +   624d ago
This guy should play manhunt
Naate  +   624d ago
I think violence in games needs to be justified. If it's violent just for the shock value, it has no place in this industry.

If the story is gritty and the violence is purposeful, I'm definitely interested. Spec Ops: The Line is the perfect example, there is some tough content in that game - stuff that makes you cringe to see and doesn't leave you when you stop playing.

But it served a grander purpose and, for that, it doesn't bother me.
rasputiny  +   624d ago
I think it had the perfect amount of violence! Wouldn't of wanted it any other way!
SmallKiwi  +   624d ago
I wouldn't say I was bothered by the violence in the game, especially since I didn't spend much of the game executing melee finishers. The violence at the beginning is clearly a meaningful part of the introduction.
Gimmemorebubblez  +   624d ago
If its necessary in the games over all narrative.
TheGOODKyle  +   624d ago
No
ArronC07  +   624d ago
Agreed.
josephayal  +   624d ago
The violence was there for a reason
Jon_Smackenrow  +   624d ago
It is a snuff Game. Even racist don't like being neighbors to murders. The argument is not very smart, much like your use of the word 'reason'. There is no healing adding more violence to a world of snuff-violence. If you hate racism, don't be racist. If you hate violence, don't be violent or do it to stop violence from taking place. Josephayal "The violence was there for a reason." You need a chainsaw to save someone? You don't even need one to kill a guy. It is only for you sick freaks who like snuff games.
As for History of a Django unNation, Quentin Tarantino is a hack knocking off 70 troupes.
I like violent video game. I have a unboosted Platinum in Crysis 2. But a chain saw to the face, close up. COME-ON-MAN.
aLucidMind  +   624d ago
How is this a snuff game? By that logic, every game where you kill enemies in a faction is a snuff game. GTA is one on criminals and cops. Farcry 3 is one on slavers. CoD is one of everyone but 'merica. Left 4 Dead is one on zombies because, seriously, all they want is a hug.

You're either a troll or you clearly have no idea what a snuff is.
#8.1 (Edited 624d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
aLucidMind  +   624d ago
What the hell did he expect to do in the game if not kill enemies? Invite them over for tea and crumpets for ten hours and tell them "you're wrong and mean" with them magically turning good?
jackwei22  +   624d ago
Well duh with the all the so called controversial stuff in the game is the reason it is rated 18+ for mature, so if you don't like it don't buy it and stop crying about it.
Summons75  +   624d ago
Possibly to some but I feel like it has a deeper meaning, especially when you first get in a fight with Elisabeth and she says "You murdered them, Your a monster!". It totally made me see that a deeper narrative that continues throughout the game on the subject so the over brutalization is justified. That very first kill of the game was messed up though, made me laugh because I wasn't expecting it to go that far. Haven't beaten the game yet but im enjoying it so much.
MadMen  +   624d ago
No game can be too violent even the ones that were banned.

Games are no different than Art, they are a style of expression, all they need on them is a rating to ensure you are of age to see the style.
CaptainYesterday  +   624d ago
I don't think Infinite is too violent..

Possible Spoilers?

But the starting of the game when you go to the raffle drawing and Booker Skyhooks that cops face I said "HOLY FUCK!" pretty damn loud. It's a mature rated game just like BioShock 1 and 2 so of course it's going to have violence I expected that when I got the game and besides the people of Columbia are insane I will unleash a swarm of crows on them!
#13 (Edited 624d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
plaZeHD  +   624d ago
The violence was unneeded.
brettyd  +   624d ago
Hippy
It wasn't too violent at all. The game doesn't even let you throw a baseball at people.
Max-Zorin  +   624d ago
The violence on that game is nothing. Manhunt 2 makes the violence on that game look like Sesame Street.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

Review: Machines at War 3 (DarkZero)

48m ago - Ben Knowles: "An RTS that plays equally well on PC, tablet and mobile may seem like an impossible... | PC
20°

Stomach Hurts and Flew Frisbee: Tips, Tricks, Cheats, and Strategies

51m ago - WP: "Every once in awhile, something happens that requires your dear author to take a long hard l... | iPhone
30°

Review: Mega Man Zero (Wii U eShop / Game Boy Advance) | NLife

1h ago - NLife: "A side character gets a great spotlight The Classic Mega Man Series was popular enoug... | Wii U
30°

Nintendo Download: 25th December (North America)

1h ago - NLife: "Festive delights with Duck Hunt, Shantae, classic Mario and more! It's Christmas Day,... | Wii U
Ad

Far Cry 4 (XB1) Review

Now - Ken finds his inner tiger in Kyrat. | Promoted post
30°

Super Smash Bros. for Wii U Review - MNN

1h ago - MNN: "After its success on the Nintendo 3DS, the classic action brawler returns to Nintendo’s ho... | Wii U