Submitted by Pozzle 868d ago | opinion piece

Bioshock Infinite’s use of racism as window dressing, and why this is a misleading argument

PA writes: There's a good amount of criticism that I agree with in this story, and I think that the better the game industry becomes as telling stories and crafting characters, the worse the pile of bodies in each game is going to look. It's hard to feel empathy for a character after they kill a few hundred people, and there's almost a willful separation of narrative and game play. Ideally they should hold each other, but we're not quite there yet in terms of game design.

The good news is that games are getting good enough that this tension is felt at all. (BioShock: Infinite, PC, PS3, Xbox 360)

HarryMasonHerpderp  +   868d ago
I think the headline and thumbnail are kind of a spoiler.
Finding out about Columbia being a racist city for the first time was one of my highlights.
How everything made it seem like the perfect place to live then bam all of a sudden this place is not what it seems.
#1 (Edited 868d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
Hicken  +   868d ago
I thought that was kinda obvious early on. Like, still in development early on. I haven't played much, and haven't watched my friends play too much, either. But I kinda got the impression way back when that Columbia wouldn't be very friendly to people of darker-hued skin.
HarryMasonHerpderp  +   868d ago
Yeah I'm sure some people saw it coming, but I avoided the trailers and previews so I could get the most out of the game and see things for the first time. I personally had no clue about the racism in Infinite until the moment it happens. I thought it was a great part of the game that wouldn't of impacted me as much if I knew it was coming.
It is an early part of the game like you say but I think it's also one of the most important.
#1.1.1 (Edited 868d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(1) | Report
Capt-FuzzyPants  +   868d ago
Once you know the date and in the first half hour you kind of get a sense at how it would turn out. They make it seem like a city dedicated to American history pre-civil war. Although I have to admit I didn't think the city was that dedicated to racism. And I kinda had it spoiled for me when I saw the statue of John Wilkes Booth in a review.
sway_z  +   868d ago
You will never completely kill Racism or prejudice, and articles such as these only inflame the issue further.

I don't care what colour you are..a dumb ass is a dumb ass.

Political Correctness has become a joke! People can't even say 'Fat' for fear of upsetting someone. When did the human race become such pansies??

I agree nobody should purposefully go out of their way to upset anyone. But live and let live, whatever skin your in...we're all crazy B'stards!
#2 (Edited 868d ago ) | Agree(7) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
spartanlemur  +   868d ago
I find the critique of Bioshock infinite to be abhorrent for its attempt to impose subjective morality upon others. Racism is not automatically evil, just because society tells us it is.
An intellectual society is one where nothing is taboo for discussion or media, and the best ideas (chosen by consensus) ultimately dominate legislation; where we start ruthlessly attacking games for presenting neutral views, it is clear that prejudice is still present, and preventing us from further development.

My point is that people need to stop trying to be moral policemen and mind their own business.
NeoTribe  +   868d ago
They didnt add the racism in for shits and giggles. In bioshock infinite there living in a crazy religious city that kinda represents what america was like back in the days. The presidents they worship in bioshock were all for slavery so abviously it fit to put it in the game. Theres a picture of Abraham lincoln somewhere with his face scratched out, depicting the hatred for that particular president due to the fact that he let free the slaves. Anyone offended by this should go watch that djenga movie. Its not meant to offend, just to take you for a screwed up ride in a backwards screwed up world.
okmrman  +   868d ago
abe had over 200 slaves when he died

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Grab New York Collapse, a survivalist field guide, for The Division

12m ago - The New York Collapse is going to be a companion book for Tom Clancy's The Division that will tel... | PC

Fingered - First Play

24m ago - NichBoy fingers some perps in Fingered! | PC

Check What PC Games are Coming Out in August

Now - At Releases.com you can check release dates for PC games. Visit now and start tracking the games you plan to buy. | Promoted post

How To Survive 2 Heading to Early Access in October

25m ago - Today, game publisher 505 Games announced its fan-favourite zombie survival hit How to Survive is... | PC

Hands-on with the procedurally generated tracks of Racecraft | TeamVVV

25m ago - TeamVVV writes: "Racecraft, which was inspired by Minecraft, is a racer which features prodecural... | PC

MIA Kickstarter RPG Kitaru Returns With a Demo

25m ago - Serena Nelson writes: "Until last week the last we heard from the Kitaru devs was almost a year a... | PC