60°
Submitted by awesomeoutof 661d ago | opinion piece

The necessity of extreme violence in BioShock Infinite

AWESOMEoutof10's Fraser Brown explores the importance of violence in BioShock Infinite after the aspect's recent condemnation.
"Have no doubts about it, Infinite is a brutal, bloody title that contains countless scenes of gratuitous violence which would make most people feel uncomfortable. Necks are broken, heads explode, men and women are riddled with bloody holes and enemies are pecked to death by supernatural crows. It’s exceptionally disgusting. And it’s also completely necessary." (BioShock: Infinite, PC, PS3, Xbox 360)

Hellforged_Savant  +   662d ago
That's probably the single best thought out article i've seen on this subject to date. Seriously, i've heard the game condemned repeatedly over this but that's some incredibly detailed reasoning you have for it there.
FantasyStar  +   661d ago
Maybe I'm already desensitized, but violence isn't the first or fourth word I'd use to sum up my experience with this game. The only thing that really stood out in violent-acts was the melee executions. The other things like Vigor-finishers or the plot-elements didn't really phase me. As weird as this is; it was the lack of focus of violence that made this game memorable to me.
Mouktouk  +   661d ago
My post may contain minor spoilers about Bioshock: Infinite
I pretty much agree with the article. Bioshock: Infinite is one of the rare games where such level of violence isn't used just for the sake of blood-splattering.

Columbia is a decadent world, powered by several kinds of extremisms: racial extremism, religious extremism, political extremism. Booker Dewitt's past, Comstock's ideology, the Vox Populi,... Columbia is the prey of violent minds that would do everything necessary to fulfill their mission.

In those circumstances, in my opinion the use of such "extreme violence" is then a way to illustrate this decadence, and not simply a marketing way to attract gamers looking for free violence.
#3 (Edited 661d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Rex_Aeternae  +   661d ago
I do agree that this is an impressive and well thought-out article but I have to admit that I actually felt nothing when killing everything. Am I a monster? No (at least probably not).

The violence, for some reason, didn't faze me. Especially not as it affected the people in the article. When I first experienced the sky-hook and the execution cut-scene I truthfully thought that the hook looked really cool, almost ignoring the brutality of the killing.
Maybe I'm just desensitized from all the other violent games I've played but I never experienced any physical reaction from killing something in the game.

(I will admit that I haven't finished the game so maybe there is something worse but so far everything has been pretty tame)

I guess I aligned with DeWitt and thought that I had to do everything in my power to get to Elizabeth even if that meant killing everything in my way, even if she hated me for it.
ywuoisdf   661d ago | Spam

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

PewDiePie and other YouTubers dismiss Nintendo's proposed revenue sharing plan

11m ago - Nintendo’s latest attempt to reach out to YouTubers has been ill received. “F*** you Nintendo,... | Industry
20°

#IDARB Is A Wolf In 8-Bit Clothing

21m ago - WOW247: "If I wanted to play NES games, I could easily buy a cheap system and some classics off e... | Xbox One
20°

See the Blanka and Chun Li felyne costumes for Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate in action

21m ago - Nintendo has released a video showcasing the Street Fighter II felyne costumes for Monster Hunter... | 3DS
10°

Samsung Gear VR with Gamepad Sells out within hours in the UK

22m ago - Want a Samsung Gear VR with official gamepad in the UK, then you're out of luck as the item is no... | Tech
Ad

Visit CGMagazine: The Culture of Games

Now - CGM is for the mature audience of comics and games that wants more out of their media than just a review score. | Promoted post
10°

Pokken Tournament: Shown off at location test, new stage featuring Lugia

22m ago - It would appear as if numerous twitter users are posting pictures of a Pokken Tournament location... | Arcade