110°
Submitted by Mac is OK 760d ago | news

Metacritic's weighting system revealed

The website Metacritic weights the scores of different video game critics and publications when calculating its aggregate 'metascore' for any particular title. (Industry, Metacritic)

Ilovetheps4  +   760d ago
Metacritic's system is an odd one. I have gotten to the point where I have started looking more toward the smaller sites than the big ones. It just seems like their views match mine more often.
#1 (Edited 760d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
Why o why  +   760d ago
their lack of transparency was why I never trusted meta scores or their site. Just another manipulation tool used by whoever to sway public opinion under the guise of impartiality. Film magazines having higher weighings than dedicated gaming sites. Western preferences... Anyway this goes some way into them being more transparent and less of a reason for anybody to use it to influence a decision or use in console disputes. All gen people wanted to know why some sites and publications had higher weighing than others only to be fobbed off or dismissed...Even now they still dont disclose their reasoning like its the kernels secret herbs and spices... boll*(ks

didn't gametrailers get caught falsifying videos......still top weighing...okayden
#2 (Edited 760d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
JoySticksFTW  +   760d ago
Yeah, this is crazy.

Never heard of some of the sites in the "highest" category, while Giantbomb is in the "lower" category

Metacritic was always like vgchartz to me. Sometimes entertaining, but never to be taken too seriously.

The problem is some developer bonuses and future job opportunities are actually tied to their metacritic score, and that's plain bogus.

Seeing this list is going to make some developers sick.
WarThunder  +   760d ago
Only mindless people and fanboys use Metacritic...
AnyaShroud  +   760d ago
and when they change the formula (ie change the weighting or add/remove from that list), do they update the scores in the past? of course they don't.

every metacritic score needs to be transparent and include the list of websites and their weightings at the time, otherwise I don't know what the score means if we're comparing scores of different games with different lists of critic sites and different weightings.
wishingW3L  +   760d ago
and that's why GameInformer and IGN get so many exclusive reviews....
oof46  +   760d ago
Giant Bomb is on the low end of the weighted scale? Huh?!? Is it because they're both owned by CBS?

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
20°

Why P.T. is a bigger loss than Silent Hills | VideoGamer

6m ago - VideoGamer: "Silent Hills getting scrapped is a disappointment, but losing P.T. is a real blow." | PS4
10°

Best Mods for Cities: Skylines

6m ago - There’s only so much a small team can produce. A team of a million plus, even if the majority are... | PC
Ad

Help Myriad get through Steam Greenlight!

Now - Myriad is a twin-stick shooter that grows more beautiful the better you play, where you build and then destroy the game space in glorious chain rea... | Promoted post
10°

It's the Battle of New York in MLB 15: The Show's Challenge of the Week

7m ago - Step into the batter's box and jump into the middle of the Subway Series in MLB 15: The Show's Ch... | PS3
30°

DiRT Rally First Trailer Debuts, Shows off Power of Stealth Released Sim

7m ago - sdsfdsfdsIt's been a long time since we've gotten DiRTy. Four years, in fact, when DiRT 3 was unl... | PC
10°

Guns, Gore, And Cannoli Gameplay Video

7m ago - Combining retro gameplay with waves of the undead and clever one liners, has resulted in a very e... | PC