100°
Submitted by kbell29 749d ago | opinion piece

EA's SimCity Disaster Made Worse With Early Positive Reviews

Gaming journalists missed an opportunity early this week when positive reviews trickled in before the actual SimCity servers even launched. The discrepancy between pre-launch and post-launch review scores is enormous. The average score before launch was 9.3 while the average post-launch score was only 7.3 out of 10. (PC, SimCity)

MooseWI  +   749d ago
So it's a good game, but the server issues that are repaired/going to be repaired dragged it down.
Yi-Long  +   748d ago
Even if/when the connection-issues get sorted out...
... you still have a city-builder game that you can't play offline, that has too small cities compared to Sim City 4, and that will milk it's consumers through DLC.

I'm sure it's a nice game, but is it really an improvement over Sim City 4. when you look at these negatives? Personally, I doubt it.
grailly  +   748d ago
it's a GREAT game, I played the whole day yesterday and I can say that the smaller cities really aren't that much of a problem, they just force you to be more efficient rather than spreading your city out to get more population.
It's a different kind of challenge from simcity4, but I really like having to rebuild parts of my city while trying to not disrupt it's functioning.

On top of that, the game nails all the charts, part , which is also really fun. I do think it's a better game than simcity 4.
pixelsword  +   749d ago
It may be a good game, but if the server issues are prevalent, why weren't they obvious before launch? Were the numbers too low to show problems or did they honestly review the game?
brish  +   749d ago
"if the server issues are prevalent, why weren't they obvious before launch?"

Some types of server issues only appear under heavy load. When reviewers played the game their weren't many players so they wouldn't have ran into the problems that users faced after the game was released.
#2.1 (Edited 749d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Soldierone  +   749d ago
When reviewers get the game, they get it a week or more before launch. At that time there are maybe a few hundred people playing, not thousands.

I've had an instance where the games multiplayer was fantastic up until launch, then the game struggled.
MooseWI  +   749d ago
They were on private servers too
porkChop  +   749d ago
Early reviews were done at a 2 day review session running on a private EA network. That's why many sites chose to wait until the game went live to review it under consumer circumstances. Many sites also felt that 2 days is not nearly enough time to properly review a game.
pixelsword  +   748d ago
Aha! Two days? For SimCity?

Not nearly enough time: they could have also waited to observe the load.
MarcT   748d ago | Spam
SDF Repellent  +   748d ago
I will just stick with my SNES version of Sim City for now until a more ethical version of the game gets made.
titans9999  +   748d ago
Fuck Sim City, I will wait for the newly announced Civitas where the creators are letting the fans control how they want it made, including mods!
ACEMANWISE  +   748d ago
I think the review system needs an overhaul. It hasn't changed much since online started. They need to consider that games change in realtime through updates. They should review each version of a game to give gamers an accurate picture of how a game evolves.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

Game of Thrones: The Sword in the Darkness Review - Pixel Related

47m ago - While the initial episode of Telltale’s Game of Thrones series seemed to be on somewhat unsure fo... | PC
40°

Interview with Andy Anderson, Producer on Smite for Xbox One [SideQuesting]

48m ago - Dali Dimovski of SideQuesting writes: "We chat with Smite's Producer about how they brought th... | PC
Ad

SMITE World Championships LIVE January 9th to 11th

Now - You can watch the games and enter giveaways over at http://beta.cursevoice.com/smite-worlds | Promoted post
40°

Guild Wars 2: Heart of Thorns Video Interview - EGX Rezzed 2015

1h ago - An interview with Liz from ArenaNet/NCsoft about the upcoming Expansion on Guild Wars 2 and the f... | PC
40°

Benchmark: DirectX 12 vs. Mantle & Dx11 on a G3258 CPU, 4790K, Titan X, & 290X

1h ago - GamersNexus: "Consoles have long touted the phrase 'close to the metal' as a means to explain tha... | PC
30°

Bit Trauma Presents - Time Slippage: A Life Is Strange: Episode 2 - Out Of Time Review

1h ago - Check out Reid Randall's take on Life Is Strange and its second offering. He was the contributing... | Xbox One