Top
570°

Tomb Raider: 5 Reasons It’s Better Than Uncharted 3

"The recent reboot of the Tomb Raider franchise has been well met by many. Lara Croft’s new adventure has been compared numerous times with the Uncharted series, which itself was initially compared to earlier Tomb Raider games when it first came out. " | Explosion.com

Read Full Story >>
explosion.com
The story is too old to be commented.
guitar_nerd_231205d ago

Not to put Uncharted down because it's great but I thought it improved on a lot things with Uncharted while not being quite as polished as Uncharted.

Considering the scale of the environments, it's a technical marvel.

lastofgen1205d ago

huh??
I think you've got your statement jumbled up.

Scenarist1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

I understand what he is saying tho but
I could only hope that any newer game, that is similar to another game , would better it since it is newer... (not always the case but key word is HOPE )

otherwise be completely different so I have no reference

Uncharted is an amazing series..
and I hope (when I play it) that I feel like the
new Tomb Raider ....TOPS IT...

and then the next uncharted top that... and so forth

I would hate for it to be any other way

FATAL1TY1205d ago

Uncharted 2: 96
Uncharted 3: 92
tomb raider: 86

Metacritic

omi25p1205d ago

I swear just a few weeks ago you said we shouldn't use metacritic because most reviewers are biased again the ps3.

Funny how now it works in you're favour its a different story.

Highlife1205d ago

Wow you can recite numbers. Who cares about metacritic. I played them and Uncharted to ME is the better game. But realy who cares about numbers especially metacritic.

fermcr1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

Reviewers tend to overhype and overscore exclusives (for all platform exclusives), and underscore multiplatform games (with the exception of games like GTA4).
Metacritic doesn't show the value of the game.

Go play the game and see how good it is.

b163o11205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

Funny how people let other people decide what games to play smdh, probably why I own 3D dot game Heroes. I'm my own reviewer pay for what I want play what I want.

007Bond1205d ago

That doesn't mean anything, Tomb Raider is way better and more interesting than that snore fest

Blackdeath_6631205d ago

while i do agree with you please for the love of god do not quote metacritic

8GB_DDR31205d ago SpamShow
icewater851205d ago

@b163o1 YOu get a bubble from me, because 3D Dot Heros is one of my favorite games this gen.

gta28001205d ago

Tomb Raider=Poor mans Uncharted.

Karpetburnz1205d ago

I agree that Uncharted is a better game, but F*ck Metacritic, They gave God of War: Ascension a 79, Thats F*cked.

rataranian1205d ago

..Yeah cause we care about what review sites give it.

+ Show (8) more repliesLast reply 1205d ago
fermcr1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

I've played all Uncharted's on PS3 (just didn't play the one on the Vita), and they are good games, but... in my humble opinion Tomb Raider is a better game.

Finished Tomb Raider last night, it's very good. Good story, very good graphics, gameplay and cinematic events. Tomb Raider took many elements from Uncharted (just like Uncharted took from original Tomb Raider), and for that it become a better game.

Seraphemz1205d ago

You passed the game in a couple of days????

I wish I had that much time to game...

Shaner_Bock1205d ago

What is it, exactly, that Uncharted "took" from Tomb Raider?

delboy1205d ago ImmatureShow
miyamoto1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

I know TR is great and lovely game and I am going to enjoy it to the max.

.... but can you please care to elaborate the many stuff Uncharted took from the original TR?

As far as facts show Uncharted is an evolution of these platforming games made by the combined efforts of Hirokazu Yasuhara, Mark Cerny, & Naughty Dog

Sonic the Hedgehog (1991)Hirokazu Yasuhara

Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (1992)Hirokazu Yasuhara & Mark Cerny

Sonic the Hedgehog 3 (1994)Hirokazu Yasuhara

Sonic 3D Blast (1995) Hirokazu Yasuhara

Sonic Xtreme (1996) Hirokazu Yasuhara

Disruptor (1996) Mark Cerny w/ Imsoniac

Crash Bandicoot (1996) ND w/ Mark Cerny

Crash Bandicoot 2: Cortex Strikes Back (1997) ND w/ Mark Cerny

Crash Bandicoot 3: Warped (1998) ND w/ Mark Cerny

Jak & Daxter (2001) ND w/ Mark Cerny

Ratchet and Clank (2002) Imsoniac w/ Mark Cerny

Jak 2 (2003) ND w/ Hirokazu Yasuhara & Mark Cerny

Ratchet & Clank: Going Commando (2003) Imsoniac w/ Mark Cerny

Jak 3 (2004) ND, Hirokazu Yasuhara & Mark Cerny

Ratchet & Clank: Up Your Arsenal (2004) Imsoniac w/ Mark Cerny

Jak X: Combat Racing (2005) ND w/ Hirokazu Yasuhara

Resistance: Fall of Man (2006) Imsoniac w/ Mark Cerny

Uncharted: Drake's Fortune (2007) ND w/ Hirokazu Yasuhara, Mark Cerny

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves (2009) ND w/ Hirokazu Yasuhara

Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception (2011) ND w/ Hirokazu Yasuhara

Clearly its an evolution of game play design that shows in Uncharted series.

Its very clear and obvious Uncharted took many inspiration from Indiana Jones on the stories department no doubt.

So please give me some info on this. A link perhaps. Thanks.

Darrius Cole1205d ago

@delboy

Unless you are female and not gay, then Nathan is clearly a better choice than Laura, and you would vote for Uncharted.

MysticStrummer1205d ago

"(just like Uncharted took from original Tomb Raider)"

Right there is where you lost all credibility.

You clearly didn't play the original TRs.

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 1205d ago
Root1205d ago

Tomb Raider comes no where close to Uncharted

For starters the cast and the voice actors are horrible and they have more backstory with the documents you find in the game then the cast in Uncharted. I mean Drakes past life is a mystery but his character development is amazing. Laras however.....well it's the voice, she sounds like a 13 year old girl half the time

TotalHitman1205d ago

It doesn't help that the voice actress is an American trying to do an English accent. The voice is really irritating. It's enough to actually put me off from buying the game.

Root1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

She's American....REALLY

Why didn't they get a British Voice Actor...honestly thats not cool

HarryMasonHerpderp1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

She's British but lived in American for 8 years and has a "American/British hybrid accent". Which is why she sounds really off.

"Luddington has lived in the United States for 8 years. This has given her an English/American hybrid accent. However, when she was a child she learned to speak with an American accent"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wik...

I hope they use a different voice actor for the next game.

HmongAmerican1205d ago

uhh,I just can't stand her voice. Doesn't match her at all characters at all.

Megaton1205d ago

The cast is one of the only places where Uncharted is better.

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 1205d ago
The_Infected1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

It's Tomb Raider 80% of the game takes place outside not in tombs. You can't even swim which is pretty crazy. Neither the graphics, animations, story tops Uncharted its very close though. Tomb Raider is a great game I'm playing it right now but it's no uncharted very close but not quite.

clintagious6501205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

Im not taking anything away from tomb raider but atleast give credit where its due. If uncharted never came along this new tomb raider wouldnt be what it is today & im glad ppl enjoy it because if u never played an uncharted game tomb raider is in alot of ways like uncharted but more darker side. Nuttin wrong with following footsteps of great devs like naughty dog.

ritsuka6661205d ago

New Tomb Raider is more open world. I can explore more. Right there I'm already liking it better than the Uncharted games. Also the bow and arrow. It's my favorite weapon in any game (Except in ACIII because it had no free aiming)

-Superman-1205d ago

Better Platforming - Tie(Uncharted is more action shooting while it has some amazing platforming and awesome things. For example - Train, Plane, trucks... seen no other video games like that)(Tomb Rider feels maybe more natural because Tomb Raider is all about Platforming)

More Involving Characters - More does not mean better. quality over quantity. Uncharted wins here.

Seamless Open World - Yeah, maybe but does it make it better? Later you can go back to place, and there is nothing to do. I remember old Tomb Raider games and those were linear and better. Its more about what you can do, story, stuff, not about open world that has nothing to do. Uncharted wins here.

Better Cover System - Cant say nothing... Let people choice... Its option choice.

Tighter Controls - nothing to say. Still Unchated wins here

-Superman-1205d ago

I can say why Uncharted 3 is better.
1)Better story
2)Better charaters
3)CO-OP and multiplayer. Tomb Raider failed big here
4)More awesome effects(plane, desert)
5)More different places(than just a island)
6)Better music
7)Other things.

Tomb Raider reboot is good, but still not better than Uncharted.

j-blaze1204d ago

now i didn't play Tomb Raider but i did play U3 unfortunately, the game is overrated as hell! it really isn't as good as they chock it up to be, the dump AI, the overdone animations made drake look drunk, laughable puzzles, silly nonsensical story, old hag as a villain, microcode gameplay not to mention the boring first half of the game. it's one of the worst games i ever played and most of you guys defending it cus it's exclusive

fsfsxii1204d ago

@jblaze
Glad people like you only have one bubble

-Superman-1205d ago

I found Tomb Raider: Anniversary better game for some reason.

Old first 4 Tomb Raider games were so great. I mean it was tight, but it was interested. I really felt like Tomb Raider is alone, doing all this stuff, and then there were some human charat, but not big roll. It was all about adventure.

New Tomb Raider feels more like just shooting action game. Big island, humans wants to kill you... wtf is this? I dont want any radio or human contacts. Just be alone, and have this adventure, than just killing bad guys because they are bad guys...

chukamachine1204d ago (Edited 1204d ago )

I'm playing the new game maxed on my PC atm and it's a good game. But it's not Uncharted.

I don't like the womans voice at all, feels off, a.i is abit dumb. Pulling ropes out of her arse is abit silly.

I enjoyed Anniversary a lot because it's just like the original TR.

This new version does not really feel like a Tomb raider game, more just an action game with a girl in it.

Strange isn't it.

I preferred the DMC reboot over the old game.

I'd give it an 8.

Aceman181205d ago

Damn the gaming media (especially no name sites) are fraking pathetic. all they do, or look to do is cause flame wars between crazy fanboys of systems, and games.

there's no need for this garbage, down vote this crappy site.

greenpowerz1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

No name sites were the ones praising uncharted the most. The games borrow from eachother and is why they're compared. It only seems like the media is trying to piss you off. You're upset because you guys are fanboys so fanatical you are personally offended. PS3 fans bashed Tomb Raider during the hay day of uncharted hype, now you can't handle many people thinking TR is better than UC

-Tomb Raider is bigger with a more open world

-It has a smart blended story that's non intrusive

-Graphics are a great deal better with realalistc art and unmatched detail/textures with almost next gen lighting. Pretty good animations and physics.

-Combat is better

-Upgrading and leveling system is refreshing

The only thing wrong with this game is there are no rewards for beating the game, things like keeping your weapons you earnded and having a new dificalty setting that allows you to use all your new weapons(like Dead Space 3)

BlueTemplar1205d ago

@greenpowerz

"Graphics are a great deal better with realalistc art and unmatched detail/textures with almost next gen lighting. Pretty good animations and physics."

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH AHAHAHAHAHAHAA

oh wait, you were serious?

Aceman181205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

@green

please shut your trap because all you do is spew trollish garbage everything time you was your one bubble. i love the original tomb raider, i love uncharted, and i sure as hell know imma love this new tomb raider.

it doesn't matter to me which is better because they are both great games.

You're only commenting because you have your head soooo far up Microsoft's you know what that you always have to bad mouth anything Sony made especially if there's a multi-plat game like this involved.

I'll just state again that the gaming media is fraking pathetic period end of story. also are you calling the big name sites that praised uncharted no name sites now?

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 1205d ago
MehmetAlperTR1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

tomb raider is a tomb raider.. uncharted is a uncharted.. none of them are better then each other.. just another stupid article..

HarryMasonHerpderp1205d ago

Tomb Raider does some things better than Uncharted but Uncharted does some things better than Tomb Raider.
They are both really well made games.

Megaton1205d ago

That's the only honest response to the comparison. They're both superior and inferior to each other in different ways, but they're both at the top of the genre.

showtimefolks1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

Tomb raider and Indiana jones was the inspiration for uncharted series. Tomb Raider started great than list it's way but than for the reboot of tomb raider I bet you Uncharted series helped a lot on what TR should be.

So in a way TR helped start Uncharted but than UC helped TR developers by giving it clear vision of what fans like and don't like.

Also people complain than inUC you kill,kill and kill more but you do the same in TR.

Uncharted series is one of the best in gaming so haters gonna hate. To me the perfect game this gen was uncharted 2. The amount of polish and overall feel of the game and pace was perfect. But that's just my opinion

TR is a good gamut for sequels it will get better, it reminds me of the first uncharted game good not great so hopefully for the next game which will on on next gen systems it will tak a huge leap.

Why do people care which is better why can't we enjoy both? We get bunch of FOS ga,Ed each year so why can't we get 2 great 3rd person action adventure games?

Instead of hating just play and enjoy

aquamala1205d ago

I agree. and Uncharted 3 is the worst game in the series, not saying it's not a good game.

MariaHelFutura1205d ago

In all reality they are two very different games, like Call Of Duty and Battlefield.

fei-hung1205d ago

how about dismissing the crappy title from the site all together and saying, "5 reasons why Tomb Raider doesn't need to be better than Uncharted and vice versa."

The game has launched 1.5 years after Uncharted naturally the tech etc will be further along.

Tomb Raider has always had a larger focus on puzzles compared to Uncharted.

Uncharted always has had a larger focus on set pieces and blockbuster moments compared to Tomb Raider.

One is has a more serious overtone compared to the other.

One is supposed to be more grounded to reality and gritty compared to the other.

Yes, they are similar, but no, they are not the same.

Can't journalists live without pitting things against each other constantly and trying to make something or another more inferior or superior to the other?

It's like they want to watch the world burn -_-

TheSurg1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

Did you just write something else than: PS3 IS THE REASON THAT HUMANS EXIST "? You will feel the flame of fanboy kids on you quickly. You offended their mothers. This site = only for ps3 fanboys. Rarely someone (me) comes here for gaming news.

guitar_nerd_231204d ago (Edited 1204d ago )

Ok (deep breath),

@lastofgen: My statement is not jumbled.
@FATAL1TY: Metacritic means nothing to me a better game is a better game f.uck the numbers.
@gta2800: Poor mans uncharted? Get real, seriously that's just plain offensive to the devs that clearly put in a TON of work in.

I actually love sony playstations and I would genuinely bet money my PS collection is better than most (not to mention my SNES collection). I don't mean that to show off, I'm just trying to get across I'm not at all anti Playstation yet I can still see Tomb Raider is better in many ways.

I'm not arguing the combat, Uncharted is technically better in that regard.

I'm mearly saying from my experience Tomb Raider is the better game overall.

I love the Uncharted games, but if your honest you should be able to see Uncharted 3 was a relatively safe play/ easy cash in/ didn't have the passion of 1 or 2 (even though 1 is technically inferior in many ways.)

I really, genuinely cannot see why some of you are so upset about this and desperate the defend Uncharted.

Uncharted is great I accept this.

Tomb Raider, however HAS suppased it.

Deal with it, hell play it- it's friggin' awesome.

Your loss otherwise frankly if you like Uncharted type gameplay.

Deal with it.

edit: The other thing I should point out is ps fanboys are showing you age and shooting yourself in the foot. As far as I'm concerned the original Tomb Raiders were a LARGE part of the PS1 puzzle WAY before Uncharted was on the seen.

+ Show (17) more repliesLast reply 1204d ago
alousow1205d ago

this game is great but uncharted is better. if u r a xbox fan boy u wont kno it

wishingW3L1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

and way better when you think about the fact that they had to copy Uncharted's formula piece by piece to finally make a decent Tomb Raider game. ;)

But we all knew these kind of articles were coming and that they were going to be on favor of the multiplat game. The same thing happened with inFamous and Prototype... It's a really easy and obvious way to fish for hits. Especially on a site like N4G where the majority of the population are Sony fans and most of these sites make most of its profit through N4G.

aviator1891205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

so....what you're saying is that even if people have played both uncharted and tomb raider on their ps3, they must agree that uncharted is better than tomb raider, otherwise they're an "xbox fan??"

...some strange logic you've got going there..

Convas1205d ago

It's strange because it's not actually logic ... LOL

RTheRebel1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

yea uncharted 2 was a masterpiece but,
uncharted 3 ughhhhhh tomb raider is better upset for the mulitiplayer
but I enjoy both these games :)

delboy1205d ago

If you're gay, then I understand that you prefer Drake over Lara.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 1205d ago
Silly gameAr1205d ago

Don't fall for this people.

Silly gameAr1205d ago (Edited 1205d ago )

haha. Honestly, I'm surprised it took this long for an opinion piece like this to pop up, but I figured it would eventually.

majiebeast1205d ago

Took longer then i thought for such a article to pop up.

Xaphy1205d ago

why dont we just enjoy both and dont compare?

Studio-YaMi1205d ago

Because stupid sites like this wouldn't be able to get hits otherwise ?

vikingland11205d ago

Intelligent bubble for you :)

mcstorm1205d ago

@Xaphy well said. I cant wait to play this game but I have a massive back log and a few pre orders already so it will have to wait until later on in the year before I pick it up. Im glad it looks like its selling well to as this game looks like it will be an amazing game.

Xaphy1205d ago

@mcstorm I feel you man. I have tons of game to finish and so little time. Especially that I have subscribed to ps plus 2 months ago.