Submitted by Jamiex66 634d ago | opinion piece

Games Aren’t Art, They’re Products

Analog Addiction writes: "Now that I have your attention with that, dare I say it, frankly inflammatory title, I’d like to introduce you to the world of game publishers.

I, being a young and supple boy at the age of twenty, can’t remember a time when publishers were not the gatekeepers to triple-A game production. EA, Activision, THQ (may you rest in peace, my sweet prince), Capcom, Konami, Microsoft, Nintendo, Sony and more were in charge of what games got made and which ones didn’t. I always thought to myself, “Wilikers! These guys must really love games to be putting out so many of them!”. " (Activision, Culture, Industry, Konami)

Argus9  +   634d ago
I had the lowest expectations going into this article, but I have to say, I really enjoyed it. Perfect examples how publishers are becoming too money-grubby and are hurting the industry.

At the same time, I feel this is a big reason there's such a prevalence of surprise indie hits coming about, a lot of them re-visiting more "outdated" gaming philosophies.

I think it's time we stirred things up. If enough gamers can vote with their wallets, maybe things will take a turn.
knowyourstuff  +   634d ago
Just because something can be commercialized to make money doesn't make it not art. It just makes it commercialized art aka products. You can sell your art at an art gallery, and invite billionaires from everywhere (particularly those who aren't fond of each other) to come and bid on it just to get the best chances of getting the highest price and making the most money. You're doing things to get the most money, you're selling a product that people are buying, whether anyone thinks that the art is good, or bad is irrelevant, don't turn around and say it isn't art to begin with because it made someone money.

There seems to be a disconnect between people's view of art, and capitalism. Just because you view something as something to make money on doesn't make it not art.
#1.1 (Edited 634d ago ) | Agree(7) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
rainslacker  +   634d ago
I had a friend who was an artist. He apparently did alright, even though I never saw any of his art. He said the problem most modern artists have is that they don't know how to commercialize themselves to actually make money, so they can't survive as an artist.

He said the modern artist is not about technique or ability, but making people believe that you created something worth spending money on.

The same is true in the game industry. To publishers, it doesn't necessarily have to be good, so long as people believe that they want it, and will spend money on it.

For the most part, I think developers actually love what they do, and want to do the best job possible, but they are constrained by deadlines and budgets. That however is a completely different debate.

Publishers don't exist to further the art of games, they exist to sell them. They are a necessary evil, but it is pretty apparent how big indie gaming has become because it focuses more on the art side than the business side.
Argus9  +   632d ago
I think the writer is saying that publishers have this disconnect; they don't see it as art, just as a product. The article isn't saying a piece of art that makes money is bad, it's saying that publishers don't care about video games as a medium, just as a product. They only care about price points.
s45gr32  +   634d ago
Not only can we vote with our wallet but we can fund and promote the games we want to play through kickstarter or indie gogo projects.
MacDonagh  +   634d ago
Art is a tricky thing to define. For me personally; the audience is just as important as the artist. The MOMA in New York City recently had 14 video games in an exhibit.

The audience in gaming has yet to mature but it will eventually.
dedicatedtogamers  +   634d ago
I do love me a good "artsy" game every so often. However, I do get tired of devs - especially some indie ones - who skimp on good game design simply because "it's my creative, artsy vision".
CrescentFang  +   634d ago
The same could be said about anything, but enough talk have at you!
RandomDude655  +   634d ago
Imma go play Castlevania now.

But anywho....everything is a product, even *gasp* art.
Hicken  +   634d ago
That's what immediately came to my mind. Many of the greatest works of art in man's history were SOLD to the person who funded it. It was produced for a person who paid for it.

That's what we call a "product." The Mona Lisa is a PRODUCT. Still art, though.
Mathew9R   634d ago | Spam
s45gr32  +   634d ago
Well a well written article that is all I have to say.
contradictory  +   634d ago
it's not very easy to determine if a game is art

games more often than not become a tool to make money for big companies
BuffMordecai  +   634d ago
I'd take commercial game art over some pretentious, subjective,and empty so called "modern art" any day.

Related image(s)
#8 (Edited 634d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
trenso1  +   634d ago
Of course games aren't art they're a collaboration of designers and coders coming together to join character models and active scenery in an journey with engaging dialogue and story telling leaving a lasting impression on you, creating a thousand sentences not words......but yea video games aren't art
#9 (Edited 634d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Jamiex66  +   634d ago
Nice to know you didn't read anything but the title ;)
TheRealSpy  +   634d ago
The movies that do best at the boxoffice don't have anything in them that resembles art.
ShaunCameron  +   634d ago
Did they ever claim to have anything in them resembling art?
TheRealSpy  +   632d ago
My point is that they aren't mutually exclusive, and that art is subjective.

Thanks for your absolutely irrelevant response.
Theangrybogan  +   634d ago
Wow! What a great article, it's a shame a lot of people commenting here obviously didn't read past the title.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Natsuiro High School details and screenshots

24m ago - D3 Publisher has released the first full set of screenshots and details for its 2015-due open-wor... | PS3

Fight Mighty No. 9 Bosses Now In Mighty Gunvolt

24m ago - You can blast Mighty No. 1 and Mighty No. 8 before Mighty No. 9 comes out next spring. These two... | 3DS

Escape Dead Island Review (GameWatcher)

24m ago - From GameWatcher.com: “Please Deep Silver, give us a third person cel-shaded Dead Island spin-off... | PC

White Knight Chronicles Developer Plans To Reveal A PS4 Game In E3 2015

30m ago - Level-5 the studio behind Ni no Kuni and more famously known for Yo-kai Watch in Japan has been w... | PS4

Blood & Blade Giveaway

Now - Join us in celebrating the release of Blood & Blade with a key giveaway for in game gems. | Promoted post

Defending A Developers Right For Post-Release Embargo’s On Reviews

30m ago - Captain Camper of Gamers Heroes writes: This is not a battle between developer and consumer. T... | Industry