100°
Submitted by ICC_06 790d ago | opinion piece

Overkill: The anti-hype and hate for Aliens: Colonial Marines

MMGN: It’s fine to criticise it for its actual and many faults, but this isn’t the second coming of Hitler. I feel emotions have stunted objectivity in this case. Even if it isn’t a good game. (Aliens: Colonial Marines, PC, PS3, Xbox 360)

badjournalism  +   790d ago
Where were all these types of articles when it was Duke Nukem Forever? FYI, it's not just journalists who are pissed and unhappy.
Linsolv  +   790d ago
Actually this is exactly what the guy who got canned from Gearbox when DNF came out said.

There were problems with the game, he said, but the reaction was way, way, way worse than the game deserved--the video game journalism community was clearly trying to send a message with those DNF reviews, and to an extent I'm seeing that here, as well.

(Although this game seems to be a complete mess--I am loving the videos of bugs from this game--where Duke Nukem Forever was just a clear example of a product being put out past its expiration date, so debatably it deserves the scores more than DNF did)
#1.1 (Edited 790d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
badjournalism  +   790d ago
Someone on the inside said it. I'm referring to all these articles defending A:CM like it's somehow a sin to bash it. There were none of these from the games' media then.

I agree with the parenthetical, though. Gearbox really didn't have anything to do with the DNF debacle other than being the company to buy the IP and stitching together a working game from a shattered, smoking ruin. In this case, if things coming out from testers and other insiders is to be believed, GBX totally screwed Sega and everyone else involved over and are reaping the rewards of doing so.
#1.1.1 (Edited 790d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report
Its9000orMore  +   790d ago
Journalists and Gamers are upset over the way the game was presented. They were mislead and were shown false gameplay demonstrations. It isn't rocket science.
zmack  +   790d ago
Well it's not like this is some run of the mil cheap DLC game. Colonial Marines is priced at a full $60. Also, like the article states, gearbox showed some footage of a much better and seemingly more complete game in their past presentations. Gearbox only has themselves to blame for any of the hype it got before release, and Colonial Marines deserves every bit of the negative attention it has been getting.

Let's also not forget this is suppose to be official canon, so movie buffs can also chime in on the lackluster storyline. Simply put, the game is just terrible and IMO it is not overkill to chastise and go all out when the finished product just seems like it broke so many promises.

Journalists and gamers alike especially those who jumped on the preorder bandwagon have every right to be outraged at the end product regardless of the poorly managed development behind the scenes.
#3 (Edited 790d ago ) | Agree(8) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
Skate-AK  +   790d ago
Well said and its all that needs to be said. Bubz.
GamerEuphoria  +   790d ago
This guy speaks the truth. Our review was willing to give it a 5.5/10 but the story slapped that to a 4.5. For a game sold as a official sequel to Aliens it fails on nearly every level.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

Mortal Kombat X - Review | My Games Lounge

45m ago - MGL: The new generation of Mortal Kombat is here and when this was originally announced I was ve... | PC
30°

Game Review: Life is Strange: Episode 2 | XXIV Magazine

47m ago - Whether or not you should play Life is Strange: Episode Two boils down to how well you can delay... | PC
Ad

Help Myriad get through Steam Greenlight!

Now - Myriad is a twin-stick shooter that grows more beautiful the better you play, where you build and then destroy the game space in glorious chain rea... | Promoted post
30°

Review: OlliOlli 2: Welcome To Olliworld (PS4/PS Vita) - Geeks Under Grace

47m ago - GUG Writer, Jonathon Klassen does a review of OlliOlli 2 on the PS4, and PS Vita. | PC
40°

Mortal Kombat X | AUTOMATON Review

2h ago - AUTOMATON's Peter Martin gets in way over his head with Mortal Kombat X—and is glad he did. Here'... | PC
40°

NBA 2K15 Says the Golden State Warriors Will Be Your 2015 NBA Champs

2h ago - 2K's sports sim predicts the outcome of the 2015 NBA playoffs. | PC