Submitted by TheSuperior 673d ago | opinion piece

John or Jack Marston to Not Star in the Next Red Dead Game?

There have been a lot of rumors flying about RockStar’s next step in the Red Dead series. Players took a huge liking to this Western game and along with it a great love for the games protagonist, John Marston. This was a game original from most every other game out there. It took players and placed them in a setting they weren’t used to playing. Red Dead: Redemption had a great plotline, long game play and familiarity that players weren’t used to. Of course, with all the good there is to say about the game fans want a squeal. With the way RockStar has taken fan favorite games in the past the odd of getting a direct squeal to Red Dead: Redemption isn’t as good as players might want them to be. (PC, PS3, Red Dead Redemption, Red Dead Redemption 2, Xbox 360)

TheSuperior  +   673d ago
I would love to see John back if they could do it in a believeable way. Didnt care for Jack. so John over unknown but unknown over Jack.
Root  +   673d ago

I thought it would of been good if they did a DLC for RDR which tells us an alternative story about the ending

Like an Outlaw Josey Wales type of story

The government come early for John, he's away, since Abbi and Jack won't give him up they kill them both, John comes home to house on fire and sees the two people he spent days trying to save now gone. Now that he's become a broken man he reverts to his old ways and decides the that "once an outlaw, always an outlaw" so he decides to get revenge on the two government agents with the help on people he's met throughout the game. The final missions in the DLC would lead up to the big fight where he would finally kill them both.

At the end he starts to warm up to Bonnie, hinting at some romance before he rides off into the sunset as an outlaw with nothing to loose


They could continue it using that DLC's ending

The way he went in the game was silly in my opinion, I mean Johns a smart man but how did he know the Government weren't going to go after Abbi and Jack anyway. They did try to kill them when they came for John and they were shooting at the house. Just seemed pretty silly to me.

In my opinion he should of just ran, sent a letter to Abbi and Jack explaining he can never come home. Least then the next game could be John trying to clear his name or something
Blacktric  +   673d ago
" I mean Johns a smart man but how did he know the Government weren't going to go after Abbi and Jack anyway."

He didn't. But that was the only thing he could do to at least have some sort proof that they wouldn't go after them. If he ran, government agents would've easily captured his family again and held them hostage to lure him back in. That was the theme of the game anyway. Redemption through sacrifice. He proved to everyone that he wasn't some cold hearted bastard that killed people for money but was a family man who just wanted to be left alone with his family after doing the dirty work of the government. But I really do like the idea of a DLC that focuses on revenge. Zombie DLC was really fun but if it was something like you said, it would've been better.
#1.1.1 (Edited 673d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(2) | Report
Sandmano  +   673d ago
Jack turned out to be a badass John had his time but I doubt itl be Jack
kingfetish17  +   673d ago
The next RDR, Bully, & Manhunt games on next-gen consoles would be worth hyping about!

I personally want to see the next RDR game set sometime before Redemption in a different location. More with a "Cowboy vs Indian" emphasis. It would be cool if R* implemented multiple playable characters like GTA5. I'd like to play a Native Indian role where bow & arrows are used and the ability to climb trees is possible. All characters can be new and intertwined as the story progresses.
#1.3 (Edited 673d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
bullymangLer  +   673d ago
why a sequel when Red Dead Redemption is a Huge game full of different angled slopes and valleys always feeling new online ? ..
in my factual opinion, Rockstar should not work on a new Red Dead Redemptions game, Rockstar should work on the games pop-up, and in adding more weapons like a machete or bow-and arrow etc . and also they should make a new room, a real Hardcore room. not this radar with dots that blow your cover
Awesome_Gamer  +   673d ago
Agree. John Marston is one of my favourite video game characters, ever. I hated Jack, though.
NYC_Gamer  +   673d ago
John is dead and Jack already got revenge for his fathers death
#2 (Edited 673d ago ) | Agree(24) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
MestreRothN4G  +   673d ago
Nice spoilers.
ApolloTheBoss  +   673d ago
It's been 3 years since Red Dead came out. There is no excuse why anyone who hasn't played it could have at LEAST rented the game by now.
A2X_  +   673d ago
A little Spoilers tag wouldn't hurt, but the spoilers are well deserved if you still didn't play this game by now..
#2.1.2 (Edited 673d ago ) | Agree(7) | Disagree(1) | Report
greatcrusader44  +   672d ago
Its been out for a few yrs now and SPOILER tags never work, at least for me cuz I still accidentally pick up a few keywords out of focus when I read SPOILERS.
classic200  +   673d ago
rockstar always gives us new characters which is cool
jrbeerman11  +   673d ago
this, discussion over
Reverent  +   673d ago
Not here on N4G though! Lol...
linkkjm  +   673d ago
A prequel would be cool, about John's outlaw days
SheaHoff  +   673d ago
Looking forward to it!
THESHAUNZY  +   673d ago
R.I.P. John >.<
Monkeycan8  +   673d ago
I hope it's someone new. Johns story is over. Jack maybe but his story is also kinda over. All I know is I can't wait for Red Dead 3!
SAE  +   673d ago
I never expected the ending that's why i loved it but i hate what happened :(
KaBaW  +   673d ago
@SAE -
Agreed. I thought it was one of the better game endings that Ive played through, tho.
#8.1 (Edited 673d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Prcko  +   673d ago
i just want new read dead,that game changed my view about new gen(current gen)gaming
Sharius  +   673d ago
of all the game in current gen console i have been played, i must admit that RDR have the most beautiful and dynamic sky and weather, even game like skyrim or AC3 i dont have the same feeling each time i look up to the sky like in RDR
MestreRothN4G  +   673d ago
Maybe because RDR is the only game you mentioned that is more than marketing?
XXXL  +   673d ago
Give me a prequel with Landon Ricketts as the main character and have it follow his exploits which eventually led him to Mexico. John could be included in the latter part of the game when ricketts is in mexico. It could cover the old west and include the industrial change that was a big part of redemption. I personally love the way Redemption ended and feel John's story was concluded perfectly.
#11 (Edited 673d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
zbg31610  +   673d ago
SPOILERS(even though everyone has beat it.) There is no chance that it could be Jack. If you played and understood red dead you should understand why. A major theme in the game was that times were changing and in the new modern era, outlaws could no longer survive like they could in the old west. That is also why John HAD to die. You cant be a murderer outlaw in modern life and expect to get away with it
Tex117  +   673d ago
Dude, the 1960's anti-hero motif was lost on most gamers.

I thought it was arguable the best ending in video game history.

It actually was complex...just like you said...he HAD to die, and if you didn't see it coming (or want it to happen), then you don't understand westerns or what the game was getting at.

As for the next one (and the thought tickles my loins). Give me some more characters. John and Jack told their story.
snowman2149  +   673d ago
It will be a new character considering what rockstar has done in the past BUT I think it will be set decades before red dead redemption since read dead is set in the year 1910 right before world war 1..so there's no way they would have a western set during or after world war 1 that just does not exist. So I'm guessing the next red dead will be set in the mid 1800s either before or after the civil war
akaakaaka  +   673d ago
i don't think anyone care.. we just want another RDR to be bigger and better with a new plot and more bad ass main character.
just like GTA does..
Nodoze  +   673d ago
Make it an entirely new character....OR make it a prequel.
ApolloTheBoss  +   673d ago
It should definitely be a new character. Off topic: Red Dead multiplayer was the best multiplayer I ever played.
#16 (Edited 673d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
FarCryLover182  +   673d ago
Please no, no Jack.
stefan771  +   673d ago
I would prefer new characters
e-p-ayeaH  +   673d ago
Landon Ricketts story to become a famous gunslinger and maybe a younger John Marston somewhere in the game.

Related image(s)
#19 (Edited 673d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
isarai  +   673d ago
Seeing as how Red from the first game wasn't in the second, i kinda see this series as completely separate tales of redemption, not a continuing story. so that's fine by me
thedarkvault  +   673d ago
since Red dead redemption was set in the dying years of the wild west I would prefer they went back rather than forward in time for the setting of the next game.
Decaf_PIxel_Kat  +   673d ago
As much as I love John, I would like to play with a new character.
STICKzophrenic  +   673d ago
TheGrimBunny  +   672d ago
i am sure it will still be an amazing game, Rockstar never disappoints.
ZBlacktt  +   672d ago
John will somehow be saved as the wounds he took did not kill him. Guy was to alpha to die.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

The Crew Review - GamesTM

5m ago - GamesTM: "A pretty respectable technical achievement masquerading as a piece of entertainment, Th... | PC

Assassin’s Creed Unity Review - GamesTM

5m ago - GamesTM: "The plot this time is even more offhand and episodic than usual, and protagonist Arno D... | PC

EGMR Awards 2014: Developer Of The Year

5m ago - EGMR writes: "This award is very difficult to hand out. Developers often bring out more than one... | PC

EGMR Awards 2014: Bastard Of The Year

5m ago - EGMR writes: "The Bastard of the Year Award is what we give to someone who did something so basta... | PC

Win a PS4!!

Now - Join us on Filmwatch to find out how you can win a free PS4 this holiday season! | Promoted post

WWE 2K15 Review - VGU

5m ago - With the next generation of wrestling games available for the world, how does WWE 2K15 stand up t... | Xbox 360