200°
Submitted by Pozzle 544d ago | opinion piece

Top 5 Video Game Stories

From Mortal Kombat to Darksiders and more, the 411 staff counts down their top 5 video game stories of all time! (Darksiders: Wrath of War, Final Fantasy X, Legacy of Kain: Soul Reaver, Mortal Kombat, PC, PS2, PS3, Retro, The Legend of Dragoon, Xbox 360)

TheLyonKing  +   544d ago
10 beats 6,7,8,9 um I don't think so.

Also where is kingdom hearts? A bit confusing but once you get it it is a brilliant story.

I found 10 to be a great story but just not as good as the others.
Kur0  +   544d ago
10 had a better story than 8 at least. Best would be 6.
TheLyonKing  +   544d ago
i disgaree i find 8 to have the best story in the series:

I felt for every character even Edea, and the places made the stories come alive.

Non PC's had more emotion if found from the mayor of Fishermans horizon to the Zell's mother.

The twist at the end of 8 was brilliant as well, overall fantastic story writing. out of ten i would give ff 10 an 8 the rest I would give a 9 out my list and 8 a 9.5.

My opinions and I understand why people would rate them in an other order. I think I rate 8 most highly as it was my first proper playthrough of a final fantasy.
Nerdmaster  +   544d ago
@TheLyonKing

At first I thought you were crazy. Then you said "The twist at the end of 8 was brilliant" and I was 100% sure that you were crazy. Then you said "it was my first proper playthrough of a final fantasy" and I understood why you think those things. Nostalgia blinds us. If you had played and finished 4, 6 or heck, even 7 (I really dislike 7), you'd see how bad 8 was. Bad characters, bad plot, worst plot twist ever, bad magic system...
LightofDarkness  +   544d ago
It's hard to list them based solely on the merits of their story-telling, because each one brought something new and more advanced but also tended to lose something along the way.

The only FF games with what I would call "good" stories (generally considered great for videogames at the time) are IV, VI, VII and IX. IV really pushed the envelope for story-telling at the time, with actual characters and a strong plot to keep you moving. VI continued this trend and even introduced a love story, with arguably the strongest plot of the series. VII continued to add emotional depth along with unprecedented presentation (even if it did have some small plot issues). IX was a welcome return to form, re-introducing the classic FF feel while upping the presentation ante again, and is (IMO) probably the strongest of the PSX games, even if it did little to advance the series really.

However, after VII, things began to sink quite a bit. VIII, while obviously boasting the strongest and most eye-catching looks for an FF game to-date, had one of the worst plots in the series. The pacing was terrible, the plot was more hole-y than the pope and the characters were either unfathomably stupid, cardboard cutouts or utterly unlikable. While IX was a return to form, it didn't actually advance the series in any sincere fashion, it just sort of steadied the course after VIII went off it too much.

X had many similar problems to VIII with regards characters, plot-holes and pacing, including the first instance of "the lead character that shouldn't have been the lead character". It has probably the best battle system of the series, but it contends with VIII for one of the worst stories of all (and also bears the blame for introducing terrible linearity). XII would've had a great story, were it not for the obvious lead character change to generic blonde teenager (a la X). XIII seemed to be trying to give the fans what they said they wanted: more emotional and focused stories, more fast-paced battles and better looks. In other words: like X, but faster and prettier.

Be careful what you wish for, I guess.

That said, no one can say that the storytelling in VI was better than that of even games like VIII or XIII. Character moods switch from manic to maudlin within two sentences in VI, and the presentation is obviously leagues beneath the modern games. However, the strength of the plot makes it feel like a better story. That's the big difference between the real classics and the pretenders.

Nostalgia counts for a lot; IV is my first FF and it holds a very dear place in my heart. But I've grown to objectively admit that VI and VII have better stories, and almost every one since tells it better (despite some denial for a long time). I would hope those whose first FF games were X or VIII would be able to objectively evaluate them, but that's usually not the case, unfortunately.
Nerdmaster  +   544d ago
@LightofDarkness

[SPOILER]
Completely disagree about Tidus being "the lead character that shouldn't have been the lead character" like Squall and Vaan. Tidus was sent from the Faith to stop Jecht. Not growing up in Spira made him question things the other character never dared to question because they grew up under the teachings of Yevon (like "why are machinas considered so bad?"). And he provided one of the best plost twists ever (him being a summon - dream of the faith brought to life by a summoner, in this case Yu Yevon himself). So, as Tidus says, it's his story.
[/SPOILERS]

Different from Vaan, who decided to go along because he didn't have anything else to do besides blaming Basch for his brother's death. Or Squall, who... I really don't know why he was made the protagonist. To be part of the game's romantic couple, I guess (and it was the worst one in any FF). Quistis should've been the protagonist.
Pozzle  +   544d ago
It really isn't Tidus' story though. It's Yuna's story. Tidus' beef with Jecht is really just a side-plot to Yuna's pilgrimage and the choices she must make. Her journey would have happened even if Tidus never showed up in Spira, though of course it would have been a little different.
#1.1.5 (Edited 544d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report
Wintersun616  +   544d ago
The lack of MGS3 on this list makes it an instant fail.
gillri  +   544d ago
Forget MGS3, MGS1 had a better story but Mass Effect 1 beats them both
kma2k  +   544d ago
This gen stories not in order for me
Bioshock, Alan Wake, The Walking Dead, Spec Ops:The Line, Red Dead Redemption.

Honerable Mentions:
Darksiders, Heavy Rain
#3 (Edited 544d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
BanBrother  +   544d ago
Great list. Agree with them.

I'd also add The Darkness, Metro 2033, and Prey. Oh and Assassin's Creed 2.
kma2k  +   544d ago
Holy crap its early i completely forgot about The Darkness & Assassins Creed 2 (kinda sad since its my avatar) lol Good call!
Son_Lee  +   544d ago
FF fans are too divisive to have a sophisticated debate most of the time. FFVII is my fave and I think it had the best story, but FFX is a close-second, so I have no beef.
Godmars290  +   544d ago
Chrono Trigger
FF4
RPG1201  +   544d ago
Why don't people respect another person's taste!? No one opinion is crazy or wrong... I'm not going to try and shove what I like into everyone else; hell i like being different, even if my top game is a cliche...

I personally like Final Fantasy VII, then X and the Tactics, the rest are awesome too. XIII's combat was ok, but the story what just lacking. BTW, FF8's twist ending was a great change of pace from the same old same old.
#6 (Edited 544d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
Nerdmaster  +   544d ago
Unfortunately, the change was for the worse. Unless not making any sense is good.
broken_back-man  +   543d ago
half life series in my opinion! !!

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

EA Launches PC Flash Sale - 50% Off Titanfall and 30% off Battlefield 4

11m ago - EA today launched their summer sale taking 50% off their blockbuster Titanfall. Both the Standard... | PC
10°

Otaku Dome: The Wolf Among Us "Cry Wolf" Review

13m ago - Otaku Dome: The epic season finale to Telltale’s newly adored The Wolf Among Us “Cry Wolf” has... | PC
30°

10 essential tips/tricks for Destiny Beta Guardians

16m ago - Nerd Reactor does the 10 essential tips/tricks for Destiny Beta. | Xbox 360
40°

Kinect may not be a hit with gamers, but it is poised to become a medical game-changer

16m ago - Xbox One’s highly innovative Kinect sensor may not be the biggest hit with hard-core gamers – Mic... | Xbox One
Ad

Looking for a great Pokemon Community?

Now - Look no further. Join us at the BulbaGarden Forums, the best community for everything Pokemon | Promoted post
10°

Concursion Review | WGTC

17m ago - Michael from We Got This Covered wrote: I’d be lying if I said that I knew exactly what I was... | PC
Related content from friends