eGamer writes: "Slenderman’s Shadow is finally complete, and it’s been well worth the wait. It’s just an amazing experience that has been stunningly recreated, and it’s fantastic value for money. If you’re a fan of Slender and especially this series, you should absolutely not hesitate to buy this. The only thing holding it back right now is Slender Man’s disappointing model, but if it gets changed in future updates, this game will be damn near perfect. Right now, it’s easily one of the best Slender releases out there."