Submitted by TheMrFraz 1007d ago | opinion piece

Should Raw Emotions Rule Game of the Year Awards?

With Game of the Year awards galore, Journey and The Walking Dead earned an awful lot of superior praise in 2012. Yet the core gameplay of each was anything but revolutionary. Should overall best-of awards take every aspect of a gaming experience into account, or are emotions enough to become true trump cards? (Culture, Journey, The Walking Dead: Episode 1 "A New Day")

jyang  +   1008d ago
This post is going to be a multidirectional mess.

At risk of sounding like a pretentious dolt, video writing has been lagging a bit behind other major media, such as film and literature, if only because it's the younger of the bunch. We have a lot of catching up to do, and we can't stand on the shoulders of giants because this specific media is so much more radically different than the others.

We may be oversimplifying it a bit by framing it as raw emotion, though, because the term 'raw emotion' is indicative of an irrational sensation which can often clash with the sheer amount of effort involved in craft that narrative.

Likewise, I think you bring up a pretty good point regarding our priorities when you insinuate that we ('we' in the large, broader, community) inflate the value of story. Personally, I believe story should be the primary strength of a game, but story is tied centrally to how the game functions.

Perhaps because we've grown up with an industry that focused for the longest time over providing a set of key interactive components rather than attempting to approach it on intrinsic grounds we've started to really look at resonance. Maybe that resonance is what's key, not the emotions themselves.

TheMrFraz  +   1007d ago
A beautiful answer so unlike a typical Internet comment. Much appreciated, my friend. Thanks for reading.
jyang  +   1007d ago
I much appreciate the reply.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

How You Helped Improve Call of Duty: Black Ops III Multiplayer

16m ago - David Vonderhaar, Game Design Director, Treyarch writes: "We’ve said it before but it bears re... | PS4

Amazon Video Game Deals of the Week: Weekender Edition

18m ago - Gamerdeals: "Amazon has updated their video game deals section with discounts and price matchi... | Nintendo DS

MoreConsole takes on Destiny: The Taken King

Now - MoreConsole's rag-tag band of guardians finally make it to the Oryx's ship...but can they make it out alive? | Promoted post

The best Legendary weapons in Destiny: The Taken King, part one - primaries

18m ago - Exotics are overrated; Legendary weapons will always be at the core of your arsenal, and with Iro... | Xbox 360

Rainbow Six Siege Preview (Invision Community)

22m ago - Onto the beta itself though, the gameplay side of things was fantastic. Dynamic gameplay is excit... | PC

Super Blackout Is Coming to PS Vita Next Week, Here’s Our Early Thoughts - The Games Cabin

22m ago - The Games Cabin does a short preview of the upcoming Super Blackout game for the PS Vita. | PS Vita