Gamer Limit: "Paper Mario: Sticker Star is clever and fully committed to its paperized setting. That’s not enough to excuse its biggest flaws. You’ll spend time backtracking and getting stuck on puzzles that require too much guesswork. But then you’ll get past them, and you’ll see another fun paper-based setpiece. It’s too bad that the game vacillates so much between the two extremes rather than sticking to a more consistent middle ground."