120°
Submitted by Lavalamp 732d ago | review

Assassin's Creed III Review | Slant Magazine

Slant Magazine: "The game is astonishingly dedicated to ruining the series' fiction, wasting as much of the player's time as possible." (Assassin's Creed III, PC, PS3, Xbox 360) 1/5

Daavpuke  +   732d ago
Well, I bit the bullet and gave the story a hit, since I don't believe it should necessarily be considered flamebait to write a harsh review on a well-known game.

Now, the review does seem extremely odd to me. It's not just the styling that smushes everything into 1 paragraph or the writer's inability to predict proper punctuation. He has a strange contrast between having a decent lyrical style and not knowing how to handle it; I have no idea why. It is more in line that the review is more of a constant, almost detached berating of the game with little argument inside. In clarity, most of the points illustrated boil down to: "This isn't the old Assassin's Creed lore. What's this new thing?"

Such as this one: "It isn't much of a spoiler for me to reveal that the first few hours of the game center around an entirely different (and irrelevant) protagonist" - Because Desmond is somehow not that in the previous games?

Or the stark contrast it has between calling the game too short and then saying: "Assassin's Creed III is encumbered with an abundance of horrible, boring side quests that exist only to waste the player's time. Most of these are lifted from previous games, where the collectibles, territory acquisition, Brotherhood recruiting, and so on were naturally implemented instead of forced" - While implying earlier that Relevations does somehow NOT do the same. It has a tower defense element and micromanagement system, of all things.

Calling for the naval battles to have their own dedicated game was the final nail. Though if I can assume this is meant as a non-dedicated AssCreed game, then perhaps. But it would be weird to have an AssCreed title to a game that has very little of both words, no?

I just hope they change the site style though. That spacing is terrible. Well, inexistent, but that is quite bad.
ajax17  +   732d ago
Trolls gotta troll
Mocat  +   732d ago
Looks more like your the troll, people have diffrent opinions, deal with it.
ahronith  +   731d ago
No, when an opinion is so far on an opposite end of the spectrum, it is no longer justified as just an opinion, but becomes a trivial and controversal piece for whatever the writers reason may be.
ajax17  +   731d ago
No game that polished deserves a 1/5, period.
#2.1.2 (Edited 731d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report
lociefer  +   732d ago
well its not the best one of the series but also its not a 1/5 , just had to be ''that site''
MrAnderson  +   732d ago
Under the words "read full review" at the top of the page, is the name of the website, click on that, then give it a "WTF" and "No" for "story quality" and "liked this website?" vote it down people, it's just trolling for hits.
#4 (Edited 732d ago ) | Agree(6) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
0pie  +   732d ago
AC3 isnt a goty or the greatest game ever... but giving a 1/5 is just dumb.
Anyway, its juste another obscure/unkown website provin that we shouldnt give too much attention to these websites...
#5 (Edited 732d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
PhoenixRising37  +   732d ago
I know of a site that wanted some hits!

SLANT MAGAZINE!
ZBlacktt  +   732d ago
Guy gives it a 1 to get hits on his story... Meanwhile in the real world. The game was up for the GOTY award.
#7 (Edited 732d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

Batman: Arkham City Retrospective

27m ago - "In October 2011, Rocksteady released Arkham City, the sequel to the well-received Arkham Asylum,... | PC
20°

Review: Oddworld: Munch's Oddysee HD (PlayStation Network - Vita) | PushSquare

35m ago - PushSquare: "When the Oddworld franchise made the move to 3D, the developer decided that many of... | PS Vita
20°

Review: PES 2015: Pro Evolution Soccer (PlayStation 4) - PushSquare

38m ago - PushSquare: "With last year’s PES 2014: Pro Evolution Soccer opting to skip the PlayStation 4, K... | PS4
30°

MWEB GameZone's Top 5 PC Exclusives of 2014

43m ago - This year has been an exciting time to be a PC gamers. Here are MWEB GameZone's Top 5 exclusive P... | PC
Ad

Are you bored?

Now - Watch 10 seconds videos about games and game culture at COUB Gaming... | Promoted post
20°

Dreamscapes: Nightmare's Heir - Review | AACG

43m ago - Dreamscapes: Nightmare's Heir is nowhere near its predecessor's greatness, both in terms of crea... | PC