Submitted by mmoattack 574d ago | opinion piece

Gaming's Most Poorly-Written Female Characters

MMO Attack has compiled a little wall of shame, commemorating some of the most poorly written, stereotypical, and downright irritating female characters in gaming. (PC, PS2, PS3, Xbox, Xbox 360)

Godmars290  +   574d ago
Yes, you're going to get flack for the ICO chick.

The hero of the game didn't get much character development or explanation - except via gameplay. Likewise next to nothing is known about Yorda. Whether or not she's even a princess is an assumption.
mmoattack  +   574d ago
Alos88  +   574d ago
I'm not sure you can call a character that has about 3 lines of dialogue "poorly written", especially given that the rest of the plot was equally minimalist.
Godmars290  +   574d ago
Didn't say she or Ico were poorly written. The story was as presented. In minimalist fashion through gameplay.

But Yorda being on a list like this is perhaps being overly sensitive to sexism.
SilentNegotiator  +   574d ago
The character that allowed herself to be captured needed help throughout the story?

MariaHelFutura  +   574d ago
Yorda = the ICO chick
stevecall   574d ago | Spam
PhoenixRising37  +   574d ago
How is princess peach "poorly written" when she doesn't say anything in the first place besides "MARIOOOO!"

I think Sonia from Ninja Gaiden II is pretty bad...
GamersXTREME  +   574d ago
Interesting list but there's a mistake I spotted with it. Ashley Graham's photo is the featured image here and she is also listed in this article...but there's nothing written about her at all. When you go to read about why she's "poorly written", the writer mentions a totally different character (Zoe) from an entirely different game (Dreamfall). Other than that, this was a decent read.
#4 (Edited 574d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
HonestDragon  +   574d ago
Okay, what? Seriously, there are worse female characters in general in video games. Others that were very poorly written. Most of the list seems rushed, but I do see a special case.

Samus - From Metroid: Other M? Are you kidding me? This game is so underrated. Look, just because they gave Samus some emotion and humanity does not make her any less of who she already is. We got to learn about her past before she suited up in the armor. She is not "weak", "submissive", or "childish". I bet the author just hated the game because it was different.

Princess Peach - Okay, now you're just grasping at straws here. Peach hardly has any dialogue. For that matter, Mario and Luigi hardly say anything. Bowser is always the one who has the most dialogue in any given Mario game. Peach is a simple character with simple dialogue. What does this guy expect? Shakespeare in the park?

Vanille - Okay, you have a point there. Vanille is one of the weakest characters in the Final Fantasy franchise. Her dialogue can be summed up in Youtube cam girls stating the obvious or acting ditzy. Oh, and also not knowing what accent she has.

Ashley Graham - There's a mistake here. The picture and name are of Ashley from Resident Evil 4, but there is no actual info on the character. It's of Zoe from Dreamfall. Editing needed for that one.
Godmars290  +   574d ago
Samus issues has to do with her going from being a solitary protagonist doing everything for herself in the many games before, to what she was in Other M. Which was subservient.
Pozzle  +   573d ago
Particularly that infamous lava section where Samus doesn't turn on her Varia suit (heat shield) because Adam didn't authorize it, even though she could BURN TO DEATH as a result.

Call it sexist or call it stupid. It was things like this that made Other M's version of Samus a poorly written character.
#5.1.1 (Edited 573d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report
metroidfusion2  +   574d ago
I like other m a good game and a different perspective and a younger samus etc etc the game I thought was really good and I wont go into details the idiots need to do their research
AznGaara  +   574d ago
Oh Vanille.. Is she wasn't such a good saboteur, medic and ravager I wouldn't put her in my party at all. Her voice actor didn't help either.
Lord_Sloth  +   574d ago
This list is stupid just because of the inclusion of Yorda.

Also anybody who expects grand writing and dialogue from a Mario game is pretty dense.
madjedi  +   573d ago
Work on some resemblance of a story first, then worry about dialogue for mario or zelda games
"Also anybody who expects grand writing and dialogue from a Mario game is pretty dense."

Right but it couldn't hurt if they could get over the helpless female routine and have the princess be not completely useless for once.

Make one game where, she saves mario and luigi for a change. And give zelda her game back or change the name already.

I am not a white knight pro feminist male by any measure, in fact i generally hate those types. But if our medium is maturing can we at least advance past the 12th century in regards to helpless princesses.
#8.1 (Edited 573d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
Zhipp  +   573d ago
lmfao! I guess you've never heard of Super Princess Peach? It's pretty awesome, you should check it out.
Also, The Legend of Zelda sounds a hell of a lot cooler than "The Legend of Link", though the latter name would be more accurate. :D And Zelda does fight alongside Link in the WW and TP final battles, iirc.
ame22  +   573d ago
In other words, all the Japanese characters.
StrawHatPatriot  +   573d ago
I would like it if Lightning was on the list.

Sorry but I had to say it.
Tetsujin  +   573d ago
I hate how SE is trying to make Lightning into the new "Cloud" of FF games; I know there's mixed opinions about 13, however I'd vote her being on the list to.
madjedi  +   573d ago
Problem is cloud wasn't a completely unlikeable douchebag with chip on his shoulder, nothing in part 13 or the little bit of 13-2 i played changed my mind about the character in any positive way.

Basically the most unlikeable protaganist in any ff game i have played to date.
landog  +   573d ago
ashly is hot

her and hunnigan


Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

VGU Talks: Violence In Video Games

5m ago - With many games designed around violence and with a recent interview with Ken Levine, are violent... | Culture

Dynasty Warriors: Gundam Reborn - PS3 Review | Chalgyr's Game Room

5m ago - Chalgyr's Game Room writes: Growing up in Canada the anime scene wasn’t quite what it is today... | PS3

FX Networks to Sneak Peek Its New Drama 'The Strain' Exclusively on Xbox

6m ago - LOS ANGELES, July 11, 2014 – FX Networks is teaming with Xbox Video to offer an exclusive experie... | Xbox 360

Blue Estate review | PS4 Attitude

6m ago - PS4 Attitude: "Blue Estate is an on-rails shooter for the PlayStation 4, based on the comic book... | PS4

Start Making Games for the PS4

Now - Want to design the next generation of video games? Start learning game design today. Click for more info on how to get started. | Promoted post

Defining Moments-- Far Cry 2

8m ago - Continue Play's Peter Yankowski reflects on the balance between life and death in Far Cry 2's vis... | PC