Submitted by 32froshes 1081d ago | opinion piece

Why Dark Souls is Not A 'Hack And Slash' Game

Does anyone remember the PlayStation 3’s 2009 gem, Demon’s Souls? Would you believe that some critics actually equated it to God of War II? Here’s another imponderable: The game’s spiritual successor, FromSoftware’s Dark Souls, was often given the misnomer “beat-‘em-up.” Even now, after the recent release of the game’s first downloadable content, some reviewers stand by this claim. (Dark Souls, Demon's Souls, PC, PS3, Xbox 360)

Canary  +   1081d ago
It's a third person action-combat game in a medieval fantasy setting.

I realize it can be difficult ascribing genre to games because we have to consider both the narrative genre and gameplay tropes... but it's not -that- hard.
-GametimeUK-  +   1081d ago
"Third person action-combat game"?

I think it is quite criminal to not cover the fact that it is an RPG. Its quite simply an Action RPG.
MagneticDeath  +   1081d ago
Agreed 3rd person action rpg.
Blackdeath_663  +   1081d ago
agreed i was just going to say that its an RPG a proper RPG like they all should be. also i don't think anyone who has played a souls game ever even thought about it as a hack 'n' slash game. dark souls requires much more skill than most games, button bashing will get you killed in one shot.
cpayne93  +   1081d ago
Hack and slash I can almost understand but beat em up? BEAT EM UP??? No, just no.
sdozzo  +   1081d ago
No one calls it hack and slash.
SolidDuck  +   1081d ago
If anyone actually says that. Then they haven't spent any time with demons or dark. There fantastic games but they are def not beat em ups, hack n slash, or a button masher in any way. Just a dumb thing to say.
Bercilak  +   1081d ago
I think of Demon's Souls as a survival horror game in a medieval fantasy setting.
MilkMan  +   1081d ago
Its a lot of things, but its not an rpg, that's for sure. Final Fantasy is more an rpg than this game and that's basically an adventure game.
Nexgensensation  +   1081d ago
hack and slash
is for game like dmc, gow, and ninja gaiden!

until I play dark souls 2 and like it, from the impression I recieve from the new director this game already failed.

this is why I dont like copy cats and imitators. now that this game damn near stole the idea from demons souls look at it now, the director have no original idea.
#7 (Edited 1081d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
Blackdeath_663  +   1081d ago
i believe it was developed buy the same studio and the story is linked in some way either a prequel or a sequel to daemon souls but it definitely wasn't a copy or imitation.
gintoki777  +   1081d ago
Makes complete sense >.> From Software copied their own game.
MattyG  +   1081d ago
I have never seen anyone call it a hack n' slash or beat em up. Don't know where that came.
Williamson  +   1081d ago
i finally picked this game up and cant wait to start it
zgoldenlionz  +   1081d ago
Right on! I hope you enjoy. Dark souls is definitely a game everyone should at least try.
StrawberryDiesel420  +   1080d ago
What the hell took you so long? These kinds of games are the ones that should be bought for full retail price day one. I hope you didn't buy it used at least...
Williamson  +   1079d ago
I guess I was just scared of all the dying that I was going to do in the game. Lol nah i bought it new but for 20$.
MysticStrummer  +   1081d ago
Hack and slash? Dark Souls? That's hilarious.
MasterD919  +   1080d ago
My friend told me to go out and buy this game...I've been holding off because I just don't have the time, but apparently I am missing out on something epic.

He states Dark Souls is significantly better than Demon Souls as well...but again, I haven't played either.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

PlayStation 1 console wallet back in stock at £9.99

21m ago - DS: This neat retro PS1-themed wallet sold out super quick last time we posted it, so don't dawdl... | Culture

Facility 47: Walkthrough Guide

24m ago - Appunwrapper writes: "This is a complete step-by-step walkthrough guide with hints, tips, tricks,... | iPhone

Win the Marvel Cinematic Universe Phase 2 Boxset!!

Now - Join us on FIlmwatch to find out how you could win the much anticipated Marvel Cinematic Universe Phase 2 Boxset on Blu-ray. | Promoted post

Super Black Friday Sweep, a colourful Black Friday action game satire

25m ago - As you all know by now, it´s Black Friday today. And that means lunatic cheap prices on games, ha... | PC

Three Fourths Home: Extended Edition now available on Xbox One in the UK

32m ago - Neil writes "Is it a game, or a piece of art? Whatever it is, Three Fourths Home is now available... | Xbox One

Radial-G: Infinity X Heading to Gear VR with Upgrades

36m ago - VRFocus reports on the reveal of Radial-G: Infinity X, an upgraded version of the spin-off of the... | Android