Gimme Gimme Games argues that most consumers will not be happy with the price of a stand alone Wii U Game Pad, which sells for nearly $170 in Japan. They make the case that Nintendo should bundle software made just for dual Game Pad usage with each controller to lessen the sticker shock people will have if the controller sells for $100 or more on its own.
Personally (with the two tablet game idea) I can see Nintendo really splitting the user base. If it is expensive it is essentially going to be like the motion control option from Sony and Microsoft (i.e. another expensive peripheral which the majority will not buy and so not as many games end up being made specifically for it). Nintendo could make first party games which support it as an option (like Sony did with the Move) but I can't see third parties really jumping on to it
Fast forward to the future now!
It looks like the nintendo wiiU gamepad is going to cost somewhere around 150-180 (i doubt they would go to 200) and if they added a great game for only a 10$ increase would you get it? Keep in mind this game could be a party game that includes TANKS! 2 (the most anticipated game ever and its only like 1/10th of the game)
(if you still say no then just go jump off a bridge at this point honestly)
I can understand that some hardcore gamers (that normally play alone) do not understand how a 3rd screen in the living room can revolutionize the way people play together. They think that wiiU will be a gimmick like everyone thought the wii will be a gimmick. So i would like to end this post will some worldwide sales data that i think people forget when they try to think.
WorldWide Console Sales
Wii - 53 Million
x360 - 32 Million
ps3 - 25 Million
I just think its funny when people think nintendo needs to compete with ps3 and 360. Microsoft changed its sales model to be more like nintendo and it payed off in the long run and they expanded their market. PS3 is easily the most powerful of these systems and sold the least. Again i understand that hardcore gamers are turned off by the idea of 'just a screen'. However i think they might not even need the 2nd screen to compete with Microsony. It is just icing on the cake. Really really awesome delicious icing ;)
(i write in ()'s because i think its fun)