90°
Submitted by TheLyonKing 781d ago | news

Motorola fails to win Xbox ban in US and Germany

A US judge has ruled that Google's Motorola unit cannot ban sales of Microsoft's Xbox 360 games console because of a patent dispute. (Microsoft, Xbox 360)

Alternative Sources
CraigandDayDay  +   781d ago
Motorola is just wasting their time
I don't think it would make much of a difference at this point in its lifecycle even if it was banned. MS has sold millions upon millions of consoles and it's still selling well. Plus, the new one is about to release next year most likely so it wouldn't hurt MS too much if they did have the 360's sales banned.

Also, important to note is that Microsoft probably has a lot better lawyers than Motorola. haha $$$ talks.

I do hope both the PS4 and 720 come out next year though.

Just curious but why the disagree(s)??

Not a single reply as to what people disagreed with, but ok, I guess.... I guess people are scared to let me know what they disagreed with??? haha
#1 (Edited 781d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(11) | Report | Reply
pixelsword  +   781d ago
they should have asked for money from each sale, if they didn't do that already.
nukeitall  +   781d ago
Motorola do ask for money for each sale at a ridiculous 2.25% of retail price.

Other FRAND patents are licensed at fractions of cents while Motorola wants at least $10 per Xbox 360 sold even though their patents are included into standards because they pledge fair and reasonable licensing costs.

It's like I promise you fairness so you make it an essential part, then I turn around and make it unfair!
BitbyDeath  +   781d ago
Disagrees are probably cause Motorola are owned by Google who have a serious amount of cash.
CraigandDayDay  +   781d ago
Oh, well I didn't know that. lol Well, in that case, I retract my statement.
ExPresident  +   781d ago
All about the benjamins
3GenGames  +   781d ago
If Apple was suing, they'd be banned today and off the shelves tomorrow. But Apple doesn't create any new patents, so that'll never happen. Just hypothetical.

But still, the price they're asking per xbox isn't ridiculous. Microsoft should pay it.
#3 (Edited 781d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(6) | Report | Reply
Swiggins  +   781d ago
They're asking for $4 Billion in FRAND PATANTS, that's like me charging you $100,000 for a pack of cigarettes, it's ludicrous.
3GenGames  +   781d ago
4 Billion/70 Million=about 58 dollars per xbox. But since it also spans to the Windows OS for using it too. When you factor that in, Motorola is only suing for....wait for it...

4 Billion/370 Million=only $11 per device in all actuality. I think it's safe to say they have the money and it's not ludicrous, considering how much an Xbox and Windows cost. It's punishment for stealing and using it in a profiting device. 2x the normal (Not ludicrous, but fair) licensing fee as punishment for stealing it without paying loyalties sounds about right to me.

They did it themselves. They could have just paid the 2.25% per Xbox for the license. Their fault. They need to be punished since they won't remove it from their services. Pay up.
#3.1.1 (Edited 781d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(6) | Report
Swiggins  +   781d ago
When you're licensing the same technology to other companies for a few cents, and then demanding that another company pay $11, well over a 1000% increase, that violates fair trade laws, there's no two ways about it.

Microsoft has said from the beginning that they would pay for the technology, but they certainly don't have to pay whatever Motorola wants... it doesn't work that way...

They'll probably settle somewhere in the realm of 50 million. THAT would be fair.
Raoh  +   781d ago
Damn it, I was really hoping this would happen.
Belking  +   781d ago
why? what would you get out of it?
Raoh  +   781d ago
Teach MS a lesson. I don't hide the fact that I dislike MS. And before the gaming fanboys go ballistic, I grew up with microsoft in my life. My dislike for their business practices and how it actually hinders competition and progress has been an issue with me since Windows Millenium.

Had no opinions on the xbox, thought xbox would appeal to me, a friend and I were hooked on the first halo's co op but then the news of power cord recalls due to fires and rrod and my disc scratching that the 360 caused that ms would not replace unless it was published by Microsoft also pissed me off.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

Planetside 2 claims world record – Most players in a FPS

8m ago - The Eccentric Gamer writes: "The Planetside 2 claims to have beaten the world record this weekend... | PC
40°

E-Pals: Grand Theft Auto

18m ago - Buddy Acker and Karl Dodds discuss Grand Theft Auto. | PS2
40°

Scans roundup – Bravely Second, Legend of Legacy, Majora’s Mask 3D, Pokemon Shuffle, Rodea

38m ago - Check out a bunch of scans from this week's issue of Famitsu. | Wii U
30°

Resident Evil HD Remaster Review - Still Number 1 [Dealspwn]

39m ago - Dealspwn writes: This HD remaster of a remake is a remarkable homage to the original survival hor... | PS4
Ad

Far Cry 4 (XB1) Review

Now - Ken finds his inner tiger in Kyrat. | Promoted post
30°

Wayforward Director Teases ‘Solo Project’

40m ago - Hardcore Gamer: No stranger to the ways of retro, Wayforward have become critical darlings with t... | Wii U