Submitted by miyamoto 1039d ago | article

Uncharted’s Nathan Drake: Hero or Villain? – Reader’s Feature

A reader examines the morality of Nathan Drake and asks whether the higher standards he’s held to is proof of how good a character he is.

Video games often have a hero or a villain. Nathan Drake from the popular Uncharted series is pitched as the hero of the piece, a likeable chap who’s witty, adventurous and has biometrics not too dissimilar to the average man. So, why is he so commonly referred to as a moral-less man intent on killing all those in his way? Journalists and gamers alike all seem to have referred to the fact that his moral compass is awry when it comes to his kill count. (Naughty Dog, PS Vita, PS3, Uncharted Trilogy, Uncharted: Fight for Fortune, Uncharted: Golden Abyss)

jakmckratos  +   1039d ago
He's saved the world quite a few times by killing those who would do harm to innocents. Overall he's an unintentional hero with ELena being his center of reason.
jimbobwahey  +   1039d ago
I like how the boss of Uncharted 2 actually pointed out how Drake is pretty much a mass murderer and no worse than he is. It's good that Naughty Dog are self aware enough to point these things out in the games.
violents  +   1039d ago
Yes but thats like saying that when the USA invaded germany to stop the nazi's that we were just as bad as them because we had to kill people to do it. Killing in defense of innocents is not the same as killing for personal gain. There is a distict difference. then on top of that most of the killing done by nathan drake was in self preservation, its not like the bad guys are just going to let him stroll on in.
#1.1.1 (Edited 1039d ago ) | Agree(10) | Disagree(1) | Report
th3n00bg4m3r  +   1039d ago
He is a thief, but again he is also a hero.
majiebeast  +   1039d ago
He is Nathan Drake and he is the lovable thief murder.
#3 (Edited 1039d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
Irishguy95  +   1039d ago
Hero ~ Why? Because that's the type of story it is. TloU will be more realistic in that sense
achmetha  +   1039d ago
i like him because he
Hicken  +   1039d ago
This has been explored.

Why don't we ask this question about Mario, or the gang from Gears, or Master Chief?

Or is Drake unique because he's also a thief?

People try to kill him. He kills them first. That doesn't make him a bad guy any more than anyone else in the same situation.
dafegamer  +   1039d ago
this^^ its just natural instinct to survive
Y_5150  +   1039d ago
Is Mario a bad guy that kills turtles and eats shrooms?

Nah mushrooms are is favorite treat and he's controlling the turtle (or Koopa) population!
Aaron Colas  +   1039d ago
Why does he have to be deifned as a hero or a villain?

It doesn't have to be black or white. Shit shouldn't be that simple all the time or it gets boring fast.

Nathan Drake is heroic in his shining moments; but he is motivated by self interest, be it fortune or survival, his friend's or his own.

Other than that he is aware that he lives in a world where its kill or be killed.

Hero? Villain?

Who cares!
Cajun Chicken  +   1039d ago
Reluctant hero.
dafegamer  +   1039d ago
Mario- Hero or Murderer?
Master Chief- Hero or Murderer?
What does it take to be a Hero? Even a Hero could be a murderer, if he doesnt have any other chance to stop the evil and protect the beloved ones. There is a word and its called "instinct".People should watch the Walking Dead to understand the difference between "killing" and "Instinct to survive"
wishingW3L  +   1039d ago
haven't you notice that most of the people that Drake murders are the same guys over and over again? I think this should give you the idea that he isn't killing hundreds of men, that this is just gameplay and you should take it as a metaphor of what's really going on and not as something so literal.

I do understand your point about Drake being a realistic character and then seeing him killing hundred of people during gameplay seuences. But you need to remember that gameplay consist of repetition and Snake is supposed to be a killer, that's why people doesn't care about how many people does he kill through the games. He says it many times on MGS4, that he is just an OLD killer... But since Drake seems so realistic and he doesn't has DA military background then... But Mario has killed a bunch of "things" too! But yeah, he isn't so realistic to begin with so his game doesn't suffer from these issues... Too many buts, I know but I'm not very good with English to be able to use a much wider vocabulary.
#10 (Edited 1039d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
cpayne93  +   1039d ago
Yeah I remember in uncharted 1 how you killed the same black shirtless dude with a shotgun who would always charge you. Drake does kill people, but not as many as the gameplay implies. Otherwise who the heck would try to stop him from doing anything? When a man kills thousands of armed killers almost singlehandedly, you think people would want to get out of his way.
Heisenburger  +   1039d ago
He's the hero we deserve, not the one we *blows brains out*
aDDicteD  +   1039d ago
yup he is a hero, if you feel bad about killing the enemies then melee every enemies you encounter, then the body count diminishes for about half of it. just stay away for the sneak kill cause drake most of the time snaps the enemies neck.
Beetey  +   1039d ago
I would have to disagree that Solid Snake is "characterless."
HowarthsNJ  +   1039d ago
Has "anti-hero" fallen out of our vocabulary? Han Solo, Indiana Jones etc
zgoldenlionz  +   1039d ago
I've never seen him kill women or children mainly it's bandits and maniacs bent on ruling the world so I'd have to side with hero for sure.
InTheLab  +   1039d ago
Would be more interested in know whether the ISA from Killzone are considered heroes, or perhaps the CoGs of Gears. Very similar situations there where it's not clear who the dicks are are.
#16 (Edited 1039d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Paris Games Week 2015 Expecting Record Number of Attendees

12m ago - Paris Games Week organiser SELL announced on Tuesday that it is expecting a record-breaking atten... | Industry

Halo 5: Guardians Personifies Microsoft’s ‘Greatest Games Lineup in Xbox History’ -- Hardcore Gamer

17m ago - Hardcore Gamer writes: "When 343 Industries studio head Bonnie Ross opened the beginning of Micro... | Xbox One

Top US Releases in Cinemas This October

Now - October is upon us and, as award season starts to gear into life, a whole slew of top movie releases hit US cinemas; amongst which will see a retur... | Promoted post

Prison Architect Review – Addictive and Memorable | PUG

40m ago - Owen Atkinson writes: "If you ask any kid what they want to be when they grow up, chances are, ma... | PC

Top 10 Resident Evil Characters

42m ago - When it comes to Capcom's best-selling franchise, there's sure to be a lot of characters to praise. | Culture

Net High Gets New Trailer Introducing The Main Characters

1h ago - Marvelous has released a new trailer for its upcoming PS Vita adventure game Net High, introducin... | PS Vita