Submitted by LindsayBelleChambers 1052d ago | opinion piece

The Soul of a Game, and Why Time Magazine’s ALL TIME 100 VIDEO GAMES Perhaps Wasn't the Best Idea

Time Magazine posted their top 100 games of all time, but is it possible to choose the best 100 and get consensus?
Me thinks no. (Culture, Industry)

Alternative Sources
Snookies12  +   1052d ago
Top anything will always be relative to each individual person. That is all.
iamnsuperman  +   1052d ago
Of course not unless you have the list in a revenue way. In theory they are still the 100 greatest video games because they do there job in generating the most amount of money. Having a list purely based on experience is too difficult for games and there are so many different gameplay mechanics that some love and some hate. Comparing genres is often very difficult
#2 (Edited 1052d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
kevnb  +   1052d ago
they have to clearly define what makes them the best games, is it influence? Sales? Longevity? Or just opinion?
Hicken  +   1052d ago
No, they don't. It's not like they're submitting the list as fact. They don't have to pick one criteria to judge all the games by and say "This is why these 100 are the best," because no matter which criteria you judge them by, you'll be leaving out games that are considered better than those you include.

All told, it's no less of a bad idea than all the "Top 10" lists we get around here, and I'll wager Time's list has more thought put into it than 99% of such articles.
The_Nameless_One  +   1052d ago
To me what did the list in was that they included Bioshock but not System Shock 2. Granted SS2 did not have Bioshock's sales numbers but there would not be a Bioshock without System Shock 2.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

New Jake and Tess’ Finding Monsters Adventure Screenshots Revealed

1h ago - VRFocus hosts a selection of new screenshots taken from BlackRiver Studios' forthcoming Jake and... | Android

Review: Castle Crashers Remastered (Microsoft Xbox One) | Digitally Downloaded

1h ago - DD: Castle Crashers Remastered gives us an excuse to take a look back at the original game from... | Xbox One

Check What Wii U and 3DS Titles are Coming Out in October

Now - Nintendo has a handful of interesting titles on offer across Wii U and 3DS systems for the orange-tinged month of October. Here's some hot picks th... | Promoted post

LEGO Dimensions Review | XBA

1h ago - XBA: I flippin' love LEGO. There's nothing more satisfying than clicking together the thousands... | Xbox One

The SideQuest October 02: Albino Lullaby, Skylanders Superchargers, Tony Hawk 5

1h ago - Robyn, Sam, Tom & Dali chat about some great indie games, toys to life experiences, and the downf... | PC

Invaders Inc. Review: Hardcore Droid

1h ago - Digi-Chain Games’ strategy title Invaders Inc. sports a novel spin on the alien invasion game tro... | iPhone