60°
Submitted by ipconflict 1021d ago | opinion piece

When Do Games Become Art

A while ago Roger Ebert commented that video games would never be art and even expanded on his reasoning an article despite never having explored the medium.

But the point still remains, when do video games become art and with a World filled with chopped up cows and hanging light bulbs – are video games already art? (Culture, Flower, Heavy Rain , ICO / Shadow of the Colosuss, Industry, The Unfinished Swan, To the Moon)

rezzah  +   1021d ago
When you start thinking of them as art.
knowyourstuff  +   1021d ago
The creative process is what defines it as art according to how the dictionary defines art. When you start using the creative process to create, it's art. It doesn't make it good art, or fine art, but it's art, in the same way that your kid's finger paintings are art.

Are games fine art is a different question. I don't think you'll be seeing videogames in a museum anytime soon, now matter how good they get.
TenSteps  +   1021d ago
Didn't the smithsonian once had an exhibition on The Art of Videogames a few months back?

Yup just googled it.
http://www.si.edu/Exhibitio...
knowyourstuff  +   1021d ago
Yeah they had an exhibition for 3 months, spanning the entire history of videogames. That's all you're likely to see is one off exhibitions is my point, don't expect Mass Effect to show up in the Louvre as a featured piece for tourists.
M-M  +   1021d ago
When they look like Uncharted. Sorry, but I had to be the guy that mentioned it xD.
#2 (Edited 1021d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
TenSteps  +   1021d ago
To me any medium that is a representation of someone or a groups creative process combined with an attempt to get an audience thinking can be art. Is it good art? Possibly yes possibly no but its art nonetheless.

Games in my opinion is the most likely to feature a sense of art simply because as opposed to most other mediums it has a wider range of areas it tries to cover. The world, the characters, the narrative, even the way the game is played. I'm not saying that games are artful as a standard but more on the fact that even in the situation where a game is aimed more towards earning a profit there will be at least one instance of there being an attempt to stir up thought and make us use our imagination to figure out the meaning within the situation. Take COD:MW2 and the whole "No Russian" mission. I'm not going to debate whether it was done well or not but one thing I'd like to point out was that in that moment you notice your character was now moving slower and can't keep up with the terrorist as they gun down innocents. There was a sense in the design of that mission that gives us a look into this character that was undercover. Though he was meant to be forgettable the scene and the gameplay managed to give that person a deeper sense of character. And when you create character or that deeper meaning in something would you not consider it art? I would and in this situation I found something I would consider as an attempt to something artful in a game that is one of the least likely to contain any sense of art.

Take games like Demon's Souls for example. What it lacks in story it makes up for in the world it is presented in. Likewise the gameplay reflects the basic concept of it. In a dark and unforgiving world it refuses to conform to the status quo of constant checkpoints and similar concepts. Does the gameplay not fit well with the unforgiving notion of the world that it is in? It does.

Long story short. Art from my perspective can be something presented in any form of medium as long as the attempt to create meaning within that product is there. Good art is when it succeeds to those things.
#3 (Edited 1021d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Bimkoblerutso  +   1021d ago
It's all technically "art." Art, by it's technical definition, is just an expression of creativity in a presentable form.

What people REALLY mean when they get into these discussions is what constitutes "inspired" art...and that's a question no one will ever be able to objectively answer.
Sketchy_Galore  +   1021d ago
3.25pm
mastershredder  +   1020d ago
This topic is old and busted. The industry and relevant opinion have already accepted the importance or art in interactive multimedia. Stop beating this old dead horse as though you just had some type of epiphany.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

What It's Like To Play Final Fantasy VI For The First Time

14m ago - Kotaku: Last night I started playing Final Fantasy VI, a video game about suplexing locomotives.... | Retro
30°

Don't Press A to Not Die in Shenmue 2

43m ago - In the latest of his Shenmue 2 adventures, deadpan protagonist Ryo goes to the barber shop for a... | Xbox 360
Ad

Check What PC Games are Coming Out in August

Now - At Releases.com you can check release dates for PC games. Visit now and start tracking the games you plan to buy. | Promoted post
40°

The Rant is Go: Mighty No. 9 (The Ride Never Ends)

45m ago - A lot of us back­ers are feel­ing burned by Mighty No 9 and most peo­ple don’t know why. Here’s t... | PC
30°

Tomb Raiding to the top

52m ago - GE writes: "Don’t tell my wife but I have a bit on the side. She’s very strong minded! Fearless i... | Culture
30°

Intro to Ys

59m ago - GE writes: "Hey, you, the person that likes your JRPGS. Tell me, could you guess the game series... | Culture