Try our new beta! Click here
Submitted by TrueAxiom 1115d ago | opinion piece

Borderlands 2 might be funny, but it's not a comedy

Nightmare Mode writes about Borderlands 2 and how and why it's not really a comedy in the classical sense:

"The more I play Borderlands 2, the more I like it. But the more I think it’s not really a comedy. Borderlands 2 tries to be a comedy, but all it is a funny action movie.

"There are many facets to video games, but boiled down, they’re a series of actions that tell stories. When I say Borderlands 2 isn’t a comedy, I mean exactly that: it is a very capable, if old fashioned, first person shooter with RPG mechanics. It slaps a hundred internet memes, slapstick jokes, and absurd narrative beats onto this to distract you, to convince you it’s a comedy video game. But don’t be fooled: it’s a funny shooter, but no comedy. It’s skinned a funny guy, and it’s wearing him as a suit, but that doesn’t make the product a comedy." (Borderlands 2, PC, PS3, Xbox 360)

digitaleraser  +   1115d ago
By comparing it to The Room and Rifftrax, you're saying Borderlands 2 was unintentionally funny, when it was very clearly intentional (have you ever seen writer Anthony Burch's webshow Hey Ash Watcha Playin?).

I think the problem you're having is that you're laughing at things that are so dark that you feel they shouldn't be as funny as they are? Take a look at the Wikipedia article on "black comedy." That's what Borderlands 2 is, black comedy / dark comedy.
Bimkoblerutso  +   1115d ago
Well, he CLAIMS he likes dark humor (in the form of Tokyo Jungle), though I really don't see the point of this article, to tell the truth. Even if you didn't particularly like the humor in the game, you're not going to get many people categorizing it as something other than a "comedy action" game.

There are obvious jokes and punchlines, the world is darkly cartoonish, and the characters are all wild caricatures. But even if all those elements didn't convince the end of the day, who really gives a flip? It's a piece of entertainment that made people laugh. Why do we need to trudge through the exhausting world of semantics to deconstruct what particular category a game rests in?
wallis  +   1115d ago
"A comedy makes us think: it proposes a ludicrous situation, and it makes us think about it."

Like say a character who's so ridiculously egotistical that he is incapable of recognizing the fact he's the villain? And then have this villain opposed by a bunch of greedy mercenaries in it for the loot? So in a story of liberation and freedom it's not a tale of heroes against selfish corporate greed it's a tale of selfish corporate greed against false heroism.

What part of borderlands 2 is not ridiculous? And even if not then what's wrong with an action game that's funny? Isn't the whole reason borderlands 2's art style is praised is because it's a break from angsty boring stories? I just don't buy the author's definition of a comedy, and even when I do I don't see why borderlands 2 doesn't qualify.
KwietStorm  +   1115d ago
lol this article is such a strongly obvious attempt to be "that" guy in the room and show how insightful he is by reading in between the lines, that he completely misses the whole point and is wrong in the process. THAT is comedy.
Sp1d3ynut  +   1115d ago
I've finished the game twice now, and have restarted with a new character 4 other times, just to get to the part with Tiny Tina. If that's not comedy (yes, maybe dark, given her background story), I don't know what is. The things she says/does...even when she's not talking directly to you...are comedic genius. And Claptrap's B-day party was painfully funny...and sad.
#3 (Edited 1115d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
RXL  +   1115d ago making someone laugh


however...whenever...where ever

iv made my best friend laugh at his grandmothers funeral..

if you start picking apart comedy/jokes and you actually try to make sense of it...

it becomes unfunny...and you're stepping into the realm of philosophy..

it's VERY hard to get Comedy perfect...everyone finds different things funny...

you might laugh at a cat trying to chase it's tail while your friend stares at you in disbelief with a "really?" look on their face..

i commend Borderlands 2 for their most gamers have..

i remember not to long ago i was watching "Young Frankenstein" and cracking up while my gf kept a straight face throughout the movie..

different strokes for different folks..
#4 (Edited 1115d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Sp1d3ynut  +   1115d ago
You always buy the wide-ruled notebooks for school, don't you? -_-
RXL  +   1115d ago
jokes on you...i never went to school!
Sp1d3ynut  +   1115d ago
It certainly shows in your grammar and sentence joke.
Bimkoblerutso  +   1115d ago
Why U mad tho?
RXL  +   1115d ago
English is my second language lol

so excuse me oh great and pretentious one

ill try to bring my A game next time i post on a website about video games just in case a member named "spi1d3ynut" thinks i care about proper grammar and sentence structure on here..

btw..i think you mean more syntax as apposed to grammar..but hey..what do i know.

have a good day nut =)

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Word Party review - ChristCenteredGamer

2h ago - Other than those minor issues, Word Party is a family friendly game that has some educational pot... | Wii U

Désiré - Prologue: Walkthrough Guide

10h ago - Appunwrapper writes: "This is a complete step-by-step walkthrough for the iOS and Android point-a... | iPhone

HotLiked - What the Internet is talking about right now

Now - Kill some time at You will regret it... | Promoted post

Blaze Proves the Commodore Amiga Was Capable of Sonic the Hedgehog

10h ago - Carl Williams writes, "While Sega never supported the Commodore Amiga with any games, they did la... | Retro

Westwood Studios to Receive Industry Icon Award at The Game Awards 2015

10h ago - Host Geoff Keighley just announced that the defunct Westwood Studios will receive the “Industry I... | Retro

Yokai Watch Dance Gets Two New Japanese Commercials

11h ago - Level-5 has released two new commercials showing off the game’s colorful and adorable gameplay. | Wii U