510°
Submitted by DV_Bastian 630d ago | opinion piece

The good and yes, the bad, from today's GTA V reveal

There's a lot to be excited about with today's Grand Theft Auto V info dump, but also a few details that have GamesBeat culture editor Sebastian Haley concerned. (Grand Theft Auto V, PS3, Xbox 360)

Alternative Sources
THR1LLHOUSE  +   630d ago
They had me at "bank heists." That's gonna be awesome.
BitbyDeath  +   630d ago
Agreed, was fun in San Andreas.
iChii  +   629d ago
"Trevor (pictured above, left) is a war veteran/drug addict who lives out in the desert amid meth heads and bikers." Looks like Heisenberg found a new client.. Tuco says hi.
HebrewHammer  +   630d ago
I'm optimistic as well, but with a hint of caution.

This was a great article that sums up my concerns entirely. Like the writer, I though GTAIV was a let down in regards to side-incentives. Liberty City was a remarkable world, but with little to do - and what was available to do had no conclusive value. Some examples from the PS2-era GTA's include completing 100 taxi missions to unlock a pimped out Cabbie. Or doing 100 Firefighter missions to become impervious to fire damage.

I miss things like that.
#1.2 (Edited 630d ago ) | Agree(13) | Disagree(5) | Report | Reply
PinkFunk  +   630d ago
Ah very much agreed. There's no point in creating a "living, breathing world" when it's all aesthetic with no interaction. For example, in GTAIV, not only were there very little dynamic interactions / missions, it was also just impossible to interact with the people of the city besides say running over them with a vehicle.

But from the reveal on gameinformer, it seems like they were addressing that saying the dynamism is a key part of GTA V. Whether it's a set kind of side mission, or just interacting with the AI of city dwelling folk.
irepbtown  +   629d ago
'Oppa Molyneux style' paragraph was unnecessary. I'm sure he made the points about the problems in GTA IV because he saw these problems well after releasing the game. At least he acknowledged the problems and told us that it will be improved for GTA V... isn't that what us gamers want?

Several of the other points I agreed with. And I agree with you, GTA V needs 'crazy' extras like having to do 100 taxi missions (obviously not exactly like that, but similar).

They were the days eyy
TheSaint  +   629d ago
They had me at 'we're releasing GTA V'.....
GuyThatPlaysGames  +   629d ago
Agreed sir!!! This game will ROCK!!!! No doubt about it!!!!
deantak  +   630d ago
very creative approach.
LOGICWINS  +   630d ago
I agree that the lack of a playable female character is a missed opportunity. Maybe this will come in the form of DLC somewhere down the line.
Knight_Crawler  +   630d ago
What is up with you people anticipating DLC?

What happened to the good old days when games came jammed packed with all the contend.
yezz  +   630d ago
I agree BUT I also think it's a bit different with GTA because it's so huge..

DLC is good but it has to be like gta iv TBOGT,TLAD and RDR undead nightmare, they told whole new stories..

DLC has a bad reputation because of for example COD where the DLC is few maps and the prices are ridiculous..
Rumor  +   629d ago
Dude! My point EXACTLY! The anticipation of DLC has been worse even more lately with the oncoming of playstation allstars. I'm hearing people say they can't wait for the dlc characters,

why not just have the content right out the disc..... It baffles me
NukaCola  +   629d ago
I think if they can go the female route, I really want a GTA set in the seventies with Pam Grier voicing the character.
A-Glorious-Dawn  +   629d ago
Rockstar are one of the few developers that make DLC worth buying.
crimsonfox  +   630d ago
Jesus this author is babbling idiot. It's so annoying have cynical writers like this guy try and put off the hype this preview has created. Especially when he try's to low ball Max Payne 3 and GTA IV. After I read that part I knew for sure this guy is a nincompoop.
DV_Bastian  +   630d ago
Being overly cynical is never good, but being blindly optimistic is equally problematic, if not more so.
crimsonfox  +   630d ago
I also feel a little iffy about some of the things announced today but I don't try and shot anything down without trying it out myself. I just don't understand why anyone would want to put off such a clearly hard worked on game by a company who have proven time and time again that they are on the top of the food chain when it comes to being innovative. No one has took more risks and has had more success. Than R* and "authors" like this are the reason I hate reading reviews. Spoiled brats.
Qrphe  +   630d ago
He made legitimate criticisms of those games and thus are legitimate criticisms for the upcoming GTA. It's not like he was trying to troll anyone.
#4.2 (Edited 630d ago ) | Agree(6) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
HebrewHammer  +   630d ago
I happen to agree with a lot of what he says. Is it really so wrong to be cautiously optimistic? There are those - the author and myself included - who felt that while GTAIV was a big step forwards, it took a few smaller steps back here and there too.
#4.3 (Edited 630d ago ) | Agree(9) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
crimsonfox  +   630d ago
Any steps back I feel we're due mostly to the systems they were making the games for we're new to them. And now years later they probably know all the tech inside and out. But I do understand what your saying. And understand why some people disliked GTA IV.
sorry if I come off as an ass but there's just something about the way this guy said it that pissed me off like this
“Diversity” must mean something different to Rockstar
The word “diversity” is thrown around a lot in the GTA V cover story, but looking at the three main characters, I can’t help but feel like we’re just circling familiar territory. There three characters this time around, and not one of them is female? Or Asian? Or Hispanic? "
They had a Hispanic dude in The ballad of gay tony already! They had an Asian guy china town wars too. And honestly for sales GTA will continue to not have a female lead. But this guys wording is something I just can't stand. Either way It's not there race that is ment to be diverse it's the way they are telling the story this time around. And the mechanics they have put in place to do so.
#4.3.1 (Edited 630d ago ) | Agree(2) | Disagree(5) | Report
Kinger8938  +   629d ago
I agree, gta iv was very dull interms of things to do etc compared to previous games
linkratos  +   629d ago
I actually prefer it when the media don't act like fanboys. It's not their job to hype something up. People who loved GTA4 will love GTA5 regardless. These concerns are for people who were annoyed by some of the flaws in 4.
3-4-5  +   629d ago
Map is Bigger/ Larger than Red Dead, San Andreas & GTA 4 combined...

^ GOTY 2013.

A Full Golf Course ! Battle Golf !
DreamTension  +   629d ago
Hell yeah! Get a bogey = headshot
WeskerChildReborned  +   629d ago
I love everything that was announced pretty much.
frankiebeans  +   629d ago
2 to 3 disk on 360 is pretty much confirmed from all the info about how big the game is...guess its time to dust off the ps3 for this one.
Cam977  +   629d ago
Stupid article, the writer complains like a child.
Pillsbury1  +   629d ago
People are gonna stfu about the 3 protagonists once they play this piece of art.

One of my favorite memories from GTA is driving around the city to find random things happening I.e. cops chasing people, sounds like they are bringing back the random and by chance discoveries from earlier GTAs
#9 (Edited 629d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
SephirothX21  +   629d ago
Female characters in a gangster role are just not as believable as male characters. That's not being sexist. Its just being realistic. Most criminals happen to be men, certainly the ones doing bank heists. Also, the three characters will interact with each other all throughout the story, a proper man's conversation wouldn't be possible between them with a woman constantly around. Maybe what I'm saying is ridiculous but I think Dan Houser is long enough at this to know what he's doing. Remember, he's behind all GTAs since 3 (inclusive) and Red Dead Redemption.
claud3  +   629d ago
Still waiting to ay it, before I pass judgement
-Gespenst-  +   629d ago
Wait a minute they called the black guy "Franklin"?

Facepalm.
TuxedoMoon  +   629d ago
I didn't like GTA4 all too much, but I'm still willing to give this game a shot.
KrimsonKody  +   629d ago
"GTAV world to be larger than RDR, San Andreas & GTAIV combined"?
That's pretty large, to say the least!

But yeah, in reference to R* using LA so much;
Could it be that they are recycling or "re-using" mapping locations for their games?
Not to say they're doing anything wrong, but I believe that you have to request permission & get landscape licences (or whatever) in order to replicate cities & such in games...
Maybe they paid a nice chunk for rights to LA, & are still in the right to use it if or as they like?

But I agree, R* should just make an LA collection available soon.

Also, although GTAIV was one of my least favorites in the series, I'm still looking forward to V.
R* hasn't quite gone the "Capcom & Square" route with the quality of their franchises.
& I say "franchises" because Capcom & Square both had some great games released this gen, but their namesake games is what went downhill.
#14 (Edited 629d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

Naruto Storm Revolution: 50+ Minutes of Footage

35m ago - Ninja Escapades, the Ninja World Tournament Mode, and free battle. | PC
30°

Gravia Tactics is a New Tactical RPG On The Scene

1h ago - Julie Morley writes: "All the combat follows a grid and is turn-based in Gravia Tactics. The enti... | PC
40°

All For One - CLG Swaps Entire LoL Roster When Top Lane Is Forced Back To Korea

1h ago - Counter Logic Gaming, a fan-favorite professional League of Legends team, sends all 5 starters ba... | Industry
40°

From Uncharted to The Last of Us: An Hour with Emilia Schatz, Part II

1h ago - Max Level: With all the hype surrounding the critically-acclaimed game, I recently sat down with... | PS3
Ad

Start Making Games for the PS4

Now - Want to design the next generation of video games? Start learning game design today. Click for more info on how to get started. | Promoted post
40°

Killer Instinct: Combo Breaker Pack Will Fight Its Way into a Physical Release on September 23rd

1h ago - Microsoft has announced the physical copy of Killer Instinct: Combo Breaker Pack is releasing a s... | Xbox One
Related content from friends