80°
Submitted by -Mezzo- 1000d ago | opinion piece

10 games that prove originality is overrated

GamesRadar - All this talk of "knock-offs" and "clones"? It's unnecessary. Iterating off of other people's ideas is part of the creative process; these ten games offer ample proof that imitation isn't necessarily a bad thing. (Culture)

Jinkies  +   1000d ago
"Uncharted

Inspired by: Tomb Raider"

<sigh>

Uncharted WAS NOT inspired by Tomb Raider, it was inspired by Indianna Jones and other action/adventure films because a cinematic approach is what ND wanted in Drakes Fortune.

The only thing they have in common is that they are both treasure hunters and have platform elements in their games, does every platforming game after TR mean it's a rip off. I never once saw Lara roll behind cover fiering at wave after wave of enemies then go into a fantastic story driven cutscene.

Tomb Raider was a Platforming/puzzle game with third person elements

Uncharted is a cinematic third person shooter with puzzle elements.

Totaly differnt...seriously why do people hang onto this
#1 (Edited 1000d ago ) | Agree(13) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
Ben_Grimm  +   1000d ago
To be honest the later Tomb Raider games did have a lot more action than puzzles and they were cinematic. I mean no where close to Uncharted levels but I think that has more to do with direction and production.

And didn't Underworld have like a Max Payne type of bullet time in it? There was a ton of shooter gun play in those late installments.

I don't think Uncharted is a clone or inspired but they are not totally different.
ShaunCameron  +   1000d ago
@ jimbobwahey

Kill.Switch was a multiplatform game. But you're right though.
ShaunCameron  +   1000d ago
Actually Tomb Raider was an action-adventure game with platforming and puzzle elements.

<I never once saw Lara roll behind cover fiering at wave after wave of enemies then go into a fantastic story driven cutscene.>

That's because Uncharted borrowed that from Gears Of War.

<Uncharted is a cinematic third person shooter with puzzle elements.>

Correction: Uncharted is Gears Of War minus the AI co-op with puzzle elements.
jimbobwahey  +   1000d ago
Well, technically the cover system in Gears of War was copied from an old PS2 game so...
SCW1982  +   1000d ago
I love how people say uncharted borrowed from gears when they were both in development around the same time. Sad how some people think.
Jinkies  +   1000d ago
Gears was never shown off when Uncharted was in development and they were in development roughly the same time. I don't think no one copied...it was just two games which shared a similar cover system and Gears was out first since it took ND longer wth the motion capturing. Bad luck at the end of the day
BitbyDeath  +   1000d ago
Eight Days was the first to show that sort of gameplay this gen so who copied who?
SCW1982  +   1000d ago
Thank you for that intelligent response.
Relientk77  +   1000d ago
Why did they chose LittleBigPlanet Karting, they should have chosen Crash Team Racing (CTR) for PS1, amazing game, definitely inspired by Mario Kart

The Torchlight and Diablo one is obvious

Glad they mentioned Kill.Switch for Gears of War

Kill.Switch has to be one of favorite most underrated games ever, it was one of my favorite shooter games last generation. Also one of the first to use a cover system
#3 (Edited 1000d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Outside_ofthe_Box  +   1000d ago
***"Why did they chose LittleBigPlanet Karting, they should have chosen Crash Team Racing (CTR) for PS1, amazing game, definitely inspired by Mario Kart"***

Because both have "kart" in the title. It's as simple as that. If that isn't case then why aren't they calling Mod Nation Racers a Mario Kart copycat/inspired game seeing as that is what LBK plays most similar to? I'll answer that for you, it's because it doesn't have "kart" in the title.
#3.1 (Edited 1000d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

Elite: Dangerous’ competitive mode has a trailer

41m ago - We couldn’t blame you for missing it in the melee that was the Microsoft briefing at gamescom 201... | PC
40°

EA celebrates Gamescom with big discounts on Origin

41m ago - "Gamescom is officially underway in Cologne, Germany, and as gamers and developers from all over... | Industry
Ad

'Warhammer: Arcane Magic' - a Digital Boardgame for iOS

Now - Arcane Magic is a turn based strategy game set in the Warhammer universe. Play it now on Ipad and Iphone. | Promoted post
40°

Short Pause Podcast #36: What The Hell Is Going On With Mighty No. 9? PS4 Breaks 25M Units Sold

49m ago - Short Pause: "This weeks topics include: - New Destiny Location Revealed - Frankie and Bender... | Xbox 360
40°

Massive Neverwinter Update for Xbox One Brings Four Different Expansions

1h ago - Who needs one measly expansion when you can have four? Perfect World and Cryptic are dropping fou... | Xbox One
30°

Velocibox Review (PS Vita)- punkandlizard

1h ago - Northlander writes for P&L:"So be warned, if you’re twelve and have the reactions of a viper, gam... | PS Vita