230°
Submitted by Lavalamp 620d ago | review

Medal of Honor: Warfighter Review | EDGE

EDGE: "While another six months in development wouldn’t have removed the lingering bad taste from one of the more tasteless marketing campaigns in recent memory – including tie-ins with the real-world manufacturers who make the in-game ordnance, and a branded tomahawk that was later removed from sale – it would have done much to help smooth out the kinks in a game where at least the multiplayer has genuine potential. Instead, what’s shipped is rushed, uninspired and cynical." (Medal of Honor: Warfighter, PC, PS3, Xbox 360) 3/10

MakiManPR  +   620d ago
Ouch!
Too bad LP were involved in this game.
JellyJelly  +   620d ago
Why? They suck even more than the game so I think they make a perfect match.
LOGICWINS  +   620d ago
LOL, I doubt its THAT bad.
HammadTheBeast  +   620d ago
It isn't. I wouldn't call it great, but it's no this bad. Edge just goes overboard with the bandwagon and their scores make them feel special.
WilliamH  +   620d ago
Edge do tend to go a little crazy with their scores sometimes, that;s what gives them their edge /s
TheDopeFiend  +   620d ago
It really isn't that bad of a game, it's just more of the same really, that shouldn't lower the overall score by that much, I would give it a 5 or a 6 at least.

The problem it has is it brings absolutely nothing new

Hopefully they'll go back to making WWW1/2 games after this
#3.1 (Edited 620d ago ) | Agree(10) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
Emilio_Estevez  +   620d ago
I would truly love for them to back to WW1/2, I would buy it in a heartbeat. Frostbite 2 with destruction and all those classic guns!
IIC0mPLeXII  +   620d ago
This game got blasted. Looks like another game joins the ranks of Ninja Gaiden 3 And Op Raccoon City
venom06  +   620d ago
please read this regarding this reviewer!! http://pcgmedia.com/what-ar...
Trunkz Jr  +   620d ago
It's true, the Buddy system is awesome. I usually stick to Teamplay games like Battlefield but this game actually has Teamwork, wtf why hasn't CoD managed to add something unique like this? Not that I would jump to CoD because of that but CoD is on its 5th title I think since CoD4 and they never managed to come up with such a neat idea, they just repackage the same old crap and sell it.
#5.1 (Edited 620d ago ) | Agree(10) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
dontbhatin  +   620d ago
Somebody needs to post this on N4G
Th3 Chr0nic  +   620d ago
WOW finally someone that understands!!!!. this needs to be plastered everywhere.

he hits it on the head so hard that it explodes in a gory gibfest of awesome writing!!!
InTheLab  +   620d ago
"Medal of Honor’s Battlefield 3 style sound and shooting mechanics are much more satisfying, and ooze authenticity much more so than Call of Duty."

"Second to that, the much newer Frostbite 2 engine and full DirectX 11 support offers fantastic, immersive visuals that actually do take the first person shooter to a new technical level of brilliance. So, we’ve got both game-play shooting mechanical improvements, and 100% technically correct and objective technical improvements. Tell me again how Medal of Honor doesn’t do things as well as the competition? What are these writers smoking?"

A PC guy who's also a Battlefield fanboy that hates CoD and thinks MoH is just as good as Battlefield...

And 9 people agreed with this link?

How do you call out bias and DO THE EXACT SAME THING?

I agree that some of these low scores might be sour grapes but if you actually read...really dig into these reviews, you'll see that it's more than that. A lot of critics site technical issues like disappearing enemies, poor A.I., 1 slo motion breach too many...etc.

It's not all, "well, it's not like CoD so it's s***" like the author claims.
#5.4 (Edited 620d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
Periphereality  +   620d ago
I actually dislike Battlefield 3.
Reviewing the game without taking Call of Duty into consideration is stupid, considering everyone reading the review will be doing it.
Medal of Honor does have better sound and visuals than Call of Duty - a point about innovation.
I didn't find the AI to be poor, at least not with regards to the competition.

I find this trend of people assuming what games I enjoy quite interesting. I've clocked 300 hours plus in Arma II, and Red Orchestra 2 is my current favourite first person shooter. I don't play Battlefield 3, and have played more Call of Duty MW and MW2 than Battlefield 3.

Your preconceptions are interesting, but your extrapolations are worrying off point. Thanks for reading, though.
Periphereality  +   620d ago
I don't have enough "bubbles" so I'll reply on this thread.

I wasn't quote mining, they're the summary quotes found on Metacritic. You say that I "chose lines that seemingly support your argument." Nope. They're the actual lines taken from the summaries. The fact that they "support my argument", being blatantly right there, in your face, actually further supports my argument.

"that's what I can't understand." (why I rate a "mediocre" game as "good")

Because I found that whilst the campaign was visually fantastic, it was mediocre - but the multiplayer was fantastic, which made the game 'good'. Not great, but good.

And guess what? I enjoyed the slow motion breaches. Why? Because I enjoy head-shots. Am I wrong to enjoy them? Not really.

In my review I stated they sold themselves short for trying to appeal to the Call of Duty fans "rather than nurturing their 2010 child", but that alone didn't make it a bad game. Certainly not one worthy of 40, or by Edge's standard, 3/10.
Yomaster  +   620d ago
Thank you, venom06.
sdozzo  +   620d ago
A 3... Cmon now.
Young_ART  +   620d ago
so based on their logic, MOH2 < "Haze".
Lou Ferrigno  +   620d ago
whoa now,i actually liked haze,i know i know .. :(- lol
InTheLab  +   620d ago
At least Haze was original...
josephayal  +   620d ago
3/10 and still better than COD
Th3 Chr0nic  +   620d ago
crap review like most of the others. the game is WAY WAY WAY BETTER than the reviews are leading on!!!!!! the fireteam /buddy system is great.
VOIP is in the game which was a huge complaint on BF3.
Battlelog is integrated into the game or can be browser bases, again was ahuge issue with BF3 for some people.

They basically gave us what everyone complained about in BF3 and people still are complaining!! i dont understand it.
its just fishy to me
Cam977  +   620d ago
It's EDGE people. They always give harsh scores to good games.
shivvy24  +   620d ago
so if it doesnt play like cod they bash it !
CPTN MITCHELL  +   620d ago
It hurts so bad that I'm going back to cod......¦-(
ALLWRONG  +   620d ago
Horrible game deserves a horrible score, and 98% of everybody agrees.
andron666  +   620d ago
Well I'm in no hurry to get this game. Last one was a decent rental for the SP, and the MP was ok for a while.

But everything I see from this one looks worse:

http://www.youtube.com/watc...

http://www.youtube.com/watc...

My favourite is this one though. He's crying about people crying about Warfighter, but somehow he's not convincing me otherwise:

http://www.youtube.com/watc...

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

Is Something Strange Brewing At Microsoft?

8m ago - CCC Says: "While news of the Xbox One’s demise has been greatly exaggerated…is its future truly s... | Xbox One
40°

Avegant Glyph: A Different Kind of HMD

10m ago - The Oculus Rift. Project Morpheus. GameFace. Altergaze. Dive. These are just some of the many hea... | PC
10°

Deadfall Adventures: Heart of Atlantis Screenshots

10m ago - New screenshots from the Farm 51 game, Deadfall Adventures: Heart of Atlantis. | PC
10°

Otaku Dome: Blue Estate Review

10m ago - Otaku Dome: The Blue Estate comic by Viktor Kalvachev has gotten it's own video game for Plays... | PS4
Ad

Filmwatch June Contests

Now - Join us as we give away a ton of cash this month! | Promoted post
10°

The Hum: Psychological Horror with Actual Psychology

11m ago - An exclusive interview with Ariel Arias, developer of the new horror game The Hum, about the psyc... | PC
Related content from friends