Submitted by Joannes 745d ago | news

Pachter: “BioWare without the doctors is like a Godfather movie without Coppola”

Industry analyst Michael Pachter believes the departure of founders Ray Muzyka and Greg Zeschuk will have a profound effect on the quality of BioWare’s output, saying “you’re not getting anything like those games again.” (BioWare, EA, Greg Zeschuk, Mass Effect 3, PC, PS3, Ray Muzyka, Xbox 360)

NYC_Gamer  +   745d ago
The studio lost its identity along time ago while the doctors were in charge
shammgod  +   745d ago
Agreed. It was EAs meddling that caused the downfall
NYC_Gamer  +   745d ago
EA is known for ruining studios and franchises
doogiebear  +   745d ago
And likely caused them to want to leave
GrahamGolden  +   745d ago
the docs maybe was there but they were still EA bitches so nope they didnt lost identity before EA but after EA.
Bercilak  +   745d ago
Thank you!

Of course, people will point to sales figures in support of their contention that more recent games sold better but quantity doesn't equate to quality. Britney Spears sold a lot of albums, too.
Jason_Tanner  +   745d ago
Well really at the end of the day that statement is just a reflection on how brainless the consumer masses are as a whole.
greenpowerz  +   745d ago
They were fine until PS3 was equally thrown in the mix after EA. Hell Even ME3 Box art was geared to PS3 fans.

Look at how Japanese this looks. http://garybaileywriting.fi... When you see Shepard in ads when this energy blade is turned on it ejects like a mineral based blade and makes a cling/sling noise.
#3 (Edited 745d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(18) | Report | Reply
Carl_Shocker  +   745d ago
"Hell Even ME3 Box art was geared to PS3 fans."

...I don't even......whaaaa

The Box art was fine, better then having a horrible purple line at the top "Better with Kinect".
lodossrage  +   745d ago
I know people like the throw ridiculous, fanboyish notions out there on this site, but somehow blaming the PS3 for the fall of Bioware is just.....well...anyone with common sense can fill in the rest for me lol. I'll just say only a fanboy would believe/agree with that dribble greenpowerz lol

Anyway, truth be told, Even though it's true EA has a habit of messing up developer units they buy, Bioware's games were slowly on the decline anyway.

Case in point, remember KOTOR? Remember how hardcore orientated it was?

Then their next game, Jade Empire, while it was still hardcore, Bioware made it more accessible to the mainstream (compared to KOTOR).

Then came Mass Effect, which was while still hardcore, it was made even more mass audience friendly than KOTOR or Jade Empire. And the rest of the games, you all know the story.

Point is yes, EA made them that much worse off true, but they were slowly going down the path of decline anyway. EA just made it come that much faster.
#3.2 (Edited 745d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
GrahamGolden  +   745d ago
hate more master zero....hey guess what ME1 coming to ps3 u mad brah?

best version confirmed also..another exclusive lost for ya..but oO wait it was also on pc's u mad ?

wait for your halo 1482937927384 and shut it kkthxbb
majiebeast  +   745d ago
I think my brain just went dead for a second when i read that. WHAT!!!
#3.4 (Edited 745d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
ChunkyLover53  +   745d ago
People leave developers, that doesn't mean the games and franchises wont be fine. When Bungie left people thought Halo would suck, but 343i looks to be putting their own touch on Halo and Master Chief and it looks like the best one ever.

Remedy sold off Max Payne and Rockstar did a great job with MP3.

A different company made Little Big Planet for the Vita and people are saying that is the definitive version.

Peter M left Lionhead and I expect that to be a positive for the Fable series. Cliff B left Epic and I expect Gears and those games to be fine.

People leave companies all the time, there are a million quality developers ready to step up.
Chuk5  +   745d ago
The difference with halo, is that bungie didn't have their hearts in it anymore. You could even see with reach that was the case. that's the case where new blood was needed. I see the doctors leaving much like Mikami leaving capcom
ChunkyLover53  +   745d ago
I have to disagree, I thought Halo Reach was the best Halo to date, certainly the single player, which was heartfelt and amazing. I thought they took too many risks with the multiplayer, but it was still a solid effort.

343i is strictly a Halo developer, that is why so many talented developers joined them in the first place. If you look at some of the people who are on that team, they are an all star dev team.

Even there name is a Halo reference, I wouldn't expect them to do anything but quality Halo games.
#4.1.1 (Edited 745d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(7) | Report
MikeMyers  +   745d ago
EA has a history of running franchises into the ground by buying out the developers and changing their identity. Just look at what has happened to Command & Conquer for example. Bioware will never be like the old Bioware because EA restructured them with Mythic Entertainment. Ray Muzyka and Greg Zeschuk were the last two remaining co-founders at Bioware.

This whole thing reminds me of what has happened to Rare and when Microsoft bought them. The main people left and only the name has carried on trying to retain the glory days. Same thing is happening now with Bioware, the heart and soul of the company is now gone.

343i still has Frank O' Connor (formerly from Bungie) at the helm and he's in charge of continuing the Halo franchise. How the company moves forward on other future franchises is the question and that is only if Microsoft allows the team to do anything besides Halo. On the flip-side, Bioware has created a lot of ip's and were not a one-hit wonder. Now will the development team be able to create new and refreshing franchises while working at EA?
#4.2 (Edited 745d ago ) | Agree(5) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
zerocrossing  +   745d ago
Itagaki left Team Ninja and now look at Ninja gaiden, number 3 was awful

Shinji Mikami left Capcom and look at the state of RE 5 and 6 they almost represent nothing of their origins.

Toyama left Konami and Silent hill hasn't been very good or scary since.

These are prime examples of creators leaving a company and their games declining because of it.
Also I'm not trying to correct you just showing the argument has weight on both sides.
munish23  +   745d ago
343i will only make Halo games, hence the name 343i.
MikeMyers  +   745d ago
ChunkyLover53, then perhaps 343i isn't the best example of new people carrying on the torch since all they will be doing is Halo. Bioware is known for many franchises, not just Mass Effect. I do hope Bungie well in the future as they probably wanted to move forward and do something else besides Halo.

I think when Bioware was bought by EA it was downhill from there and now nobody is left from the old team. I also expect some people from 343i to jump ship in the future once they have experience under their belts. Not too many people only want to work on just one franchise forever.
Jason_Tanner  +   745d ago
The name of a developer means nothing without a talented group of people behind it.
zerocrossing  +   745d ago
miss post
#4.3 (Edited 745d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
Belking  +   745d ago
I knew once EA stepped in it wouldn't be long before those guys took off. No studio wants want to be owned and those that are owned and say otherwise is total BS. All my opinion of course.
Knight_Crawler  +   745d ago
I hate MS for not buying Bioware when they had the opportunity.

Blah blah blah...Rare was already dead when Nintendo sold them to MS so do not give me that BS about MS killed Rare.
Belking  +   745d ago
"Blah blah blah...Rare was already dead when Nintendo sold them to MS so do not give me that BS about MS killed Rare."

I know Rare wasn't the same when MS bought them. As a matter of fact, MS actually brought them back to profitability. In this case there was no need for EA to step in with that deal because Bioware was doing well with their publishing deals. They really didn't benefit from the EA take over. When they had to defend their ending to ME3 I knew a change was gonna come. These guys will start another studio and won't that mistake again.
MasterD919  +   745d ago
Well, it will be a fresh start for the series next installment, that is for sure...but I disagree. Maybe ME needs some new minds at work.

They also said the same thing about Bungie not being involved in Halo 4 though, and Halo 4 looks phenomenal.

Oh yeah, and figures this quote is from Pachter.
#6 (Edited 745d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
New stories

Another Massive Atlus Sale Hits PSN

43m ago - Hey Poor Player's Frank DiPersio writes- Are you without a 3DS and wishing you could get in on... | PSP

Armored Warfare Shows Off New Map

59m ago - Obsidian Entertainment and My.com release information a new map for Armored Warfare. The new map... | PC

Forward to the Sky is Now on Greenlight with New Trailer

1h ago - Hardcore Gamer: A Steam Greenlight campaign has been launched for Forward to the Sky | PC

Hands on Impressions of the Omega Ruby/ Alpha Sapphire Demo

1h ago - MONG writes: "Being a Pokémon fan, I was certainly excited to hear that demo versions of Pokémon... | 3DS


Now - Quickly locate just the right card for you. | Promoted post

Joylancer brings chaotic Game Boy style to Early Access

1h ago - 2D action platformer made in Game Boy visual style coming to Steam Early Access in November. | PC