The strangest thing happened this week. My friend, who gets scared by the simplest thing, played about four hours of Amnesia, said she was bored, and stopped playing. I don't understand it. I never get scared by anything...except certain video games. She walked through it like a Mario game!
Amnesia
Penumbra
Fatal Frame I-III
Silent Hill 2
That's it. I play TONS of survival horror games.
Also, Siren 1/2 were awesome! I think Blood Curse is the scariest though.
If only I didn't have a vivid imagination while I am alone.. after playing these games.
Shadowman and Eternal Darkness were scary in a very twisted and unique way.