80°
Submitted by mrprice33 746d ago | opinion piece

Hate Gaming Journalism? Here's How You Can Fix It

VGRevolution's Gaming Editor Marc explores the causes behind problems in the gaming press, and what the audience can do to fix them. (Gamespot, IGN, Industry, Joystiq, Tag Invalid)

MultiConsoleGamer  +   746d ago
I avoid "trolling for hits" articles and obvious sensationalism. I also avoid place like NeoGAF, which are full of agenda ridden fanboys who selectively quite articles and cannibalize web site content.

Some people will criticize n4g for whatever reasons they might have. However this ste does a tremendous service for both the gamer and the gaming journalist.
Dante112  +   746d ago
Yeah, it's gotten really bad at neogaf. There's so many misquoted and lame "why you shouldn't buy so and so game/comsole" threads there. Even the official game threads are extremely negative (For all console exclusives). You can barely get any good thread discussions in.
#1.1 (Edited 746d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
Gaetano  +   746d ago
Amen. I admit that in the past I've even written many a "hit" piece, but at the request of ownership and advertises that expect positive content, or controversial content that is so, so stupid.

I hope there is a little sympathy for games journalists. They often have their hands tied and are forced to write certain things. Not everyone has the capacity to say "no" and lose their job. That's the sad reality.

I'm in the process of starting an outlet that is influenced minimally by publishers, and doesn't rely on reviews and previews for coverage. The reality is that reviews, previews are too open to publisher exploitation, and the reader can never truly trust an outlet that is running an ad for a game they're also critiquing.
#1.2 (Edited 746d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
mrprice33  +   746d ago
One thing I just couldn't work into the article is that the complaint of reviewers receiving free games before the public is also something that is the public's doing. At our site we sometimes have to purchase games that we review, but we know that every day we wait before publishing, our potential traffic plummets.

One way to combat that is to write reviews in such a way that they are worthwhile even if they're late, but the internet is much more about first than best.

Plus, as a consumer, I want to know if a game is any good before I purchase it. Reviewers have to get games early so that reviews can be ready on launch day.
JasonKCK  +   746d ago
I agree that N4G is a good place to get the latest news, but this site is slanted.
LOGICWINS  +   746d ago
N4G has a slanted community without a shadow of a doubt. But as far as getting the latest gaming news is concerned, I've yet to find a better site.
3-4-5  +   746d ago
That is why I come to this and maybe 1 or 2 other sites. There is much less immature comments on this site then most, and as a whole it offers good articles/content/information.

If their Boss's/editors let them publish/write this crap, then it is the superior's fault as well...even more so really because they are supposed to have credibility/ morals/ standards and if they let this crap out there, then that isn't saying that much for themselves as an editor/boss/leader.
Blankman85  +   746d ago
Stop falling for flamebait articles! When we respond to them and give them hits and heat, we are telling them they can cash in on tabloid style journalism.
Grimhammer00  +   746d ago
Biggest problem is indeed us & the sites that pander to our hunger for anything new.

Here's a thought.....why don't game devs create sites that truly engage us to go straight to the source? Rather than journalists with agendas and sites catering to revenue advertisers.

Unfortunately many game sites are run by the publisher. Asking for our personals just so we can get info in drips or get past the sites walls.
mrprice33  +   746d ago
Honestly I would say the biggest problem with that is that devs simply don't have the time or perhaps the skillset to communicate in the way a good journalist or writer should.

Also, I can't imagine corporate PR would ever let them say anything that wasn't completely gushing and positive.
123456777  +   746d ago
I put part of the blame on the approval system here on N4G (bye bye, everyone).
A lot of nonsense and obvious troll articles get submitted here, and get approved fairly fast.
Vita and Wii U seem to be the trolls' favourite targets as of late.
"Can **** Save The Vita?"
"5 Reasons Why The Vita Is DOOMED"
"5 Reasons Why The Wii U Will Fail"
"Wii U Is Weaker Than The PS3/360"
And then there's the other types of articles.
"5/10 Top Babes In Games"
"5/10 Villains In Games"
"5/10 Best Females In Games"
"5/10 Reasons Why The PS3 is Better Than The 360"
"5/10 Reasons Why The 360 Is Better Than The PS3"
"DOOMED"
"DEAD"
"DOOMED"
"DEAD"
"DOOMED"
"DOOMED"
"DEAD"
"DOOMED"
"DEAD"
I can't tell if they are Journalists or Necrophiliac Goths.
Lay off the junk, hate and doom articles and give us some originality, ffs.
#4 (Edited 746d ago ) | Agree(9) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
LOGICWINS  +   746d ago
Maybe the solution is to have stiffer consequences for approving junk articles. Bubble loss, temporary bans etc.
SageHonor  +   746d ago
People respond more to negativity. Its a shame
0pie  +   746d ago
i think someone saw this thread http://www.neogaf.com/forum... on neogaf and decided to do an article about the same subject.
#5 (Edited 746d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report | Reply
mrprice33  +   746d ago
I link to that thread in the first sentence in the column.
jeeves86  +   746d ago
Garbage journalism is hardly unique to the gaming industry. Until *that* changes, I wouldn't expect gaming journalism to change.
Derpy  +   745d ago
I couldn't even read the article, as some annoying Facebook tab kept comming up over the text on the left side f the screen. After wasting a few minutes trying to get rid of it and failing to do so, I just gave up and closed the web page, wishing I'd never wasted clicking on it.
#7 (Edited 745d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

PS4's Until Dawn Scared Me Out of My Headphones - TGS Hands-On, Headset-Off Preview | GR

9m ago - "When the big moment came, I had become invested in the characters' search for truth in this horr... | PS4
30°

Noct quietly passes funding goal

16m ago - Stylised shooter Noct slyly crept past its Kickstarter funding goal this week. The project has ra... | PC
30°

FIFA 15 New Skill Moves Tutorial

24m ago - FIFPlay: Eden Hazard is here to teach you the new skills in FIFA 15. | PC
40°

Hyrule Warriors Review - GameRevolution

27m ago - GR: Link, Zelda, Impa, and more Hyrule heroes hit the battlefield in this Dynasty Warriors spin-o... | Wii U
Ad

Celebrate the new TV season with Filmwatch

Now - With the 2014-2015 TV season right around the corner, come join us on Filmwatch as we celebrate and give all you TV lovers something to enjoy! | Promoted post
40°

FIFA 15 Stadiums - The Complete List

32m ago - FIFPlay: The complete list of stadiums in FIFA 15 revealed. | PC