Quantcast
570°
Submitted by Pozzle 281d ago | opinion piece

The Five Most Disappointing Video Games of This Generation

UM writes: I recently wrote a post about the most disappointing summer blockbusters, movies we thought were going to be fantastic but ended up letting us down. I thought I’d try something similar with video games, as this has happened plenty particularly in the last console generation.

Some of these are slam dunks, a few might cause a bit more controversy like how I can’t STAND Halo: Reach. Yeah, I said it.

Check out the list below, and check back for another iteration in fifty years after we’ve all been disappointed by Half-Life 3. (Duke Nukem Forever, Fable 3, Halo: Reach, PS3, Xbox 360)

« 1 2 »
Futureproof   281d ago | Spam
-MD-  +   281d ago
Diablo 3 definitely tops the list. Never seen a game receive so much hype and then come to a screeching halt less than 2 weeks after release.

Blizzard really hurt their reputation this year.
#2 (Edited 281d ago ) | Agree(27) | Disagree(8) | Report | Reply
da_2pacalypse  +   281d ago
Agreed. I'd also argue ME3 should be on that list, seeing as how the quality difference between the first two games and the third is so big.
moeqawama  +   281d ago
Quality? The game was amazing, it was the ending that put a blemish on it... The game was great
strauser360  +   281d ago
Get over it already.
rpd123  +   280d ago
ME3 was an awesome game and leagues ahead of ME1 in terms of gameplay. The story may not have been as good, but it's an awesome game nonetheless.
dasbeer88  +   281d ago
Don't forget Starcraft 2.
Panthers  +   281d ago
Starcraft 2 is amazing. I dont really see the comparison between that and Diablo 3. Im a little worried about HoTS but I believe it will shape up nicely.
dedicatedtogamers  +   281d ago
I really liked (and still like, since I'm still playing it) Diablo 3. Admittedly, launch was a huge drag with all of the "server down" problems. Nowadays the game runs like a champ.
schlanz  +   280d ago
I would mostly agree however Blizzard improved Diablo 2 enormously over time and they will do the same with D3. The next patch appears to address many of the stupid things that caused my disenchantment with the game, I'm very much looking forward to it.
Psychotica  +   281d ago
GTA 4 was one of the best this generation..
roadkillers  +   281d ago
The story telling was great. I thought it was up in the ranks of crime movies like Goodfellas.
ape007  +   280d ago
I agree GTA 4 is totally freaking awesome
Eyeco  +   280d ago
To compare GTA 4's story to one of the greatest movies of all time is completely ludicrous , it may have been good interpretation of classic crime movies but as good, seriously ....?

I've said this before and I'll say it again GTA 4 is the most overrated game this gen perhaps of all time
#3.1.3 (Edited 280d ago ) | Agree(9) | Disagree(3) | Report
RufustheKing  +   281d ago
GTA was a huge let down, in fact all of rock stars games this gen were not great(except max pain 3 didn't play it)

The last assinsins creed was not that great either.
"GTA was a huge let down, in fact all of rock stars games this gen were not great"

Really???? Red Dead? L.A Noire????? *facepal.... *faceboot*

Say what you will but GTA4, RDR and L.A Noire had some interesting characters and some damn good story telling. + the physics engines and the revamped shooting mechanics & cover system did wonders for gameplay. Lets not forget top notch acting. Not sure what you didn't liked it, is there a possibility you overhyped it?
#3.2.1 (Edited 281d ago ) | Agree(18) | Disagree(6) | Report
SnakePayne  +   281d ago
lol..rockstar is the best developer.
DasTier  +   281d ago
GTA IV, Max Payne and LA Noire let me down, But RDR is my favourite game of this gen and Bully from right at the start was very good too.
ToZanarkand86  +   280d ago
Shame on you! Red Dead was immense!
RufustheKing  +   280d ago
@xXBlondieVanHarlowXx
"Say what you will but GTA4, RDR and L.A Noire had some interesting characters and some damn good story telling. + the physics engines and the revamped shooting mechanics & cover system did wonders for gameplay. Lets not forget top notch acting. Not sure what you didn't liked it, is there a possibility you overhyped it?"

I don't care about the updated graphics or new revamped shooting. if the game is not good it's not good. MP is ok for awhile but it boring after a few days. Also it was a GTA game with GTA:VC and GTA:SA coming before it, i expected much better.

For RDR the sp was good for about 22hours but haven't play it since i finished it 2years ago. The MP for RDR was better than GTA MP but was boring after about a week of play.

GUN for PS2 was a far better cowboy game than RDR.
#3.2.5 (Edited 280d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(1) | Report
SnakePayne  +   281d ago
GTA IV was the best one not san andreas.
DasTier  +   281d ago
Im afraid the best games was neither of those. It was infact Vice City.
#3.3.1 (Edited 281d ago ) | Agree(10) | Disagree(9) | Report
SnakePayne  +   281d ago
@ujean69
in my opinion best gta was IV becouse the story and gameplay and characters and missions are superb.
Vice City was great and it was The best one yet IV
San Andreas was graet in exploring becouse the map was huge & the terrain and environment was variety but in other things the game was normal.
ape007  +   280d ago
vice city is the best imo but all of the gta's are legendary and some of my fav games ever, i still get impressed by GTA IV till this day, the depth and the amount of quality\care is second to non, it's the number 1 open world this gen, nothing come close, the only game that make gta 4 look outdated is GTA 5
#3.3.3 (Edited 280d ago ) | Agree(3) | Disagree(2) | Report
TheLaughingMan  +   280d ago
I agree I was so disappointed in it I never even finished it and I LOVE all the other GTAs
NastyLeftHook0  +   281d ago
Devil May Cry (looks like it will be, there is already gameplay...so yeah.)

Final Fantasy Series

Resident Evil Series
kent80082007  +   281d ago
Resident evil may not be a survival horror game like it used to be, but it's still a darn good action game.

Final fantasy on the other hand, I don't even know what it has become, a giant pile of turd is a generous description.
Booyah  +   281d ago
Final Fan... I mean they're dead ! Maybe Versus will b better -.-
ChunkyLover53  +   281d ago
No way does Halo Reach belong on a list with Duke Nukem Forever. I'd say Dragon Age 2, Brink, Homefront and Haze were probably much bigger disappointments in my opinion.
TheColbertinator  +   281d ago
Halo Reach is a great game.

Halo 3 ODST is a crime against nature.
Booyah  +   281d ago
Each their own, I played more ODST than Reach =p
bubblebeam  +   280d ago
@TheColbertinator

Does everyone dislike Halo 3 ODST? Or is it just trendy to say it, whether you have played it or not?

ODST had excellent storytelling, the best music out of all of the Halo games (which is saying a lot) and had tons of atmosphere (night time in new mombasa).

I think that Halo fans (I am A HUGE Halo fan) are just as dumb as the cliche of the FPS type person. It finally shakes things up, and to me, let me know once and for all that the fanbase are generally not interested in stories and are fairly stupid when compared to people who prefer other genres.

Fable 3 havn't even bothered with. I like how he mentions it changed things from the 2nd and made some things worse. That's exactly the feeling I got when playing the 2nd (played it for like less than 2 hours).

I think the Fable series is overrated, I loved the 1st one, but wasn't interested in the 2nd or 3rd. Not BAD games, just not that great.

Halo Reach was great. He (the author) is just a HALO 3 FANBOY (the worst fanboy there is, they live to kill another noob online, they take no prisoners, they love charging into another player with assault rifle then beating them down, whilst the exact same happens to them).

I personally thought Halo 3 online sucked BIG time.Reach's was great, some of the most fun I had. If I still had XBL gold, I might give it a shot again (over 30,000 kills). I think that HALO 3 fanboys (uuuugh) just cried when they changed the gameplay up and found out that they weren't top dog anymore. Bunch of sooks who are worse than cod fanboys.
#5.1.2 (Edited 280d ago ) | Agree(7) | Disagree(3) | Report
crzyjackbauer  +   280d ago
Halo Reach is THE best halo until now
Some fans just didn't like it because
there was no BR in it. thats all there is to it
i love the DMR and i am glad its back on Halo 4

ODST has way better story telling than halo 1,2 or 3
some halo fans didn't like it because it took away the feeling of being a spartan and it was more on stealth
BitbyDeath  +   281d ago
There's always one controversial title in lists to get extra hits, today it is reach.

I'm surprised they didn't make that the article image.
#5.2 (Edited 281d ago ) | Agree(11) | Disagree(2) | Report | Reply
Kin23g  +   280d ago
Dragon Age 2 was disappointing compared to DA: Origins. But it wasn't disappointing compared to other western RPGs .. I say that because I've finished it 3 times. DA:origins is 10/10 while DA2 is 9/10 IMHO.

I'd say Ninja Gaiden 3 is the most disappointing game in my book.
Tornadobounce  +   281d ago
Sniper elite v2, aliens vs predator, mass effect 3, mw3, crackdown 2
Bathyj  +   281d ago
I'd put the new Ghost Recon in there for sure.

Man was I bummed.
metsgaming  +   281d ago
although no one cares, i would put Ace Combat. Great franchise just completely and utterly ruined.
BitbyDeath  +   281d ago
I'd like to add Haze not cause of the game itself (i never played it) but the mere fact it killed Free Radical is a huge disappointment.

I want a new Timesplitters
one2thr  +   281d ago
Haze was awful, I tried my hardest to get through that game like this sent...en...ce........
blahblah346  +   281d ago
Resident Evil 5 and 6, FF13.
Mikefizzled  +   280d ago
Putting a game on thats not released is beyond ridiculous.
blahblah346  +   280d ago
Actually, not. It has a great potential to be a return to its roots. But Ca$hcom insists on making it Gears of Evil 6: Among Thieves.
MrAnderson  +   281d ago
duke nukem forever, final fantasy 13, no contest.
InTheLab  +   281d ago
Halo Reach...GTFO. Try MW2 and 3, and probably MW4 when that s*** comes out next year.
ape007  +   280d ago
i agree that Halo reach was awesome but i disagree with mw2, MW2 was the last great Call Of Duty game and as a COD die hard fan, i can safely say that MW3 was a huge a HUGE let down, yes the control and gameplay was identical to MW2 but the awesome level design, the atmosphere, the shock value, the trademark vintage original IW magic is lacking ion mw3, mw3 levels are so dull,cheap and boring, even the menues and soundtrack are worse
InTheLab  +   280d ago
I get all of that but MW2 signaled the beginning of the end.

Unbalanced weapons
dual wielding shotguns
dual wielding period
cheap attachments silenced sniper rifles?
Killstreaks adding to killstreaks which added to more killstreaks
massive glitches...day 1 game breaking glitches at that.
$15 map packs
recycled maps and assets
exclusive deal with MS

I don't know how anyone can look back on MW2 fondly, like almost all CoD fans can for CoD, CoD2, CoD4MW.
#12.1.1 (Edited 280d ago ) | Agree(4) | Disagree(1) | Report
sugadaddy  +   281d ago
How was Reach disappointing after the abortion that was ODST?

I suppose if you're on ODST-denier then maybe it was disappointing.
bubblebeam  +   280d ago
ODST denier? I thought other than 1, ODST was the best. A ten from me. People who disliked ODST are either part of the trend or are silly Halo 3 fanboys.
crawling182  +   281d ago
Only played Brink from the list, and yea it was a bit disappointing.
StreetsofRage  +   281d ago
Again, these kind of lists are always a head scratcher. Halo Reach? Fable 3? Worst this entire generation? LOL!
#15 (Edited 281d ago ) | Agree(7) | Disagree(6) | Report | Reply
TheRealHeisenberg  +   281d ago
Those games must be on the list just to get hits.
sugadaddy  +   281d ago
To be fair, the author did say "most disappointing" rather than "worst."

A game can still be pretty good yet disappointing when considered next to the rest of the franchise. It's more a matter of expectations rather than actual quality.
StreetsofRage  +   281d ago
Fair enough. I wouldn't go as far to say "most disappointing this entire gen" tho'

All personal opinions tho'
JellyJelly  +   281d ago
I thought Fable 3 was the best in the series. Very enjoyable title and the closest thing to a Zelda game on the 360.

Halo Reach didn't disappoint critics and didn't receive much bashing from gamers either, so I don't know what it's doing there.

I think Gran Turismo 5 would fit better in the list, with all the standard cars, missing damage modeling etc.
Booyah  +   281d ago
Don't put Zelda in there dude, Fable 1-2 were way better than the 3rd
turgore  +   281d ago
Crap list.
R_aVe_N  +   281d ago
There are so many I don't think I can name just 5 without offending the rest lol
Kingdom Come  +   281d ago
Halo Reach? Are you joking?
Tr10wn  +   281d ago
^ WTF? of all games Halo Reach? really? i can name 3 games that are worst than anything in that list Too Human, Haze and Sacred 2 top that.
taquito  +   281d ago
Diablo 3 is, by far, the best game of 2012 as of now, though there are a lot of great games coming soon

guild wars 2 will be effing amazing!
CLOUD1983  +   281d ago
My own TOP 5

Diablo 3
Final Fantasy XIII
Resident Evil 5 & 6
Silent Hill: Downpour
TERA

This generation the disappointment was huge, all my once favorite franchise except MGS have turn to a pile of poo, but I guess was expected as all the original creators (Blizzard North, Sagakuchi, Mikami, Team Silent) left.

The only one who stay was Kojima, the creator of the best PS3 exclusive, a MASTERPIECE that cost 60 million $ to make but it was for sure money well spent.
#20 (Edited 281d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(5) | Report | Reply
ape007  +   280d ago
i 100% agree, silent hell is no where near as good as the last gen, as well as FF, Resi5 was decent but no where near the magnificence that is Resident Evil 4
ape007  +   280d ago
also perefct dark zero is nowhere near PD64
kma2k  +   281d ago
Dragon Age II, Duke Nukom, Final Fantasy Xiii, Resistance 2, Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II, & Homefront.

I know im in the minority but i actually enjoyed both Brink & Fable III.

I had to look at my list to remember all the disapointments...yes i have a list, but my god hadnt looked in a while im at 153 games this gen & counting, thank you gamefly!
#21 (Edited 281d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
jagstatboy  +   280d ago
Resistance 2 does not belong with the other travesties you mentioned.
kma2k  +   280d ago
Oh im not saying it was bad, I was just personally disapointed in it. I loved the one man against the world aspect of R1 & felt R2 had capeli with you through virtually every turn. Again wasnt really bad i just really enjoyed taking on the whole camaren army alone. But disapointment is in each persons opinonin.
Klonopin  +   281d ago
RAGE
strummerdood  +   281d ago
Far and away, most disappointing for me was Skyrim.
Sizzon  +   281d ago
I disagree with Halo Reach.

For me: Diablo 3 (was looking forward to it so much, but came with no PVP and such), Dragon Age 2, Brink, Duke Nukem Forever and Modern Warfare 2.
#24 (Edited 281d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
tigertron  +   280d ago
My somewhat controversial list:

FFXIII - some annoying characters and was incredibly linear
RE5 - a copy and paste job from RE4 and a mediocre story
Resistance 2 - lacked the feeling of RFOM and was more COD-like
GTA IV - lacked the fun from San Andreas
Killzone 3 - based on its multiplayer
Uncharted 3 - based on its multiplayer and graphics downgrade
Stoppokingme  +   280d ago
perfect dark zero has to be up there somewhere, i don't know how RARE managed to screw that one up. The N64 version was one of the best games ever.
tigertron  +   280d ago
Yeah, that too. I bought it for a couple of pounds a few months ago and controlling Joanna felt like driving a tank.
jagstatboy  +   280d ago
RE5 for me.
jayman1  +   280d ago
1)Socom 4 ( still play it but could have been better),
2)haze, 3)lord of the rings Conquest (EA sunset the online?),4) Resistance 2 (no weapon wheel but still play it great game),5)Wolfensein (could have been alot better),
6)mercenaries 2 (no online multiplayer) 7) Army of two ( control scheme messy) 8) Burnout Paradise ( messy aproach did not like it)
Gigglefist  +   280d ago
Brink.
I was following that game since development
I couldn't be more excited.
Waited so long...
What a disappointment
Soldierone  +   280d ago
I'm surprised this list was actually good lol. I was expecting flame baiting with the Halo comment, but its a solid list with solid points.

Duke Nukem and APB are huge for me too. I was so hyped, telling everyone about them, then finally go put it in and was like...."ugh I better go hide in a hole for talking about this"
« 1 2 »

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories

Zombie Tycoon 2: Brainhov's Revenge | Digital Chumps Review

7m ago - Digital Chumps write: 'Zombie Tycoon 2: Brainhov’s Revenge is a zombie real-time-strategy game... | PS3
10°

Soul Sacrifice: Inafune’s latest is all about trade-offs | SnackBarGames Review

12m ago - SnackBarGames write: 'Soul Sacrifice does what few games do. It carries a theme, clings to it,... | PS Vita
10°

Zombie Tycoon 2: Brainhov's Revenge Review for PS Vita, PSN | Gaming Age

12m ago - Gaming Age writes: 'At first I thought I disliked Zombie Tycoon 2 because of its level of diff... | PS3
10°

The Last of Us Preview | spong

12m ago - spong writes: 'The Last of Us is not a survival horror, according to developer Naughty Dog. Bu... | PS3
Ad

Sanctum 2 (PC) Review

Now - Tower defense from a different perspective returns. Find out how the sequel fares in our full review. | Promoted post
10°

Call of Juarez: Gunslinger Review – PC | GCVGN

12m ago - GCVGN writes: 'Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood was one of my favorite FPS games of 2009, and th... | PC
Related content from friends