90°
Submitted by KenAdamsNSA 728d ago | opinion piece

How to Fix the Video Game Review System

Over the years, a few things have been omitted from the process of game reviews in favor of a more streamlined approach that is primarily focused on appealing to the lowest common denominator of gamer. Too often have we, as critics, felt satisfied with evaluating games from a shallow perspective without spending the time to dig deeper into the mechanics and theory behind the development of each title. It’s time we make a change. (EA, IGN, PC, PS3, Wii, Wii U, Xbox 360)

iamnsuperman  +   728d ago
It is really up to us to not have a hissy fit/buy games when they get a score of 7.5 or 8.
wallis  +   728d ago
I think yahtzee has the best score system - as in non-existent. A reviewer should be able to infer all the qualities of a numerical score in the content of the review, there's no need to reduce such a difficult and complicated medium to 8 or 9 out of 10. It's bizarre and exceptionally pointless. Critics should highlight the subjective nature of reviews and the importance of taking one person'a interpretations with a pinch of salt before removing the number system entirely.

No one ever complains abmiguity in yahtzee'a reviews because he uses phrases like "better than jesus" and "more fun than a triple c*nted hooker" - those words tell you everything you need to know without stamping a 9 on the game's cover.
PopRocks359  +   728d ago
It should not boil down to a numerical score. Players should actually READ the review to get an idea of how the game plays, not to have someone else's overall opinion dictate their own.
CouldHaveYelledUiiW  +   728d ago
I agree.

There has been many a time where I looked at the final score of a game, that I was looking forward to, and was discouraged in buying the game UNTIL I read the review and found out the reason why the score was so low.

If you own a Wii you understand to read the reviews because they can take points off for graphics.

Or if a particular game of a genre- tried a new control scheme (see KI:Uprising).

Or because the Hero(ine), who never talked before, is forced into a "Sexist" storyline.

You got to read why they take-off the points.
(Personally, I think IGN's is pretty decent; they even show Online Average and the average score of Consumers.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories

Neocore tease new game Deathtrap

6m ago - Forget Van Helsing 3 for a moment because Deathtrap is brewing at Neocore. | PC
40°

BioWare Releases Second Teaser For New Game

11m ago - Recently over the past few days, BioWare has released a teaser for what is most likely their new... | Dev
10°

The Swapper - PS4 Review | Chalgyr's Game Room

16m ago - Chalgyr's Game Room writes: The swapper at first glance looks like it might be some sort of an... | PS4
10°

Review: Wii Sports Club Baseball & Boxing (Pure Nintendo)

16m ago - Pure Nintendo: "Overall, I think the Baseball + Boxing Club Pass is worth a download even if it’s... | Wii U
Ad

Looking for a great Pokemon Community?

Now - Look no further. Join us at the BulbaGarden Forums, the best community for everything Pokemon | Promoted post
20°

The 10 Best (And 5 Worst) Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Video Games Ever Made

16m ago - There have been nearly 50 TMNT games, some cowabunga-worthy, some not so much so. | Retro