Try our new beta!Click here
90°
Submitted by KenAdamsNSA 1287d ago | opinion piece

How to Fix the Video Game Review System

Over the years, a few things have been omitted from the process of game reviews in favor of a more streamlined approach that is primarily focused on appealing to the lowest common denominator of gamer. Too often have we, as critics, felt satisfied with evaluating games from a shallow perspective without spending the time to dig deeper into the mechanics and theory behind the development of each title. It’s time we make a change. (EA, IGN, PC, PS3, Wii, Wii U, Xbox 360)

iamnsuperman  +   1287d ago
It is really up to us to not have a hissy fit/buy games when they get a score of 7.5 or 8.
wallis  +   1287d ago
I think yahtzee has the best score system - as in non-existent. A reviewer should be able to infer all the qualities of a numerical score in the content of the review, there's no need to reduce such a difficult and complicated medium to 8 or 9 out of 10. It's bizarre and exceptionally pointless. Critics should highlight the subjective nature of reviews and the importance of taking one person'a interpretations with a pinch of salt before removing the number system entirely.

No one ever complains abmiguity in yahtzee'a reviews because he uses phrases like "better than jesus" and "more fun than a triple c*nted hooker" - those words tell you everything you need to know without stamping a 9 on the game's cover.
PopRocks359  +   1286d ago
It should not boil down to a numerical score. Players should actually READ the review to get an idea of how the game plays, not to have someone else's overall opinion dictate their own.
CouldHaveYelledUiiW  +   1286d ago
I agree.

There has been many a time where I looked at the final score of a game, that I was looking forward to, and was discouraged in buying the game UNTIL I read the review and found out the reason why the score was so low.

If you own a Wii you understand to read the reviews because they can take points off for graphics.

Or if a particular game of a genre- tried a new control scheme (see KI:Uprising).

Or because the Hero(ine), who never talked before, is forced into a "Sexist" storyline.

You got to read why they take-off the points.
(Personally, I think IGN's is pretty decent; they even show Online Average and the average score of Consumers.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
40°

Unravel Review | AusGamers

23m ago - AusGamers has reviewed Unravel and writes: "It’s all well and good to attempt to tug at hearts... | PC
40°

[VC] Nuclear Throne - Teenage mutant post-apocalyptic fish

24m ago - Indie developers love making rogue-likes and twin stick shooters. Sometimes, they craft a hybrid... | PC
Ad

Guess N4G Game of the Year Winners, win a $300 Amazon Gift Card

Now - Also enter for a chance to win a gift card for writing a user blog, writing a user review, or being a top contributor for the month. | Promoted post
40°

Dinocide Review | Bit Cultures

1h ago - Coyle from Bit Cultures writes: "Dinocide is a true old-school platformer that pays homage to man... | PC
40°

Mario Party 5 - Impossible Gaming Vs Series Premiere

1h ago - You’ve witnessed Chadley and Tristan taking on some of history’s toughest video games in Impossib... | GameCube
40°

Dragon of Legends Kickstarter Cancelled, But Project Will Still Continue

1h ago - J Station X: Thrive Games announces that it is cancelling the Dragon of Legends Kickstarter campa... | PC